Sunday, May 19, 2013

Super Secret Sunday 19: Second Looks

Welcome back to Super Secret Sunday! The place and time where we discuss underplayed cards, under the radar strategies, and under-thought thoughts. Now we all know that your Ol' Grandpa Growth can get to talking. And sometimes when he gets to talking he can get pretty opinionated. Well now that Dragon's Maze has been around for a couple weeks and I have had a chance to play with the new cards I am gonna take a look back at the predictions I made in the set review and talk about some cards where my expectations were way off. That's right, we're talkin' about Grandpa's biggest screw-ups from Dragon's Maze!

Sire of Insanity So right off the bat we have to look at the Pro Tour decklists that showed up this weekend. This guy has been pulling big boy weight against every version of Esper deck in the field. Standard isn't exactly the same beast as Commander, but Sire shines even brighter in a multiplayer dominated format. I misread the role that this card can play in games. It isn't so much of a creature threat that you just want to play and attack with. The timing of this card is so critical. This is much trickier to operate than a Mind Twist, but when you hit them with it you already have a decent clock to back it up. The potential for card advantage is very high and skill testing cards in R/B are kind of rare. I like this in practice quite a bit more than I did in theory.


Crypt Incursion I called this as a big hit in the set review. I know the value of a Time Walk and I am also good as spotting one, even in a disguise this good. This card just looks so unassuming, but check the score! How much life do you need to swing the race? How many turns do you set your opponent back by gaining 12 or more life? All this and it still has the potential to trade for a card from your opponent and denies them resources in the late game. This is a huge beating. That is an understatement. I knew it was a huge beating. It is an indescribable beating.







Ætherling So back on the results from the Pro Tour: this card was the finisher du jour in a variety of Blue based control decks. The analogue that I have been able to draw with Commander is how often these Standard control decks hit big mana. They are built to maximize Sphinx's Revelation and frequently control 10+ lands. In these late game situations (which happen to come around a lot in Commander) Aetherling is very difficult to race. I underestimated this cards ability to play defense. In a grind fest, you can nug your opponent with the unblockable four damage, but then blink it and leave your mana to pump its toughness to near infinite levels allowing you to block basically any single threat your opponent has. I stand by my assessment of this card as a pure threat. It is slow and expensive. What I didn't catch on to is how easily this card turns into inevitability.


Deadbridge Chant I was extremely excited about this card when it was spoiled. My excitement got the better of me. I made comparisons to many very good cards. I was pretty far off the mark. This costs two more than it is really worth. You still get a basically random card, which isn't much better than just drawing a fresh card except in the smallest corner cases. This card is much easier to hate out than other card advantage outlets, for no real reason. That card advantage by the way, really isn't that great. You only ever get one extra card. Nothing special. Mind Unbound. Yawgmoth's Bargain. Phyrexian Arena. The comparisons are not as favorable as I once thought.

 Well there we go youngins. A dose of my own medicine and a helping of humble pie all in one. It's good to be back doing S^3. It has been on hiatus for quite a while. Do you think I got these cards right the second time around? Let me know in the comments.

-GG

Saturday, May 18, 2013

The Stack #9- Flavor Judges Say Wha---???

Well it's another shiny Saturday morning on your favorite Commander Blog, The General Zone, which means the gang and I are Stacking it up once more.

Per a suggestion, we've got flavor fouls on tap this week. So our thumbs will be more indicative of whether or not we believe these cards fit well into the dialogue of Magic's Story as well as the concept of being spellcasters locked in never-ending battles to see who can use their library better.

So put on your stripes, take out your whistles, your hanky-flags, or your red and yellow cards. It's time to decide where design and story don't meet.

Here's the way they stack.

VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Not that this card is a bad card (I love it, and it's one of the few Red cards to gain my respect), but something is seriously weird with the way this card works. First off, as a Red Defender, you'd think the power would be greater than its toughness (Wall of Torches) or you'd be able to pump it up (Wall of Fire), but no. It's a 0/5 with Reach (a typically green trait). Furthermore, it's a bounce house (Blue player scratches head, then scoops), which is great, but never in my life have I seen something this completely off-color (pun intended, with a vengeance).

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
No surprise that a card from Time Spiral shows up here, I listened to MaRo's podcast about it. In it he talked about how it has confused a lot of people by messing with the Color Pie in a way that has shaken the core of magic forever. I agree and this guy is one of those examples. "Aether" X is something that usually falls into Blue being a type of illusionary magic. I like this guy, a Defender with Reach that threatens to bounce the attacker back to it's owners' hand? Awesome.

Bounce is something I love to do in EDH, and it's just as annoying as tucking a creature into a library. Players will have to re-cast the creature then wait for summoning sickness to wear off again. Killing a creature is fine and all but I'd rather bounce them back and this guy is scary enough to save a kill spell for.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP AND DOWN
The Thumbs for this week will probably be all manners of different directions and for all kinds of reasons, and this is a pretty good example.

I'm not sure this is such a gross misuse of flavor, but that's alright. Being from Time Spiral, everything was up and down and all around, so it's no surprise that this guy's off the wall. Definitely not a Red card, but I'm sure it was supposed to be designed this way, and I like that a lot. While Damnation might feel more logical switching in the color pie, this card falls victim to some of the same flavor issues of a card like Brute Force in my opinion. It's not flavor-retarded, it's just surprising, and that's the point.  Being weird is one of the things that drew me to this card, and made me want to test it.

Unfortunately, this is where my Thumb goes down. I've played it, played against it, and that last ability basically makes your opponent either not want to attack into you, or even worse- influences your blocks in a way so that you don't send their Solemn Simulacrums back to their hand. I didn't like that a card on my side of the table was doing this to me, so I cut it. It's bad design, not bad flavor.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
This card pulls me in a lot of directions. It represents the worst of Planar Chaos' color pie chicanery: Pick a color, smash a bunch of stuff onto the card that the color shouldn't have, forget about drawbacks. Planar Chaos should have been about realligning the color pie in a way that made sense in the modern game. Unfortunately, most of the cards they color shifted didn't really live up to this.

Mechanically, I like it. Red has very little Reach and very little bounce. I don't think it is outside the realm of possibility to make these things work in Red. It just needs to elegantly combine mechanics and flavor. As far as flavor goes this is definitely a foul. Look at it. Why would any creature knowingly walk into that? It wouldn't stop any attackers. It looks like a drag net to catch thing out of the Aether and bring them IN to the plane. It also looks quite fragile, so 5 toughness probably isn't appropriate. We can't quite see the top of it, but unless it extends infinitely into the sky, it shouldn't have Reach.

GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
Quick recap: You're a multidimensional, super powerful wizard, who just met another person like yourself. All you can think about is murdering that person in a ritualistic duel using your spell-casting ability. Cards that you have in play and in your hand represent the territory you currently control, the minions who are currently at your side, and the spells you can cast off the top of your head. Your library is the figurative, not physical, collection of your accumulated knowledge. It contains all the spells that you know how to cast, all the minions and organizations you can control, and all of the territory you know about. Your graveyard is the figurative, not physical, collection of your expended resources and ideas that you have used in the battle so far. The physical corpses of minions that die during your battle are a part of this collection, but are presumably left on the battlefield where they died.

Now snap back to reality. This is a 'fetch land'. It let's you dig a land out of your library. What does that mean in the game? You have control over a physical piece of some random plane, in this case let's just say you have a Polluted Delta that is meant to represent a polluted delta on Otaria. Now, unlike most other lands, it doesn't have the ability to produce mana, it is effectively exhausted of all useful resources. BUT, you can pay some life, weakening your physical health or giving up part of your soul, in order to DESTROY the polluted delta here on Otaria and give you immediate, direct, physical control over another Island or Swamp that you previously knew about (and was thus in your library). So you break open a wormhole into another section of space/time and connect to the mana energy contained in that land. Pretty bad ass. The best part though: this doesn't involve casting a spell. Even though it does the same thing that many mana ramp spells do. Even though it essentially does the same thing as Polymorphing a creature. BULLSH---- //end flavor rant//

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
No fouls because unfortunately, there are no Worm Holes here.

