Saturday, January 25, 2014

The Stack #44- Ground Control to... More Control

Much was to be discussed about the content behind this week's Stack, which was named "Ground Control to... More Control" so we could talk about... well, I think you'll get the picture, so let's get to it.

Control. Removal. Disruption.

THIS IS THE STACK!

UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK 

Uncle Landdrops-  THUMBS UP
Like Pongify or its Gatecrash counterpart, Rapid Hybridization, B-Dubz requires a little more desperation than your average Doom Blade, but when the Beast hits, you know.

Personally, I think this is the best card Wizards printed from our second trip to Mirrodin/New Phyrexia. "Destroy target permanent" is rules text R&D has given to a select few cards, and I dig the trade-off. Trading this for creatures always feels even, and getting a pesky enchantment or artifact off the table is usually good if you're desperate.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
Would you look at the art on that one...I have never seen this printing before and I'm just glad I hadn't eaten recently. I am all for keepin' it real, but this interpretation is just a bit too literal for me. In the original iteration Phyrexia's creeping corrosion ate away at something and a new creature was born out of the re-purposed material. The amount of pain this poor dude is probably in is suitable for mature audiences only.

Also, play this card. It is awesome.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
I've stated before, i'm all for cards that, "taketh away" and "giveth something back." The more you think about Beast Within in green you see that it's far more one sided than it seems. It's awesome indeed, and I agree with GG- Play this card.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
My favorite aspect of this card is its versatility. It is not just a creature remover, but it destroys any target permanent. I realize you can read the card, but I cannot stress how amazing that is. Planeswalkers? Hah! how about a nice beastie instead? Or you could be cruel and take out someone's duel land.

VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Hooray for one-drop spells. With the exception of Hexproof creatures, this card has proven to be one of the most useful, reliable removal spells in my MTG history. It's one thing to destroy a creature, but then there's the chance of it coming back or coming back stronger even, but exiling is the more permanent solution. If one of your creatures is in danger of someone's Control Magic, pop this out and ramp up your mana!

Uncle Landdrops-  THUMBS UP
Surely one of the better spells, but it does come with a trade-off most people overlook. Because we're a society focused on big scores, giving a player an extra land instead of a threat can be a huge mistake. On the flip side, I've also used this card as a way to ramp, or get value out of an irrelevant creature on my side.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
The cheaper the better. This, Swords to Plowshares, Condemn, and Terminus, with that awesome Miracle cost, are what makes White amazing. Also as VJ has said, I too have used this to remove a creature I control to ramp up when i'm behind.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I find comedy in the strangest of places with Magic. This card is awesome and sees more play in Commander than any other format. Strange then, that the drawback is at its most significant here. Every deck has basics, every deck wants to accelerate on mana. Path is a go-to answer in Modern even though every deck packs basics simply because Bolt can't hit Scavenging Ooze or Goyf, which are both key targets even though they see play in very mana hungry decks who would love to have an extra land in play.  People don't play Path in Legacy even though a minority of decks even have basics because "Swords is better." The life from Swords matters more in Legacy because almost every game is a foot race to see who can kill the fastest. The only decks that try to kill slowly are like...Lands and Countertop, who have no creatures anyway.

So what is my point? Path sees play in Modern, but would be better in Legacy. Swords sees play Legacy, but would be better in Modern...thanks Obama.

GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK


Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
The OG of "oh jeez I don't want that to happen." Counterspell has been there since the beginning. It has been declared too weak, too strong, and finally outdated. We live in strange times. The brave new world of 2013 saw a return of mono Blue, but without its trademark answer. We have seen updated versions of Terror, Wrath, and even modern printings of Lightning Bolt, but nothing that puts the crush on opposing dreams quite like Counterspell. Pour one out for my dead homie.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
Honestly, how can you not like this card? It's the poster boy of why most people hate Blue players and if used properly it's also the best political card on the table. Need evidence, you say? Even if Blue isn't in one of your general's colors, players will still look for a counter-effect spell they can play, albeit they can never get as strong as "Counter target spell" for only UU, but my point remains.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Last I checked I only have one deck with actual Double-Bluesy here in it. These days I'd just rather set myself up with Island and another color so I can coax an opponent into playing something I can counter with a Negate or Memory Lapse or possibly Foil. Not that it isn't good, but everyone can and should be able to see Island-Island, and know better.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
It took me a year to realize that I needed multiple copies of Counterspell to put in all of my Blue decks. The classic response is certainly the best in my opinion, (next to Path, of course), and I don't mind the Island-Island so much. With enough dual lands and mana rocks, you can do anything.

