I have teetered back and forth for a long time about writing on this topic. It is controversial by nature. I am talking about getting competitive. About taking your show on the road, as it were. So you win casual games. So you can beat your friends decks. I am going to lay out the seven decks that I consider tier 1. The decks that, built right, will break the format. The decks that I won't even play against unknown opponents. It has been asked for, it shall be given. The tier one decks...and the decks that would be tier one if some additional rules applied. I am currently on a quest to prove my points to my play group; to demonstrate that these decks will, in the absence of dedicated hate, overwhelm the format and create a consistently unfair game.
These decks violate all the social rules of the format. Some of these are banned by the official rules. Knowing that I don't abide by that document you can take my comments with a grain of salt. This, at most, constitutes my personal opinions about the format. Note that, as usual, I am discussing these cards from a 1v1 perspective, but the unique thing about these decks is that they happen to be very strong in multiplayer because they win in broken ways. These decks can certainly be built in such a way that they are fair and engaging and not abusive, but the reverse isn't true of most other decks. I'd love to hear what decks you guys don't want to play against, whether you agree with this list or not.
Since these aren't being presented in any particular order I don't feel bad about starting in a weird spot. Sharuum is probably the most fair and normal of the decks on this list. Most games tend to play out in a pretty normal fashion. The thing that makes this deck so strong is the consistency and resiliency it has. The tutors in this color combination are top notch and you also have access to virtually any kind of disruption you want. Thoughtseize, Mind Twist, Armageddon, Counterspells. These cards make people pretty unhappy. It is pretty miserable to begin a game knowing that you are going to be dead on turn 8 and will never resolve a spell. This is the only three-color general on my list. Consistency is a big part of why these decks are so strong, but Sharuum is different in that it has dozens of possible win conditions that don't overlap and are easy to set up. Isochron locks, Strip Mine + Crucible, Sculpting Steel combos, Mindslaver, pretty basic stuff, but there is much available that I won't bother listing individually. Knowing which win-cons your opponent's deck has can be very tough to figure out pre-match. Unlike the other decks on this list (which experienced players will be familiar with) you can't guess the composition of a Sharuum deck very easily.
This is a little bit more like what I am really talking about. When somebody whips out a Jhoira deck know exactly what they are up to. There really isn't much of a surprise factor here. Mass land destruction -> Resolve Eldrazi. In fact, you can probably guess 94 of the cards in a Jhoira deck right off the bat. Of these seven, this is the only deck that I have actually built and played myself. I can never find opponents that want to battle it...so it doesn't see a whole lot of action.
Another pretty self-explanitory deck. Play braid, preferably early, and proceed to the win phase. You always have access to a Smoke Stack and getting stuck on 3-4 lands means that most Commander decks will never be able to cast even half of their spells. This deck is somewhat less viable in multiplayer, where you will immediately draw tons of hate, but it still is very powerful since the ability affects all players. Keep in mind most of those players are not going to be prepared to play a low-econ game.
A very basic, very consistent combo deck. This deck is actually pretty easy to disrupt, but the fact that this deck is chock full of counterspells means that patient players will be able to force the combo through every time. If don't have counterspells you just can't beat this deck. You try kill the Kiki-jiki, they counter your removal and you lose on the spot. No fun for anyone.
This is the exact same deck as Niv-Mizzet, except the win conditions are slightly different. Note that I am not talking abut the Wizard Tribal version of this deck. I am speaking strictly about the focused combo version, which I think we can all agree is much more competitive and less fun.
Another general that enjoys the dubious distinction of being banned by the 'official' rules. This deck is unique among these seven because it has virtually no disruption and doesn't win with infinite combos. What it does do is make an absurd amount of mana on turn three every single game. Either you mulligan to removal or you get destroyed by a giant monster before you cast anything relevant to the board. Warping the game in this way is exactly what makes these decks so powerful and so unfair.