I think the term fetch land is perhaps the biggest culprit of flavor misdirection. As GG mentions, Your library contains a collection of figurative knowledge and the territory you know about. If that's true, what exists here is a land you know about that will, upon giving a part of yourself, help you find other lands you are already aware of. Like marking trees in the woods, if you find a familiar spot, then you know you're going to the right place. In this way, it is both knowledge and territory, because it is knowledge of your own territory. Like having good spells, fetches allow good mages to get good footing for more consistent spellcasting.

If you can't see the woods for my tree-marking analogy, here's another way to look at it. Maybe the power of a fetch land is innate, and being the incredible mage that you are, You are now able to "transform" said land from being a Polluted Delta or Wooded Foothills into the mana you're looking for. Cause you're that good.

Either way, the flavor feels Kosher. It's not a spell, but lands and mana is always just as powerful and important as spells. I think that's the important thing to take away from this Flavor debate.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
I can't really find a flavor foul in this card, unless you're questioning the physics of how a polluted delta will bring you to an Island or a Swamp; but, even that question seems to have a reasonable answer. I get that its only use is to fetch land for a small price, but it can be the key to casting the right spell with the right combination of lands.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP (makes my wallet hurt though)
I understand GG's feelings with said card(s), it's in the same flavor of Evolving wilds and Terramorphic Expanse. The fact that you play a land to 'fetch' another land to color fix and deck thin can be advantageous in play. We play with 99 cards and fetch lands make me wanna sing "I got 99 problems but basic land ain't one".

Moving away from practical use,I agree the flavor is a bit off. Using Grandpa's imagery we're looking for the mana to chuck some fire in my enemies face but I'm a little short so I'd have to dig deeper into my connections to make the spell fly. LD also brings a solid point to the table, Universes you've been to and draw from should be of the strongest bonds for your spells. In the end it's not a total flavor foul, its just weird- weird and overpriced haha.

JOHNNY CONFIDANT'S PICK

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS DOWN
Phyrexians are all about fusing machine to flesh to manipulate the world to their liking. Sacrificing a creature to destroy an artifact with a Black enchantment is confusing. Red and Green are known for artifact destruction in flavor of returning to nature and Black has a hard time destroying artifacts and enchantments, so when this came out in Antiquities it gave Black an answer it has never gained again.

Granted this was still in the early years of Magic. I would've expected this to have shown up in Time Spiral, but alas even messing with the Core of Magic still didn't give Black artifact destruction.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS... WHA???
Johnny is most correct in saying this card has a flavor foul. Black artifact destruction is pretty much never going to be a strategy, since our Gruul friends have that base covered pretty well. The only thing more confusing than the premise of this card is the "You may not sacrifice a creature that is already on its way to the graveyard." Do they have a funeral procession phase in MTG? 

Uncle Landdrops-THUMBS DOWN
I don't get how this is a gate. Am I paying a Troll Toll to go Phyrexia? If so, why would I do this? And why would this only happen at the beginning of my turn? Why can't I go to Phyrexia whenever I want to kill one of my guys? And look at this flavor text. Why is it raining grease? And why do so many Magic characters have diaries? What if I don't want to read your personal thoughts? Why does Wizards think these entries are important? And why are you giving them copies? This flavor fouling gets no sympathy from me, and basically makes me not want to play this card ever.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
I don't see any reason why Black shouldn't have artifact/enchantment removal. Corruption can hit flesh and metal alike. I once saw a fan made card that was just a Disenchant, except Black instead of White. It was called Disillusion, which makes sense to me. It's a sort of dream crushing kind of evil that Black would do. Not in the name of purity like White, or Nature in Green, but in the name of spreading grief.

Gate to Phyrexia doesn't make no kinda sense. Ignore the bit about it being a gate...because it really isn't. It is a machine that eats people to blow up stuff. Phyrexia is all about KILLING YOUR PEOPLE to BUILD THEIR MACHINES. So this is backwards...and upside down. And wrong. I forgive Wizards though. This was printed at the very beginning of flavor being a thing and, at that time, the color pie wasn't quite nailed down.

UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS DOWN
Will I play this card? Yes. I have a copy coming, but like Teysa's god-awful design, I'm still left confused.

The Obzedat has little or nothing to do with said permanent's resurrection. I get aristocracy, so maybe they said, "Make it so," but they're still not actually responsible. Had R&D called it "Blessed by the Obzedat" I'd feel better.

According to the picture, it is in fact "Obzedat's Aids" who are doing the work. So the card should be called, "Obzedat's Aids' Aid," but I get that this is both confusing and insensitive towards Acquired-ImmunoDeficiency-Syndrome. Overall though, Art's cool, Aristocracy's confusing, and new Teysa sucks. Flavor's bitter for me.


Venser's Journalist- NOT SURE
Sure the whole immortality thing is a big part of Orzhov strategy, but I'm not too thrilled about paying 3WB for a rare that does only one trick, and a mediocre one at that. There is merit in it though: planeswalkers are tough to revive once they've lost all loyalty, but this will bring your Sorin back for sure. Unless you're one of the rich-boys playing Crucible, lands are mighty hard to retrieve, but this will do it (although if you're using this card on a land, you might have bigger problems).

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
I'm excited for this card, but not for its cost. For 5 I'd rather use a Black or White spell for my permanents back, but this makes for a great late game finisher. As for flavor, all colors have a way of getting something back from the graveyard and combining white with Black can give you permanents with respective restrictions. So why not anything permanent with no restrictions when you pay both? It makes sense to me in flavor, but UL is right about Obzedat, they work in the background.


Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
My co-pilots here have gotten off course. This makes perfect sense mechanically, but UL is right. It doesn't do what the card says it does. Or rather, it isn't being done by who it says is doing it. Phew, that was a mouthful. Also, we have a cross-card flavor error here. If the Obzedat can bring stuff back to life, why can't its card bring stuff back to life? Also, the Orzhov are all about Extortion these days. Their aid should be free to begin with, but then come with a grotesquely high interest rate. What's that? Flavor reversal? Bringing people back to life in order for them to continue paying off their debts is how the Obzedat COLLECTS. This isn't aid. FEMA is aid (or it's supposed to be). This is foreclosure. Obzedat's Foreclosure.

That's all we got.

Now Go See Star Trek Or Iron Man 3. One of them has to be decent, right?

-UL

Thursday, May 16, 2013

Top's down // Bottoms up : Budget Utility Pt.1

It's Thursday again and that means that Johnny C is back from the clutches of the Undercity with a new Top's Down // Bottoms Up piece.

This week I've searched through my playgroups hidden gems to bring you some cheap utility that will hopefully enhance your EDH experience.

So why Budget? Budget cards are for the new and old players alike. Building a new deck is a process that gets better the more you do it, and card choice is key in focusing your deck. You don't always need the biggest, shiniest and most expensive cards to close a game. Sometimes there's treasure in those dollar rare boxes in card shops, so lets take a look at what I have seen and used from this hidden treasure cove.

20$ whole Dollars! Thanks Mister!


~Artifacts~

- Mizzium Transreliquat - Guildpact - This is Copy Artifact or Sculpting Steel on crack, possibly even better. There is always a good artifact or artifact creature hanging around the field, and this guy makes good use of both. For any color you can borrow for a turn, or Red/Blue and one to gain it permanently with options to copy again.