JOHNNY CONFIDANT'S PICK

Johnny Confidant-  THUMBS UP
Everyone hates to love a good tuck spell and Unexpectedly Absent is the newcomer to this scene. Interestingly enough, this is one of the cheapest cards to cast in order to stop those pesky aggressive deck that come out swinging early.

The other great utilization that is unique to this card is the ability to stack it into the deck. I like the feeling of putting someones general 4-5 from the top and watch them ponder over whether to tutor or shuffle the deck is worth it.

Personally, UL told me to try this out in my Daxos deck as a control card, but also for an opportunity to set up a solid steal on contact. First time I used it, I stole an opponents Ashiok, so I'm completly on board with this card.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I believe there were very few low expectations about this card when it came out. Because I practice what I preach, I too play this in my Daxos deck. In one of the early iterations, I got it on an Isochron Scepter, and it was everything most other people hate about Commander.

Still, I don't think this card is too horrible. Not like Exsanguinate or D to the D-less. This is a good card that has to be played even better. Timing, in addition to your target, is still everything. It's single "removal" with a scaleable effect, and most times you're probably just paying WW if you're doing it right.

Generally, a Commander like Daxos really helps make this better. Getting their threat and turning it into your own is a lot better than having to play the "Lantern of Insight" game most Daxos players do, which has been a somewhat of a wasted card every time I tired to play it.

Grandpa Growth - THUMBS UP
Dear. Sweet. Lord. This is my new case study. Whenever someone talks about the "potential" of a card I swiftly direct them to this. AT WORST, this trades one card for one card as a very average two mana Instant. Most answers that we think about being good, look just like that. That is potential. Being, at worst, as good as the next card and occasionally going SUPER DEEP and just shutting the whole block down.

People shuffle their libraries way more often than is safe in Commander. This card is tough to play around. Case in point: I was recently playing with a friend's 5-color deck. It was very janky and has some suspicious card choices, but a situation came up in-game where the opponent went for a Natural Order, binning his Noble Hierarch. My board was basically empty except for a Vedalken Orrery, which I used to Flash in a Grafdigger's Cage. An Unexpectedly Absent on his general (Rubinia) in response ended the game on the spot. In about four seconds his emotional state went from: "I'm about to win!" To: "I don't want to live on this planet anymore." This is the equivalent of killing a zombie that is chasing you by dropping a piano onto it. Thanks Sister Cynthia Knickerbocker.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
This type of card, I feel, is the perfect removal card against Graveborn type decks. Putting something in someone's graveyard has proven fatal to me in the past, and with indestructible creatures, the only other options are exile or gain control. I've been a fan of the idea of cards that put things into their owner's libraries, but I haven't used them extensively and now I feel I should start experimenting with this, Proteus Staff, Condemn, Bant Charm, and Ether Well.

Feel free to tell us what you think about our favorites in the comments below.

Next time, we'll have plenty of great Born of the Gods things to talk about, so stay tuned, and have a Legendary Weekend.

-UL/VJ/JC/GG

Friday, January 24, 2014

TGZ News: GPSAC, MTGO Cube, and Born of the Gods

Hey Zoners! Grandpa Growth here bringing you what is up in the world of Magic in another TGZ News!

GP Sacremento finished up last weekend and it was definitely an exciting tournament. The live coverage by members of Team ChannelFireball was awesome and their very own Tom Martell ended up taking down the whole tournament. If you missed out you should definitely check out the text coverage on the mothership and the video of the Top 8 Draft on Channelfireball.com:
http://www.wizards.com/magic/magazine/article.aspx?x=mtg/daily/eventcoverage/gpsac14/welcome
http://www.channelfireball.com/videos/grand-prix-sacramento-top-8/

Exciting news for casual fans, MTGO Cube will return January 29th! Announced this week on Daily MtG complete with an updated Cube list. Make sure to set aside some time next week to crack virtual packs and have some good old fashioned fun.
http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Article.aspx?x=mtg/daily/other/01202014

Born of the Gods spoilers are all over the internet making waving and lighting up Twitter feeds from here to Hong Kong. Whether you are testing modern for the upcoming Pro Tour or just trying to get a leg up at your local prerelease make sure you check out the full visual spoiler. At the time of this post nearly the entire set has been spoiled!
http://www.wizards.com/magic/tcg/article.aspx?x=mtg/tcg/bornofthegods/cig#

Thursday, January 23, 2014

It's "Born of the Gods," not "Bored of the Gods..."