And here it is, the final card. I am sure that you all guessed this anyway. This is the one true master deck. It was banned the instant the rules committee formed and with good reason. If you have ever tried to build this deck or have played against it you will know why it is so frustrating. Spot removal is rarely effective at preventing the Erayo lock from happening. If they cast Erayo and then you cast a kill spell then they are already halfway to flipping it and trust me, this deck plays plenty of free spells. I don't want to call it unbeatable, because it isn't, but this deck destroys the other 6 on this list and will make a mockery of your typical Commander game, multiplayer or not. The process of actually getting killed will be slow, painful, and embarrassing, but the game is almost always unwinnable by turn three.
Honorable Mentions: Blue Braids, Momir Vig, Arcum Dagsson, Glissa the Traitor. These use the same pieces (infinite combos, overloading on disruption and counterspells, cheating mana requirements), but can't consistently beat all seven of these decks, so I left them off the list, although an explanation of the individual match ups is important in understanding why, I don't have the time or space to do so here. A story for another day I guess. There are a lot of decks that are in my 'tier 2' that are very good, but still play fair and fun so they aren't a problem in the format. Rhys for example.
Bonus section: in competitive 1v1 tournaments the landscape of Commander changes slightly. A more restrictive ban list is implemented, fast mana is restricted, and players are aware of and prepared for the popular decks. In this format there are two other decks that I would consider top tier. I won't spend too much time discussing them,
That's all for today zoners. Leave some comments to let me know what you think about these decks and what role they play in the format. If you think I missed any let me know!
Tuesday's rolled around once again, and it's time to for me to finish my lists.
So rather than bore you with any nonsense, I'm gonna shut up and play the funky music.
Here's my top 10 favorite Black creatures.
10. Butcher of Malakir
Probably no surprises. I think people know how good this guy is. A Dude with a Grave Pact.
Having a 5/4 Flyer is actually good too. It affords you the opportunity of getting a huge removal spell in multiplayer, as well as a way to beat down and make your opponents think twice about blocking. Second guessing leads to mistakes. Mistakes lead to losses. Their losses lead to your victory.
At least, that's what Yoda tells me. Then again he also said "Hard to see the Dark Side is." So what is it Yoda? Amirite?
9. Bloodgift Demon
BGD is a neat little card. He scales nicely with your plans, adding hopefully to the additional card you're probably already drawing with Phyrexian Arena. Having a 5/4 flyer can also be relevant if you need to chump block.
And having a 5/4 flyer that looks like Hellboy with wings and a raised golden chalice, presumably filled to the brim with Blood, is... kinda like looking at an unsettling picture of Demon Communion? I don't know where I was going with this. It's just art. The colors really pop in this one, and I think that's why I I like it.
One of the cool tricks that I haven't felt good about doing yet is pinging other people with the ability. Mostly, cause I don't want them drawing cards. But I've got him in this Kaervek deck where I can stack additional damage effects on for drawing said card.
8. Graveborn Muse
Original Gravy is an O.G. (The other Gravy being Gravy T, rolling with Zombs). Again, scales nicely with Phyrexian Arena. I've only had one rare circumstance where I was able to play Arena, Gravy, and BGD Turns 3-5. It's kinda like hitting the jackpot, and I love to revel in the small victories when I get to draw lots o' cards.
Do remember though that OG can be ballsy, particularly in Zombie tribal. The more dudes you put out, the more damage and cards you draw. It's not the worst, but it could be. I always forget about Army of the Damned.
Also, it's a spirit. So if you're going Spirit Tribal, you now have an extra card draw outlet if you're trying to stay faithful to that.
7. Sepulchral Primordial
Seppy Prime's one of the new additions to the gang, so I don't have much experience with it quite yet, but I do like what it does.
Fear- I mean, Intimidate- seems relevant, and again, we get to make as many players pay as we want.
I've seen this card get so much value in multiplayer. In most of the games I play in black, it essentially becomes a contest to see how many times I can play Solemn Simulacrum. My opponents have followed suit, and most of them actually love playing this guy to get my Solemn Simulacrum. So the fun never ends, and we all get a shot at winning, because as a joke, we say that the person who casts Solemn Simulacrum the most is totally who should win the game.
6. Crypt Ghast
Like Seppy, I pre-ordered this card in Gatecrash cause I had a feeling it was going to be good. Boy was I on the money. It's been the Extraplanar Lens I needed, and as an added bonus, I get to trigger Extort. Oh, and I don't lose a land.