Most of the time you'll want to mainly use the second ability but that doesn't mean the first one is irrelevant. Temporary use of effects may be to your advantage because they're less mana intensive, or you just need something for a specific trigger. Cause it's awesome when you borrow an Eldrazi Monument to block or board wipe. 




- Mimic Vat - Scars of Mirrodin - I'm sure that this little gem has found its way at a table near you. If not, you've missed out. Having an imprinted ETB monster or your opponent's monster can lead to some interesting game-play.  When a creature dies you may imprint it (exile under) unto the artifact then make copies of it for 3.

For token generation decks, or those with Parallel Lives and/or Doubling Season this can go a long way. Making more tokens of ETB badass Avenger of Zendikar? Want  more use out of Evoke creatures like Mulldrifter or Reveillark? This card makes it happen. We can also utilize Populate from Return to Ravnica block and gain the token produced permanently.

Mimic Vat also has a interesting interaction with Commanders themselves. sure you can imprint a General unto it (Most likely will be yours) but if Mimic Vat gets destroyed that general is out of the game COMPLETELY.

- Illusionist's Bracers - Gatecrash - When this card was spoiled i was very excited. Before this there was the lonely old Rings of Brighthearth. While the Bracers won't get you infinite mana, or copy planeswalker abilities, it can still be pretty fun.

Plenty of Generals can make use of this card but who would benefit the most from it? Rhys the Redeemed and his token doubling effect now quadruples your guys. Mayael the Anima digs 2 creatures 5 or greater out now. Double your creature fling with Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord? The list can continue but those are some of the many good use's for this 2 cmc equipment.

In my opinion, this is probably one of the most overlooked cards. Sure you can go for the any ability Rings, but I dare you to spend a buck on this and not have a good time.

- Nim Deathmantle - Scars of Mirrodin - This odd little equipment can serve as a lifeline for your best hitter,
or your voltron general for 4. Having a strategic piece on the field usually inspires your opponent into tossing the metaphorical monkey wrench into your engine. Having a card like this can help prevent such downfalls as watching your well build voltron loose all its equipment then get blown up.

Using this in a Non-voltron style deck is also possible. Many players are fans of reanimation and since this card brings it from your graveyard instead of a pseudo-regeneration effect you can gain lovely ETB (Enter The Battlefield) effects once again.

A strong way of utilizing this effect could be with your Undying creatures or in combination with Mikaeus, the Unhallowed. After you've gained the bonus from the undying you can pay 4, and restart the process over again with +2 and Intimidate! Awesome!

~Creatures~

- Reaper from the Abyss - Innistrad - Morbid is a fun mechanic. People are all about the Grave Pact, and I am one of them. If I lost something someone else should lose something. It's childish I know but they still get to choose whom they sacrifice.

With this guy they have no choice, they lose what I want them to. Reaper even goes a step further by being able to trigger at each end phase no matter who lost a creature.

My only problem with this card is the limiting factor of what type i can destroy, granted its a small creature type but sometimes its a demon that's wrecking my life total, Looking at you Kaalia players- put Rakdos away! jk


- Odric, Master Tactician - M13 -
The foreshadowed embodiment of the Battalion mechanic that works so well with Boros in standard these days. While getting three creatures to go along with Odric sounds easy, it's making sure that the three can actually do some damage. Having control over the declare blockers phase is HUGE in EDH, you could take out someones pretty Oracle of Mul Daya that is just sitting alone causing all those tempo problems.

Personally I tried out a Mono white token deck with this guy as the general and I was amazed. with just a small group of 1/1's and 2/2's I was wrecking utility creatures, using Odrics' First Strike to take out the heavy hitters or even some Commanders, and picking away at my opponents without much of a sweat. The main problem that the deck had was due to my high reliance on Odric, once he was gone I lost.

Using this guy as a good utility creature can benefit token generation decks like Ghave, Guru of Spores giving you some major control of end phase shenanigans.

- Ulvenwald Tracker - Avacyn Restored - nicknamed "Fight!" - Having selective battle between two creatures especially if they have protection from a color, deathtouch, Indestructibility, or damage modifiers can be a beating. These benefits can make quick work of utility bench sitters that provide helpful/harmful effects just by existing while giving Sad Robot something to smile about.

Control players love having static effects on creatures that prevent spells from being cast on their turn, or at all. Our little human here can make Teferi and Grand Abolisher no more with '1G' and if you read GG's Dragons Maze three part article, you know the value of '1G'.

Looking at the "Fight" mechanic, It is another strong creature removal for green which was lacking. If you're thinking of Mono-green decks I recommend you look at this mechanic or even better, this creature for your removal or evasion plays because you can do this to a creature being blocked so your beasty gets through unblocked!

- Deadeye Navigator - Avacyn Restored - nicknamed "Shenanigans"- The list of what this guy can do is longer than what he CAN'T DO and for good reason. Creatures that enter the battlefield love him, creatures that need protection love him, and your opponents love to hate him. He is everything to everyone. I wished he was legendary so I could make him my general and do horrible things with him.

6 cmc for a 5/5 is normal for a Blue creature but with the ability he is under-costed for the position he takes on the field. Not horribly under-costed but i'd say just enough for shenanigans to make an impact. Playing this guy at the right time can create the perfect opportunity for a win con, but be careful. Once people know his tricks they tend to save a spell for him.

Something about the "Flicker" ability that people may not realize is that you can get rid of Deadeye fairly easily if you know when to strike. After someone exiles him, when he re-enters the battlefield, you can use a kill spell on him before he has a chance to soulbind to another creature or watching their mana base and see if they get a bit overzealous with him.

Well that does it for this week. Join me next week when I bring you more budget goodies with the other 4 types, Enchantments, Instant, Sorcery, and Land. Till then pilfer the dollar rare box and let me know what's hidden there!

-Johnny Confidant


Tuesday, May 14, 2013

UL's Favorites: Some Really Funky Black Guys (and Girls)


Tuesday's rolled around once again, and it's time to for me to finish my lists.

So rather than bore you with any nonsense, I'm gonna shut up and play the funky music.



Here's my top 10 favorite Black creatures.

10. Butcher of Malakir
Probably no surprises. I think people know how good this guy is. A Dude with a Grave Pact.

Having a 5/4 Flyer is actually good too. It affords you the opportunity of getting a huge removal spell in multiplayer, as well as a way to beat down and make your opponents think twice about blocking. Second guessing leads to mistakes. Mistakes lead to losses. Their losses lead to your victory.

At least, that's what Yoda tells me. Then again he also said "Hard to see the Dark Side is." So what is it Yoda? Amirite?




                                                                                                9. Bloodgift Demon

BGD is a neat little card. He scales nicely with your plans, adding hopefully to the additional card you're probably already drawing with Phyrexian Arena. Having a 5/4 flyer can also be relevant if you need to chump block.

And having a 5/4 flyer that looks like Hellboy with wings and a raised golden chalice, presumably filled to the brim with Blood, is... kinda like looking at an unsettling picture of Demon Communion? I don't know where I was going with this. It's just art. The colors really pop in this one, and I think that's why I I like it.

One of the cool tricks that I haven't felt good about doing yet is pinging other people with the ability. Mostly, cause I don't want them drawing cards. But I've got him in this Kaervek deck where I can stack additional damage effects on for drawing said card.

8. Graveborn Muse
Original Gravy is an O.G. (The other Gravy being Gravy T, rolling with Zombs). Again, scales nicely with Phyrexian Arena. I've only had one rare circumstance where I was able to play Arena, Gravy, and BGD Turns 3-5. It's kinda like hitting the jackpot, and I love to revel in the small victories when I get to draw lots o' cards.

Do remember though that OG can be ballsy, particularly in Zombie tribal. The more dudes you put out, the more damage and cards you draw. It's not the worst, but it could be. I always forget about Army of the Damned.

Also, it's a spirit. So if you're going Spirit Tribal, you now have an extra card draw outlet if you're trying to stay faithful to that.