Now that most of the cards are spoiled in the second Theros expansion, Born of the Gods, it's time to do some pre-reviewing before the pre-release next week. 

Today, we're going to examine and re-visit some of the spins being done on previous set mechanics as well as the two new ones. 

Let's begin.

NEW MECHANIC- INSPIRED

Our first example is a card I've already heard people call, "The New Dark Confidant." 

I hope I don't need to point out the irony that comes attached with this "Inspired" mechanic.

Now, I have no idea how good Pain Seer is going to be in Commander, or any other 60-card format. I'm using this card strictly as an example of what seems to be the best card with this mechanic, and I'm really not seeing it.

What I know is that the thing about Dark Confidant is that he really doesn't want to attack. He wants to stay in the shadows until the board is clear of other little Goombas so that he doesn't lose his 1 toughness. 

That's why I believe that if this is supposed to be what Wizards calls, "Inspired," it's not. There's a rule taught in writing and reinforced in everyday life that we define ourselves how we want to be seen, not what we are. 

This is the inherent problem with this design of most of these cards. I don't see anything here that feels truly inspired. The mechanic itself is so innate to the game that it's obvious, and the majority of triggers that happen feel very similar to the Lorwyn/Shadowmoor block cards with untap symbols.

While it appears to be a pattern Wizards is showing us, Devotion is actually awesome across most of the formats being played. It's in the strongest decks in Standard, and it's rewarding people who play mono-colored decks in Commander.

Again, I don't have any in-game experience yet with these cards- but all signs point to flop. 

PAYING TRIBUTE

Tribute, on the other hand, feels a little more interesting.

For Commander, the best Tribute card revealed is probably this hot-lookin' Hydra. 

Though Wizards seems to be catching up for lost time with all the Hydras printed in the last year, I feel like I can still get behind some of the designs.

Here, I'll be willing to admit that I like NWR because it fights, which isn't as much about the Tribute as it is about the fight mechanic.

Clearly, Fighting is much better than Tribute as a mechanic because of elegance, natural color inclination, and simplicity (Fighting doesn't have numbers!), but still- I can see Tribute creating an entire Doctorate-Level course in Magic Player's Psychology. Some of our staff's favorite cards are Realms Uncharted, Fact or Fiction, and the always banned Gifts Ungiven. Though not the same, Tribute has a similar, tricky quality that just might be compelling. 

MULTICOLORED DEVOTION- NOT TERRIBLE, NOT BROKEN

Reddit was all abuzz a few days ago with the discussion on how the new gods make everything a little more complicated this time around with their color-split allegiances. 

So, in case you were probably wondering, but too afraid to ask, or too smart and thought you could make a great rules assumption, let's clear this all up:

1) Devotion on multicolored Gods is combined. For our example, it is not seven devotion to Green AND seven devotion to Red to turn our evil Planeswalker pal turned God into a creature. It is a combination of seven Red OR Green mana.

2) Hybrid mana symbols do not count double. Naturally, Deus of Calamity turns on Xenagos as a creature. That's because combined, they create 7 red and green devotion. 

The best way to look at this is to count number of non-numerical circles in a converted mana cost, not the color(s). With Deus' 5 symbols and Xenagos' 2, our Legendary Enchantment Creature God is a Creature.

However, your individual color Devotion is a different count (SIX devotion to red, and SIX Devotion to Green), and obviously never add up to twelve. 

Ultimately, I think this makes Devotion possibly better than it was in the first block. This isn't necessarily because of the strength of the cards spoiled either. I didn't think I was going to like it before I looked up how this is being counted, but I'm digging it. Devotion creates a fresh angle of game design which was already printed on every single non-artifact/colorless card in Magic, and it's going to force us to read the game in a different slant of light. 