The art isn't much to write home about, but it's good to have expectations met. I really do like the shading and the transparency that's near the bottom of his shape. See also the moving masks. No idea what the flavor is, but it doesn't matter to me- this creep can roll, man.
Again, this is another great addition to mono-Black spirit tribal. See if you can make a better Infernal Kirin EDH than the one I scrapped a few weeks ago. Just don't forget Wicked Effing Akuba. Or you'll be sorry.
5. Coffin Queen
Koffing Queen Alter to follow.
This is actually a card that I don't have a lot of experience with, but I want to get to know her. Like Preacher, which I mentioned a few weeks ago, I plan on playing this card in the near future, possibly in a deck where I can abuse other activated abilities so I can play Illusionist's Bracers and get mega value.
I currently have her slotted in my Lazav Sewer Protection deck, predicated on getting some mill, some laughs, and a few copies of dudes from other people's bins.
I really like this art too. Really good fun Vintage Magic art. She looks like a super villain.
4. Necroskitter
I've talked up this card a lot, and I think it's a gem. I know other people do. I mean, there's gotta be a reason he's still 5 bucks, right?
I ended up not making the Skeleton Ship deck that I wanted to cause it didn't feel too inspired, but I plan on crafting a deck with some -1/-1 counters in the future, and I definitely have a spot for Mr. Skitter here in a future design.
I feel like this card is a pretty flavorful masterpiece top-to-bottom. From his spiny attributes to his spidery legs, even his P and T, which is pretty uncommon for a black creature. I like how all of this stuff seems to match up really well, and it's one of the reasons I'm looking forward to playing this card.
3. Braids, Cabal Minion
Since she's banned as a General, I figured we could talk about Braids here, cause she is a card I play a lot.
It's nice having recurrable removal to slow people down in multiplayer. Even in 1v1 she's pretty good. I've found her to be very useful in just about every black deck she's ever been in.
In decks with a bunch of other hate bears, she can really shine by stacking sacrifice triggers onto each other. I had an old Ghost Council 1.0 deck that was trying to accomplish this. Her plus Hokori or World Queller really wreak some havoc.
One of my favorite ploys is to sac her to her own upkeep trigger and reanimate again. It's fun when they think they're safe, but they aren't. Having her on a Mimic Vat to activate on their upkeep is pretty cool too. Especially in 1v1.
Just don't look into her eyes too long Zoners. She's got the crazy eyes. Queue Twilight Zone-Looking clip from CBS's hit show, How I Met Your Mother.
2. Midnight Banshee
As far as mono-Black is concerned, I think
Banshee is pretty incredible. It's a token hoser, and a decent 5/5 attacker that's going to shrink a Titan at its worst.
Unfortunately, I
think people see "nonblack" and like Doom Blade, they get scared. Though
this text can sometimes be hard to play around, especially if your
opponent plays black, I still find her more useful than not.
Again, another Spirit to treasure from the sadly unsuccessful Infernal Kirin deck.
The art's still pretty sweet though. Really nice and unsettling.
1. Skinrender
I'm fairly sure I speak for GG too when I say that
this card is awesome. He's basically right at the beginning of relevant
curves in black, and he allows you to get rid of anything that will
probably come before, like a Gaddock Teeg or a pesky Merfolk Looter
(though it's probably too late on the Looter. They've drawn cards, and
you've lost the game.).
I love the art, I love what he does. He's just been a great little pet card.
He fits well into Zombie tribal too, which is a pretty common thing, though I wish they'd given him his actual creature type, which is Predator. That's what I call him anyway, despite Skinrender being a sweet name for a card in its own right. He's like the world's most violent-sounding Decepticon.
We got great stuff this week from the TGZ team, so make sure you keep yourself above water as we talk budget cards and flavor fouls this week.
Til then, keep Starscream in check, Megatron from turning into a gun (cause it's stupid), and even if all else fails, promise me you won't shove it in Optimus' chest.
Keep your Matrix of Leadership. Don't be an Awk-timus Prime.
-UL