                                                                                                7. Sepulchral Primordial
Seppy Prime's one of the new additions to the gang, so I don't have much experience with it quite yet, but I do like what it does.

Fear- I mean, Intimidate- seems relevant, and again, we get to make as many players pay as we want.

I've seen this card get so much value in multiplayer. In most of the games I play in black, it essentially becomes a contest to see how many times I can play Solemn Simulacrum. My opponents have followed suit, and most of them actually love playing this guy to get my Solemn Simulacrum. So the fun never ends, and we all get a shot at winning, because as a joke, we say that the person who casts Solemn Simulacrum the most is totally who should win the game.


6. Crypt Ghast
Like Seppy, I pre-ordered this card in Gatecrash cause I had a feeling it was going to be good. Boy was I on the money. It's been the Extraplanar Lens I needed, and as an added bonus, I get to trigger Extort. Oh, and I don't lose a land.

The art isn't much to write home about, but it's good to have expectations met. I really do like the shading and the transparency that's near the bottom of his shape. See also the moving masks. No idea what the flavor is, but it doesn't matter to me- this creep can roll, man.

Again, this is another great addition to mono-Black spirit tribal. See if you can make a better Infernal Kirin EDH than the one I scrapped a few weeks ago. Just don't forget Wicked Effing Akuba. Or you'll be sorry.


                                                                                               5. Coffin Queen
Koffing Queen Alter to follow.
This is actually a card that I don't have a lot of experience with, but I want to get to know her. Like Preacher, which I mentioned a few weeks ago, I plan on playing this card in the near future, possibly in a deck where I can abuse other activated abilities so I can play Illusionist's Bracers and get mega value.

I currently have her slotted in my Lazav Sewer Protection deck, predicated on getting some mill, some laughs, and a few copies of dudes from other people's bins.

I really like this art too. Really good fun Vintage Magic art. She looks like a super villain.




4. Necroskitter

I've talked up this card a lot, and I think it's a gem. I know other people do. I mean, there's gotta be a reason he's still 5 bucks, right?

I ended up not making the Skeleton Ship deck that I wanted to cause it didn't feel too inspired, but I plan on crafting a deck with some -1/-1 counters in the future, and I definitely have a spot for Mr. Skitter here in a future design.

I feel like this card is a pretty flavorful masterpiece top-to-bottom. From his spiny attributes to his spidery legs, even his P and T, which is pretty uncommon for a black creature. I like how all of this stuff seems to match up really well, and it's one of the reasons I'm looking forward to playing this card.

                                                                                                3. Braids, Cabal Minion

Since she's banned as a General, I figured we could talk about Braids here, cause she is a card I play a lot.

It's nice having recurrable removal to slow people down in multiplayer. Even in 1v1 she's pretty good. I've found her to be very useful in just about every black deck she's ever been in.

In decks with a bunch of other hate bears, she can really shine by stacking sacrifice triggers onto each other. I had an old Ghost Council 1.0 deck that was trying to accomplish this. Her plus Hokori or World Queller really wreak some havoc.

One of my favorite ploys is to sac her to her own upkeep trigger and reanimate again. It's fun when they think they're safe, but they aren't. Having her on a Mimic Vat to activate on their upkeep is pretty cool too. Especially in 1v1.

Just don't look into her eyes too long Zoners. She's got the crazy eyes. Queue Twilight Zone-Looking clip from CBS's hit show, How I Met Your Mother.


2. Midnight Banshee
As far as mono-Black is concerned, I think Banshee is pretty incredible. It's a token hoser, and a decent 5/5 attacker that's going to shrink a Titan at its worst.

Unfortunately, I think people see "nonblack" and like Doom Blade, they get scared. Though this text can sometimes be hard to play around, especially if your opponent plays black, I still find her more useful than not.

Again, another Spirit to treasure from the sadly unsuccessful Infernal Kirin deck.

The art's still pretty sweet though. Really nice and unsettling.




                                                                                                1. Skinrender

I'm fairly sure I speak for GG too when I say that this card is awesome. He's basically right at the beginning of relevant curves in black, and he allows you to get rid of anything that will probably come before, like a Gaddock Teeg or a pesky Merfolk Looter (though it's probably too late on the Looter. They've drawn cards, and you've lost the game.).

I love the art, I love what he does. He's just been a great little pet card.

He fits well into Zombie tribal too, which is a pretty common thing, though I wish they'd given him his actual creature type, which is Predator. That's what I call him anyway, despite Skinrender being a sweet name for a card in its own right. He's like the world's most violent-sounding Decepticon.

We got great stuff this week from the TGZ team, so make sure you keep yourself above water as we talk budget cards and flavor fouls this week. 

Til then, keep Starscream in check, Megatron from turning into a gun (cause it's stupid), and even if all else fails, promise me you won't shove it in Optimus' chest.

Keep your Matrix of Leadership. Don't be an Awk-timus Prime.
-UL

Saturday, May 11, 2013

The Stack #8- The One Where We Restore A Guildpact

Last week on The Stack, the hate was in full swing, and afterwards, you could've probably seen me doing something to Control Magic metaphorically comparable to this iconic Yu-Gi-Oh! scene.


And the answer is no- I don't mind pulling a "Weevil" and throwing cards emphatically into the ocean. Especially if they're ones recommended and passed on by "Grandpa." Yes, I mean the relevant, legal target, Old Man Growth. Truth be told, this next vid is probably a more accurate representation of how I'd do it.


This week, however, we're all cool as cukes. In fact, we're so calm, that it seems when we picked our favorites from Dragon's Maze no one actually put up a fight. Let's just hope the government is testing out something in the air that will result in us turning into Reavers and we'll end up wiping out everything beyond the Central Planets. Yeah, that was for you, Firefly fans. If you don't know what I'm talking about, well, there's a YouTube video for that.



Fortunately, all they've done is a few random tests with some sexy-new zombifying drug we now call Bath Salts.
NOTE: Eating people is very comparable to what Reavers do.
Thank God we've caught these psychos before they
started wearing our skin as clothing though.
Mine wouldn't be too fashionable.
Anyway, the picks this week were unanimously accepted amongst the four of us. So, we don't have to run no stupid Maze. Guildpact solved! We can all go home! Hidden clues in Guildgate Flavor Text Be Damned! (Google this if you didn't figure it out. I can't post all the videos and relevant information for you, even though I try anyway.)

So if you're looking for us to "hit ourselves as hard as we can," you'll have to wait til next week. Here are our picks anyway, so you can get to blowing up the format with all the obvious goodies that Dragon's Maze brought us.

VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK
Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
Essentially a Time Stop for three and that's just swell by me. I am a fan of counter spells and this one is my second favorite, second to Countersquall. Esper control will hug this card till the game ends.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP (NATURALLY)
This has got to be my favorite counterspell ever, because it not only shuts down the countered spell, but renders the rest of your opponent's turn, well, silent. I also love playing Standard, so the fact that I can put Silence-effects in a standard deck makes me squeal with joy.






Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
VJ nailed it. This card is the business. Powerful. Elegant. Simple. Nostalgic. This is the kind of card that makes me want to keep playing Magic.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Good card is good, I'm just not calling it the "bee's knees." To me, this is part of what is gonna make playing Lavinia more than sadistic. Cause it's not like she had little baby toys. There's real stuff in U/W, and they just seem to be getting an upgrade while other colors stay relatively inferior. Good news is the spell's still got to resolve, so my advice is to dig out Spell Pierce and Dispel and remind your Azorius friend that David still slays Goliath. Or, if you want to get real cute, remind them carefully of what Silence actually looks like.