Well, that's all I got for today. Continue to look for more Born of the Gods stuff once the full set's spoiled.

Until next time, devote yourself to something inspired so we can pay tribute. 

-UL
 

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

You Make the Pick #3

Hey Zoners! Grandpa Growth is back again with another YMTP! The segment where I show you a booster pack, talk about what cards I think are good, and then YOU leave us a shout out with what you would take. We assume this is a pick one, pack one situation.

This week we have a Theros Booster pack that is...not exciting at all. In fact, it is the kind of booster you don't want to open anywhere. No money rare, no sweet tech cards, nothing that is really worth anything outside of limited. Let's take a look:



The rare is generally pretty good, but not great. There really isn't another exciting White card that the next guy could take either, which is a bonus. There is a solid Green option with the Emissary, a card that I like quite a bit. The card I am most excited about is Gray Merchant. Staking your claim to Black early on can really pay off if the packs break the right way. Unfortunately there is also an Insatiable Harpy, a very playable Black card that is likely to go in the next couple of picks. Taking either could potentially mean we get cut on Black in pack 2. Gary is the best card in my opinion, but I would take the Gift of Immortality. White is a very strong color, we aren't giving much up in terms of power, and we aren't sending any clear signals to the left. Final thought: I love Burnished Hart and everyone else thinks it is bad, poor little guy.

There are certainly options here and plenty to think about, but the only question left to ask is...WHAT WOULD YOU PICK?!

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Spin Into Myth: Loony Dudes

Heya Zoners!

Ya boi Landdrops is here with another Spin Into Myth, the segment full of UL's trial-basis tech.

Today, I've got several oddball creatures to share, and I'm anxious to hear your thoughts, see what people want to try, and what sticks in the next few weeks.

We'll start off with a new piece of Greel tech.

At a CMC of 4, this is where most Mono-Black decks stop durdling if they were, and start casting creatures if they have them. Abyssal Persecutor and Desecration Demon are pretty aggressive cards I like to play here, but this particular spot is pretty expansive.

The Greel deck alone has somewhere over 5+ targets for Fleshwrither's ability. The most notable of these is Erebos, which is pretty nice.

I'm not sure it's any better than say, Diabolic Tutor, but it is more interesting.

With Animar, I'm always trying to change out cards here and there. This is one of two new changes I made.

Obviously, Striker is one of my cheap role players. In past versions of this deck I noticed that the blue and green creatures overpowered the red. Normally, this isn't a problem, but it's in my best interest to have a few extra red creatures for rainy days and rough draws.

Clearly, his Battalion trigger is going to go off the majority of the time, which can put some serious pressure on my opponents. Not being able to block with a dude or their best dude ensures that they are going to be out of luck a little bit quicker than anticipated. My guess is that this will become a Legion Loyalist, but sometimes playing cards that you pulled from your own booster packs can be rewarding.

This is probably not "surprising" tech, per se, as there are a lot of people who like this card, not only in their red decks, but also as a Commander.

My copy of Marton has been sitting in a binder since I made the switch from Fumiko to HH. Strangely, I never once considered it for Animar until a few weeks ago, when I was going through my binder looking for new stuff to try out.

I think he's going to be a bad copy of Mirror Entity for this deck. Like Hero of Oxid Ridge, and Hellrider, Marton gives me incentive to attack with Spellskite and some of the other Myr mana dorks that I play.

I'm not confident in this card, but he does have a high ceiling in Animar, where he has the potential to be better than a bad card.

This past week I made the tough decision to retire Yeva. I'm anxious to get back to what I like most about green decks, and I wasn't able to find ways to keep me excited about playing it.

So we've got a new day, and a new Commander. And Sporemound got invited to this party, where there's plenty of ramp and Skullclamp (probably) to go around.

The testing phase has yielded the results I expected when this thing got spoiled a while back, and I'm glad I finally found a place to get this guy in the game.

And now for my Looniest pick.

When I finally got Daxos to the kitchen table, I noticed there was a huge space in which my deck was lacking: Draw power.

Without consistent momentum, the Daxos deck had a tendency to lose its momentum and eventually get beat in card advantage.