JOHNNY CONFIDANT'S PICK
Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP!
I'm already looking at my Karador, Ghost Chieftain deck for potential slots. Ten cards from your library or not, the fact that if it's non-creature I still get something out of it. It's a risky card granted but since I reanimate fairly well the risk will more than likely pay off. Can't wait to get my hands on one, FOILED!

Uncle Landdrops- TWO THUMBS UP
Can't wait for this one either. It's an enchantment with some really innovative design, and I love recurring stuff. I've got one copy on the pre-order, and two decks it could go into. Wherever it goes, I know my playgroup will definitely start packing more Naturalize. They're gonna need it.

Venser's Journalist- NOT SURE
I was never big into the whole graveborn/graveyard retrieval, but it seems to work in theory. Based on what I've seen from other graveyard decks, this card might not be entirely worth the 6 mana it takes to cast. Granted you get to fill your graveyard with things and stuff, the "choose a card at random" isn't really the most effective way to pick at your graveyard.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
Super sick. I like extra cards and I am willing to pay for them This card isn't much of a risk because you are essentially guaranteed to get your card back. Either they use a card to blow it up or you start the value engine and get off to the races. This is a funny card. The random selection is kind of a bummer and 6 is a lot to pay for an extra card a turn, but the chance of putting a dude back in play is a fun mechanic and worth the price. I especially dig that there is no weird restriction on putting things back into your graveyard like Yawgmoth's Agenda.


GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
 
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I love pauper. I play a bunch of it. I have a pauper cube; it is my favorite format. This block has been great for pauper: Common dual lands, Bloodrush, great new multicolored cards in under-represented color combos. Now this? I am WET....and covered in water.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
The Creature version of Saving Grasp. Some scoff at "save your creature" spells like this but would you want to be at the wrong end of your General or worse, having your leader "tucked". He's tribal, instant-speed and cost approved. I want to see more commons like this, How bout some Blue/Green's? XD

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
This card is very similar to Whitemane Lion, save for the U in his mana cost. Both cards are great and work very well as protectors from boardwipes; this guy's one of the few ways of saving your general from a Supreme Verdict.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
An interesting pick here. Like VJ said, we've all kinda seen and played this guy before if you've seen Mr. Lion, so I'm not ready to set myself on fire about this card, but for being a common, this is fairly nuts. Too bad I can't rock U/W like VJ can.


UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK

The Red Hot Chili Peppers Movie Cast:
Flea, played by Man U's Wayne Rooney
Chad Smith, played by Will Ferrell
Anthony Kiedis, played by Notion Thief
SIGN. ME. DAFUQ. UP.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
This, Plasm Capture, Progenitor Mimic, and the two big Golgari cards round out my Top 5. So this pick wasn't easy.

But I had a Notion, and the only prescription for it was--
Whoops. I ruined it. Well, you get where I was going.
MOAR CARD DRAW!
I had to go with one of my favorite nonsensical frontmen, Mr. Anthony Kiedis. He's quite the spicy Chili Pepper, and I've got big plans for him in this new Lazav deck I just finished. So he'll perhaps be the most immediately useful in a deck where I'm trying to play a bunch of Windfall-style effects to get people to bin their things. You discard your hand, I draw your cards, and mine? Yeah. This isn't fair. Howling Mine and Font of Mythos are a little less nice now, and that's okay. I'm sure the birds will share their lonely view with you when you snap lose to the insane tempo and draw power this card has.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
I'll allow you to play your Consecrated Sphinx and pass turn, During my upkeep I'll flash this guy in and squeal with joy as I sit and enjoy the benefits of your 6cmc bad decision. I'm happy to finally see a strong Dimir card for EDH that effects so many card advantage spells and permanents out there. Rhystic Study? thanks. Mind's Eye? Bet you'd like to use that. Phyrexian Arena? Awww you shouldn't have :)

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
He's a mean, sneaky bastard that other Blue decks will come to rue, especially if combined with Kami of the Crescent Moon. Flash makes him a great response to Mind Springs and Sphinx's Revs. The 3/1 power/toughness, however, leaves a bad feeling in my stomach though, since once he's out, it takes only a ping to excecute this thief.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
This is a decent counter spell variant. I stand by what I said in my set review. 3 to 4 is a big difference; a difference that will stop this card from seeing mainstream play. I expect this card to go on the radar immediately. People will see it, become aware of it, and begin to play around it. Also, if your plan for victory revolved around you resolving a huge Mind Spring, you pretty much deserve to lose. Leave Counter back up. When in doubt: leave counter backup backup. Just don't fall victim to this guy.

Hopefully though, you've already fallen victim to the patterns that come at the end of every Stack.

So once again, be sure to check out GG on Sunday with a nice little In General piece called, "Things Magic Players Say." It's a good 'un, so don't miss out.

Barring some serious emergency, or a VJ article, I'll probably be around on Tuesday doing something relevant. Maybe I'll make good on that Repay In Kind article I keep putting off. I'm not sure. I've got a lot of different things to choose from, now that I'm not mouthing off most of the week.

And JohnnyCon will be serving up some sweet budget Tech this Thursday, so don't miss your chance to find out about some nice cards that won't make you overdraft the rent check.

Till then, promise me you won't do Bath Salts, rescue your crazy sister named River from the clutches of the Alliance, or get on a ship named Serenity without me.

Cause you can't take the sky from me. And by the sky, I mean Inara.
-UL

Thursday, May 9, 2013

In General: Things Magic Players Say

Hey there Zoners! Grandpa Growth here.

I love Matt Sperling's articles on CFB. Combined, Rule of Law and Sperling's Sick-of-it are two of my favorite Magic columns. I agree with about 95% of what he says.

I also love (Social) Contract From Below on Commander Cast. By contrast, I agree with approximately 0% of what Nole Clausen says. I respect him. I respect his content. As far as critics of the game though, we couldn't be further apart. It makes some of my disagreements with old Uncle Landdrops look seamless by comparison.

The common thread between these columns is that they are discussions not of the game of Magic, but of the culture of Magic. Important, under-represented work. Today, I am going to take a page out of their playbook and talk a bit about that culture. In my typical shameless fashion, I am also stealing a page out of Youtube's play book. Surely you have seen this video or others like it. Probably even a few about Magic.


I am going to go through a list of the 10 things that I hear all the time from Magic players that I absolutely cannot stand. I will explain why they are offensive/ignorant/meaningless/make no sense/are overused/or just mean something totally different.

If you didn't like my cultural diatribe on scrub players in Magic, turn your eyes away now. This one might hurt a bit. Before we go too far though, I am guilty of 100% of these. Am I a hypocrite? Nope, I'm human. We can work together to improve our communication, our experiences, and our shared game.

"I am a timmy/johnny/spike"
I find it a bit alarming how misunderstood the player psychographs are. If you haven't read the articles by Mark Rosewater, the creator and original authority on what the psychographs are and what they represent then please go resolve that issue. These aren't people. They are ideas. They are sub-human sections of your psychology. You are person. You can't be, in sum, something that is only a part of you. Mathematics says it isn't possible. Now, these people might mean, "I have more fun with Timmy cards than I do with Johnny cards." I am not going to guess at what motivates you, but it is important to remember that everyone enjoys winning, everyone enjoys feeling, everyone enjoys solution. We as humans are evolved to appreciate all of these things intuitively. That is what creates resonance.

"I am a control/aggro/combo player"
A related misconception to what I discussed above, but with higher implications. Magic has many formats, each with a metagame. Your job as a player is to win the game you are in. Sometimes that means doing whatever is necessary. Sometimes that means making do with what you have. This is what gives Commander a bad wrap outside of its own community. Many players are only interested in games where you ignore conventional strategy or archetypes. Disruption and counterspells are frowned upon. Threats are oversized and glacially slow. Infinite combos and instant kills are ostracized. I am not an 'aggro player', but I never miss an opportunity to attack safely and I strive to play my combat phase perfectly. I am not a 'combo player', but all of my decks employ strategic synergy and the cards are selected to work together effectively. I am not a 'control player', but I employ cadres of disruption and removal. Be a player, not a pigeon hole.

"I am a [color] player."
This is almost the exact same as the archetype pigeon hole, but even worse if possible. Lot's of times when people say this, they aren't just implying that they favor particular mechanics or strategies, but that they personally identify with some flavor or story aspect of the game.  That is weird to me, but I sort of get it. If you only want to play with your Elf Tribal deck, okay. I don't see why you want to do that in Magic, a game that actively punishes self-imposed restrictions. Games like Warhammer are focused more for this demographic. It mechanically unites your army with that army's flavor. There are very good reasons why Magic DOES NOT do this. You don't have to jam the square peg into the round hole all the time. Just play the format where your favorite deck is good. Like mono Red? Cube it up. Tribal decks? Elves, Goblins, and Merfolk are all Legacy decks that are viable and have been good at some point. Mono Red isn't a thing in Commander. Don't beat your head against the wall. Get outside of your comfort zone people.

That all being said, Star Mono Battle is one of my favorite formats.

"This card is good/bad."
I personally do this all the time. It usually sounds like 'reediculous' or 'bananas'. What gets left out of these commentaries is the context. Jace, the Mind Sculptor is a good card. Turns out it is good in every format, so that is one exception. Black Lotus, also a spicy one. For most cards, though, where it is good is just as important as how good it is. Tarmogoyf is a beatdown in Modern and Legacy, but not really that scary in EDH. I am more scared of Eight-and-a-half-Tails, a card that is irrelevant in basically every other format. The point I am driving at here is that when you say something like this, be a good chap and include where exactly you expect it to do all of its good work or better yet: just say you personally like it instead.

"Why are you targeting me?"
The short answer is: I'm not. I am playing the game with the intention of winning. My strategy is designed such that, to the best of my ability, it maximizes my chances of winning. I don't have personal feelings in the game. I leave my life outside and my game on the table. Be an adult; not everything is personal. It is even worse to me when people will apologize to me for 'targeting' me. It's just plain silly. We played a game. We both did what we could in order to win. That's the point. No ego, no offense, nothing to be sorry about.

"Card X is for multiplayer"
I have talked about this before, but I am not a big fan of multiplayer. I don't mind politics. I don't mind a bigger challenge in reading the board and projecting my opponents cards in hand. I don't mind games that go long (although I would rather play more games than longer games), but I do expect a reasonable pace of play. My disagreement with multiplayer is how the cards are designed. The vast majority of cards are made with the intention of filling specific roles in a 1v1 block Limited environment. Meaning that most of the mechanics don't necessarily translate all that well to multiplayer. I mean game mechanics, not just card mechanics. First Strike isn't much crazier in 1v1 than it is in a team game, but things like targeted vs mass removal, shuffling, disruption. Adding more players fundamentally alters these variables. It skews the core principles within the game: cost/effect ratio, board complexity, time (imagine if every player has a Sensei's Divining Top). Every once in a while R&D will show up with a card or mechanic that is 'specifically designed' for multiplayer, but the generalization of casual formats is a big problem. Not even the professionals at Wizards can make cards that are equally fun/fair/powerful/properly costed/universally understandable in every format.

"X is cheap/unfun/mean"
Removal. Hand disruption. Counterspells. Combos. *gasp* Land Destruction. These are the pieces of the game. The pawns and the rooks and the knights if you will. They are tools. You use them to achieve the goal of victory. How do you beat aggro decks? Kill their creatures. Does that make removal cheap? Poor carpenters blame their tools right? If you are being beaten by a 'cheap' strategy, you are a scrub and you don't understand the game. Every strategy has exploitable weaknesses. Take advantage of those holes in your opponents plans. It is childish and unnecessary to be upset at people for not playing by your self imposed rules. 

"Spirit of the format"
There is no such thing. There is no spirit of Standard. There is no spirit of Legacy. There are rules. There is a metagame. That is all. Why do I not believe in the spirit of the format idea? Why don't I want to idealize my format to match the superimposed definition of ultimate fun created by the Rules Committee? Because no one can agree (or concisely explain) what that is. If you put three people in a room, you will have six opinions. Some of them might even be correct, but games need a more objective authority than the whims of the few. Failing that they should have as few subjective criteria as possible.


"If I had known..."
This is usually something like, "If I'd known your guy had Protection from Green I wouldn't have attacked," or "I didn't know I had to do these things in the right order." I am a firm believer in not allowing so-called 'take backs'. If you aren't sure what to do in a given situation...welcome to the game. It is hard. Decisions have consequences, some that may never be fully understood. It is just hard like that. However, announcement is a procedure within the game. It has it's own rules, it is binding. There is no backtracking your main phase to play your Overrun pre-combat. Sequencing is a skill. Master it. It is not anyone else's fault that I don't know how to play the game properly. At the same time, we are all both students and teachers of the game. It is critical for us to be good ambassadors. Offer to help. Your opponents are most likely your friends. If they aren't yet, they very well could be if you demonstrate good will. Also: don''t be afraid to ask for help. Sometimes tipping your hand sucks, but so does making a critical error that costs you the game. The best you can do here is make it into a learning experience and the best way to learn is to help each other. I always correct my opponents when they are wrong and I will always, when asked, do my best to help them pilot their deck in good faith.

"I never lose/This deck never loses"
Everyone loses. Every deck loses. Saying that a loss or win wasn't legitimate because of some exigent circumstances is absurd. This touches on many topics but, internalizing your locus of control and accurately recording your results (relative to the matchup) is an important part of improving your game. Take your losses on the chin and learn from them, but don't get your perspective skewed. A slight advantage in play skill can win or lose a game, but it may not even show up at all. Switching one card might improve your odds of winning in a certain matchup by 5%. This difference will never manifest until you have played hundreds of games. Most tier 1 competitive decklists in sanctioned Magic formats have about a 50% win ratio versus the field. Commander isn't quite that 'solved' as a format, but facts are facts: if you are 50% or better against every other deck in the room, you have the best deck possible in that room. Doesn't mean you aren't going to lose half your games.

-GG

Tops down//Bottoms up: Campfire stories

Death, the state we fight but inevitably find. One man nay, one King found himself in the grip of death. Try as he might, the reaper came and brought him to the realm of the dead, and his village wept. The funeral was somber, for the collective thought they would never see him again, let alone find a Chieftain as strong, charismatic, and fearless as the one they mourned.

Then one night the forest whispered with echoes of the familiar, voices of the past hallowed through the camp. Villagers slowly appeared out of the forest in a ghastly blue, which startled the tribesmen. Yet before panic could set in making the living villagers flee, Karador, the Ghost Chieftain returned as king of a greater realm.

Welcome back to "Tops down, Bottoms up!" We've got Karador, Ghost Chieftain on tap, and I can't wait. This a general that I've been playing for a while now, so I'm excited to talk about him and share some of my favorite tech.


Karador hails from the "Commander" set and was the main focus of his Black/Green/White "Necra" Wedge, or Enemy-colored shard. Though Karador's flavor resembles mostly a Black commander, his creature type and value added bonuses provide the Green and White support so he can embody all three.  

His abilities allow us look at Wraths and Doom Blades in the face and chuckle. The first one gives us a discount on his CMC, which provides decent value, and includes the General re-casting cost, which is great value and unique flexibility among Commanders of every color. Karador's second one then allows us to dig these creatures out, which provides an even stronger flexibility, fueling the graveyard with all kinds of Toolbox power and putting you closer to victory.

The bin is both Karador's strength and his weakness. While the graveyard can supply great resources, our opponents are hoping to shut us down. "Exile target graveyard" effects, especially "free" ones like Bojuka Bog and other Grafdigger's Cage style ones can prove to be pretty formidable hosers. Fortunately, in my playgroup no has played Grafdigger's or Ground Seal so they are low on my worry list, but Bog is great utility in Black decks, and is the primary culprit for taking my graveyard and giving me nightmares. 
However, all is surprisingly not lost! Although exile is harsh in most formats, all is not lost in EDH. There are a couple of cards that can save us, but the best one for Karador is Riftsweeper. Riftsweeper exists and thank the gods it does. Hailing from FutureSight, this card was originally meant for owning Suspend cards (and eventually Haunt effects), but now we can abuse it over and over again for (1G) and recycle the relevant cards we need back into our library.

Riftsweeper being a creature, he is by far a better option for Karador solely because he's a creature, and can therefore be abused as card advantage several times over, which is why I'm not playing Pull from Eternity or the risky Mirror of Fate.

Creature spells is one of the main focal points of this deck and we owe it to ourselves to put the most fun utility creatures while maximizing any situation in a semi-toolbox way. Artifacts  Enchantments and other permanents make up a good chunk of utility plays in Edh by providing effects not native to you color scheme or manipulation game play. Players like us are no stranger to Sensei's Divining Top's scry plays or the turn one Sol Ring artifacts along with Enchantments that maintain your tempo or hinder opponents. Two of my favorite tools for dealing with them are my "Sliver twins": Harmonic Sliver and Necrotic Sliver. Recurrable artifact/enchantment ETB destruction with "Instant speed" Vindicate's help make solid board positions or add to intimidation factor. And both are approved by your friendly neighborhood Sun Titan! 

The use of this duo are an odd addition to my deck, I know. Usually, slivers like to stick with their own kind, providing buffs and abilities for total synergy. The way they benefit Karador is by gaining the effects of Aura Shards and Vindicate as creatures that trigger off one another, then add to the sacrifice outlet for (3) providing the bonus effect of permanent destruction. Three cmc cards like this go a long way in terms of mid and late game play while still being able to stop something early game if the need arises and they have never been dead-draws. Part of what makes Karador good is finding a balance between utility and performance to always have an answer to something else. 

Sun Titan is Karador's  main engine that doesn't rely on the Chieftain. What do I mean by this? It's the Recursion aspect and some key spells that are three and under like my enchantment trio: Dance of the Dead, Animate Dead, and Necromancy that keep this deck pumping out field presence. Karador's second ability allows us to cast a creature out of our graveyard but its just slow cause you have to pay the full cost of them, which usually is Karmic Guide to Sun Titan to "Animate" Enchantment, Three creatures for the price of one. I've dubbed it Hyper-Reanimation with added help from Hell's Caretaker, Doomed Necromancer, and Mimic Vat to make my field swarm with creatures.
So how do we get there? How do I get creatures into my graveyard to make the general cheaper and have answers without giving my opponents reason to remove them? The answer is to play stuff, but don't pull out everything all at once. Amazing things happen with this deck left alone but even the most well rounded decks can't do everything so it's important with a deck like this to let the game progress as it normally would then take advantage of a perfect situation. Think of our color combination, Black, Green, and White; we want to win but were playing semi-slow colors.

The semi-slow pace is welcomed by this deck. While I used to try to close the game a bit faster I noticed that late game has so much more potential than trying to "beat the clock" as a combo deck would be more focused to do. While we have our Tempo cards in here I also tuck in some disruption cards in here like my good friend Mindslicer. While he barely misses the 3 and under Sun Titan love he provides perhaps one of the most disruptive effect in Karador by eliminating the hands of you and your opponents. The downside to this guy is that it's mutual in the games hand disruption and it brings a halt to the game if he makes it to the field. I counteract his ability by pairing him with Disciple of Bolas so I will remain with 4 cards in hand but that only happens if I have them both or if Disciple is worth tutoring for at the moment. Mindslicer helps out our general while also maintaining his preferred pace so to me he's never a bad option to play. Most players are terrified to lose their hand almost as much as they don't want to let you draw the card off of Solemn Simulacrum so you can use this guy as a beater and hopefully remove some smaller utility creatures. Hand disruption along with my Instant/Sorcery hate cards like Dryad Militant and the new Sin Collector can be devastating to my opponents while only the former effecting me. 

Creatures die all the time in EDH so we don't have to wait too long to start reviving creatures but sometimes you get a combo player that doesn't care about removal or creatures and that's where Karador's Secondary engine kicks in. Sacrifice with a sprinkle of discard to amass our plays and fill our graveyard. We start with a creature tutor package of Birthing Pod and Fauna Shaman to get what we need when we need it, or set up a play. Birthing pod is usually one of the first things I tutor for if I don't have an engine. Black/Green draws cards for a price so it's no surprise I look to a sacrificial route for cards. These include Disciple of Bolas, Greater Good, Phyrexian Arena and Ancient Craving for this to complement my land ramp spells thinning out my deck. Another good resource is what I call self-sustaining creatures. These creatures die without any interaction while providing essential functions to the deck to which the Echo mechanic makes for a useful resource. Karmic Guide and Bone Shredder destroy and revive, then return to where I may use them again or return them to Mimic Vat. 

The "ideal" hand for Karador looks something like this:
  • Karador engine
  • Tutor spell
  • Early game answer
So you can adapt to most situations and that's good. You can revive just about anything from your or others graveyard, and you can abuse your creatures. One question remains is the biggest of them all.

HOW DOES KARADOR WIN?!?
Simple my friend, by being persistent and unrelenting in a fun and interesting way. Three main win cons of this deck include: Using key or strong effect creatures your opponents lost with animate effects then bring the game to a close with Avacyn, Angel of Hope and swing hard. Mirari's Wake into Genesis Wave usually puts a huge damper on things for my opponents and ends it there. Sorin's second ability will reduce one life total to 10 and usually it's a quick utilization of Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord's ability or beat down. Jarad has been known to get a moderate buff off of my graveyard but I never felt the need to attack with him. Simply using his ability to Fling and tidal wave each opponent provides an extra win con if I can't get by with my creatures.
Those are plenty examples of strengths in the deck, but what always marks a hero is their weaknesses, and yes Karador is my hero. Since the deck works well mid to late game, strong combo decks that can pull off early game shenanigans prevent this deck from being able to perform. Having some answers to common combo's are already in the deck but are not specifically used in that way. Karador also can have trouble against faster graveyard decks like Chainer, Dementia master and The Mimeoplasm because they can steal and Exile your creatures that are needed for your win. Both of these are weaknesses but by far this deck has the most trouble against Control decks. Opponents that have answers for your answers and prevent your field from even happening are the worst for Karador. I have placed a Gaea's Herald to prevent my creatures from being countered and the previously mentioned Riftsweeper to get back my exiled utility and creatures. The benefit of these are equally useless due to being a weak creature (Herald) or being slow to recur (Riftsweeper). No deck is without weakness, and I take that in to consideration in every deck built with three big questions asked; Can it win? Is it fun to lose to? and does it have fun and interesting outcomes?

The Link to my deck is Here. 

Until next time my friends, keep your games fun and your graveyard full of answers!
- Johnny Confidant

Tuesday, May 7, 2013

UL's Favorites: Little(r) Green Men

Happy Tuesday Zoners! Landdrops is back in his originally scheduled time, and we're going to continue my favorites segment chatting about the OG's of the Forest.

Green is a color I can't seem to stay away from. So it was no surprise that it took me a while to check and double check to make sure that these 10 were in fact my favorites. Cause I have a bunch. 

However, I was surprised to find that most of the creatures I like are comparatively smaller than you might expect for this color, which is known for big Beasts and even bigger Wurms.

10. Sakura-Tribe Scout
I know she's got four stick-looking arms and swords, and she's a Snake, but I still call her Shrek's Wife, or Fiona, and you're not gonna stop me.

For one reason or another, I've been trying to find a copy of this card for a while, and I always seem to cut it from an order or forget it.

I finally got a chance to play her in my Borborygmos Enraged EDH (cause I'm tough like a lumberjack), and I've been really impressed.

Unlike Walking Atlas, which is an unfortunate card with many flaws I can't even begin to count on my fingers, I like Fiona cause she powers out lands in my hand, which can help with mana floods and ramping into  a big Commander, which I certainly have in ol' Borby. This effect is really really good on Turn 1 in 1v1. Though Terrain Generator is probably just better, being able to put nonbasics into play is a nice relevant skill. She's not for every deck, but she's effective where it counts.

                                                                                                9. Krosan Tusker
In all the time I've been playing this card, I think I've only cast him twice. Once was on purpose and necessary. I needed a dude, and I was about to die. The other was a Cascade trigger off Maelstrom Wanderer, and I laughed while swinging all my guys for lethal.

Tusker isn't made for the battlefield though. His sole purpose in your deck is to be a Green Instant-speed Divination, netting you a land and another card.

I never get tired of cycling this guy. He's one of my favorite "secret" pieces of tech, though I'm not sure he's an actual secret if you've been playing EDH a long time or you've been following this blog for any length of time. I almost always keep a 3-lander with this guy in an opening hand. Ranking him here at 9 probably doesn't do diligence to just how much I like him, but he's not coming into play if you're managing the game properly, so don't worry about the 5GG at the top. This guy's CMC is really 2G, and it's one of the most reliable pieces of card advantage green has.

  8. Ant Queen
There's a lot of love for Verdeloth and Nemata, and I don't get it when "Auntie Ants" here exists.

If it's armies-in-a-can you want, Ant Queen is my favorite. I love Saprolings too, but why play with Saps when you can spit out Ant-Babies? Isn't that just better? (Ant-Baby tokens are soon to come.)

Say what you want about unpumpable chumps. They're much better to Skullclamp and chump block. I'm not interested in making them big and relevant. They're tokens, and there's an Overwhelming Stampede for that.

On the curve, a 5/5 for five is great. she can make 3 dudes assuming you play a land every turn, whereas Nemata and Verdeloth, though great nostalgia picks, just don't want to come out before you begin the late-late.

                                                                                               7. Spike Weaver
I've long since retired my old Chorus of the Conclave EDH deck, mostly because Animar's way more fun and I couldn't justify playing two decks with the exact same plan.

However, Spike Weaver was a key part to the coolness that the Chorus deck had, if it had anything.

Spikey was constantly changing games, and I wasn't even using him to protect me. In fact, I used him a couple times to keep other opponents from dying, which made him a lot more unpredictable. Politics are a thing in multiplayer, and he helped me abuse them.

Doing so also helped bring a lot of unnecessary hate to him, which in turn helped me keep Gaddock Teeg or Sun Titan, which were far more instrumental in the deck's wins.

I know it's not a good card cause it's fairly predictable, but I still like what it does, and the way it looks kinda harmless sitting on that branch, even though we all know it really isn't. Also, I'm sure Gatherer ruined his cool creature type, but yeah- he's a Spike, which isn't usually irrelevant to the way I pick cards, but I like it here.

  6. Dryad Arbor
Dryad Arbor's something I've been looking to play for a while, and since the FTV Reprints, I've finally felt comfortable dropping the dimes to get copies.

Being a Forest, a Dude, and Green makes her(?) the most tutorable card in any Green Deck, and I think that's pretty cool. Making your tutors get even more utility provides some flexibility that can be useful.

I'm often Green Sun's-ing for 0 to go get Arbor on Turn 1 in Borborygmos. I've also been known to Worldly Tutor for an Arbor when I need the land.

Your Grave Pact-ing Opponents are gonna love you when they're fry short of getting rid of your Avenger of Zendikar or whatever.


                                                                                                5. Sylvok Replica
I had Acidic Slime here at number five, but I decided to go with Sylvok Replica, which is basically a green card due to the activation cost in order to save time when I roll out my Artifact dudes. He may pop back up again there. I don't know. I'm playing this by ear.

Anyway, like our slimy friend, Replica is solid utility. Though not quite as good, Replica is a little more handy, as you can chump and sac to destroy something, or you can wait until your opponent forgets about him as a relevant board threat, and then blast their Gauntlet of Power into oblivion.

Obviously, Acidic Slime outclasses my friend here a little bit with deathtouch, but still favor Replica as the cheaper option with a reasonable activated ability. I usually play both, but I felt like this guy was worth mentioning cause a lot people play Acidic Slime. I've got both in my Dollar General Glissa deck and Animar, where Replica is actually kinda better than Slimer.

  4. Chameleon Colossus
I don't play this card as much as I should now, but I still love it.

He's one of the cheapest late-game threats to cast, and this card is often a blowout. Cause if you don't take care of it immediately, especially in the late-late, you're going to die.

One of my favorite tricks was to combine overruns with him, especially Overwhelming Stampede or Triumph of the Hordes, before that got really absurd.

He is a metagame choice though. If your group relies on black to get rid of dudes, he's a perfect addition to any roster. Cause he's every creature type.


                                                                                                3. Eternal Witness
I'm not sure it gets too original from here on out, but E-Wit is my homegirl. Probably one of the most abusive cards for Green card advantage. Being able to get back countered creatures or spells is huge, and she's half the reason Green is played wayy too much now.

When you play other colors, she gets even better. With Blue, I've set up Mimic Vat Time Warp locks. With Rite of Replication and an Early Harvest, I saw one of the guys in my playgroup make infinite E-Wits and mana.

If I'm ever going to define the word "Staple," this is the picture I want next to it in the EDH dictionary. Eternal's such a fitting word for this warrior woman.



  2. Sakura-Tribe Elder
Speaking of EDH-themed things in real life, Alex Trebek told me he was the answer to last night's Daily Double on EDH jeopardy.

This is a card that is 100% guaranteed to make your deck better. He makes Dawntreader Elk look like Wood Elemental. 

I think this guy speaks for himself. He's a Rampant Growth and a dude. GG plays this, I play this, you should play this, and so enough said. We'll move on to my favorite card.





                                                                                                1. Fierce Empath
Let's set the record straight. Cause I'm not saying that Fierce Empath is a better card than Elder. We're splitting hairs here though, in my opinion.

But I had to pick one, and Fierce Empath is my absolute favorite green creature. And if (the biggest IF) I ever get tired of casting Solemn Simulacrum, Fierce Empath would be the only card in my mind to unseat the Saddest Robot.

GG played this against me in Pauper a year or two ago, and that was all it took. I went home immediately and bought 4-6 copies of this guy, and I never looked back.

I'm pretty sure I'm the leading expert (next to Gatherer) on Empath targets. I'm not kidding.

This guy does so much work in every deck I put him in. My favorite combo is to go search for Krosan Tusker and leverage maximum card advantage. However, I've done a lot of different things with Empath.

So far, my Animar deck has been the most broken place for him. There's a list of targets a mile long, and depending on what the board looks like, he's a toolbox with endless possibilities, getting anything from Maelstrom Wanderer to Duplicant or even Sun Quan to close out a game. He also really likes getting Steel Hellkite for more removal, Etherium-Horn Sorcerer for more Cascade, or Prime Speaker Zegana for super-sexy card draw times. Like I said- the list is a mile long.

We've got a pretty nice week ahead of us here at TGZ. Thursday Johnny Confidant returns with this great article on Karador. Saturday's going to be a pretty great stack episode, where we dissect some of our Dragon's Maze favorites, and Grandpa Growth will be back Sunday with a piece from his In General series. So don't be a Square. 

Keep tuning in for all things essentially Commander. Same bat times, same bat place.
Your turn.
-UL