So I brought in the bird.

This was a card one of my friends had been kicking around in a Lavinia list that never got made, and I found it intriguing.

Sawtooth Loon isn't a card I'm necessarily excited about. However, he can create a recurrable engine in a tight spot. He's seen a little action in games so far, and I'm anxious to see more.

So I saved my favorite pick for last.

Before I took apart Yeva, one of my biggest problems was avoiding damage if I didn't have Spike Weaver or a Fog.

A few weeks after Theros came out, I was looking for other ways to stay alive, and thought this might be worth a shot. Get it?
Creature type puns never get old.

Fortunately for this Disciple and her God, I decided that devotion would be a nice element for my new deck. So the process has begun, and we'll see if Nylea's Disciple is worth it.
Well, Porky Pig says I'm done for today. Be sure to leave comments if you have 'em about these various pieces of nonsense I like to play.

I'll be back on Thursday to try and make sense of the spoilers for Born of the Gods.

Until then, let the Wookie win.

-UL








Monday, January 20, 2014

SNAP KEEP?! #3

I'm Grandpa Growth, you're a loyal Zoner, and around here we like to take care of our friends. I am going to reward you with another SNAP KEEP?! The fun weekday segment where I show you an awkward looking hand, tell you the story behind it, then YOU TELL US whether you would keep it or send it back.

This week's hand is some more action from my Pauper Cube. Here, we on the play with a Green/White Aggro/Ramp deck that is splashing Red for a miser's Flame Slash, which is conveniently clogging up our opener. I don't know exactly what my opponent has in his deck, but I am pretty sure that he is Blue because I shipped a Deep Analysis in his direction and saw no Blue whatsoever in Pack 2. Take a look at our starting seven:



So right off the bat I am thinking mulligan because this hand has a ton of problems: No one or two drop, it can't currently cast any of it's spells, it has our only double Green card, our only Red card, and no lands of those colors. Our mana base is something like 7 Plains, 4 Forests, 1 Mountain, Panorama, plus 3 signets: Boros Orzhov. Fourteen is a very reasonable amount of land in Pauper Cube since most of what you have costs 3 or less and there is a ton of bounce lands, artifact acceleration, and mana elves.

Our deck has a high end that consist of Hexplate Golem and Voice of the Provinces, with a Fierce Empath to fetch them. Unfortunately, this hand is light on mana so it could easily stumble before we get to the late game. If my suspicion about our opponent playing Blue is correct, then their late game might just be much better than ours anyway. Also, we don't know what other colors the opponent has. We are hoping to see a more aggressive Black or Red start so that we can clog up the ground with a First Striker and then protecting it with our White Instants.

This hand has a path to victory though, which makes me like it, Test of Faith can just be insane as a combat trick. Countering a Lightning Bolt and adding three counters to our guy usually makes it too big to trade 1-for-1 with.

So what do you think? Is this a snap keep?!

Sunday, January 19, 2014

In General: Engines and Investment pt.2

Welcome back to part two of my series on investment in strategy games. If you missed part one make sure to check it out here: Part 1. At the end of that post I left you with some homework, which was to compare and contrast three different cards with the goal of identify which of them is a good investment. What do they do, what are they good for, what you have to put into them to get something back, questions like these are what define the parameters for our investments. The interplay between these parameters and the actual game state we are in will provide the answer to the following question, which is what today's installment is all about. That question is:

What makes an investment 'good'?
  • "An investment is good if it makes you money." This is what you will hear most often. This is, of course, the most wrong, but it feels okay. If I buy a property, like a space on the monopoly board, I give up a hundred bucks or so with the initial outlay, but then every couple turns or so someone will land on it and have to pay me a portion of that money back. I turned a lump sum of cash into a predictable income. That's all well and good. This makes people comfortable. That chunk of cash isn't burning up in their pockets and they get a check every month to pay their own bills with (see how the return schedule lines up conveniently with the subject's expense schedule) so you don't have to worry about the details as much. If you only own one piece of the board though, you are unlikely to ever make back what you spent to get it. This demonstrates the problem of low return on investment. You don't get back what you gave away. 
  • "An investment is good if it makes you more money than you invested." When offered the above explanation, people will often have some sort of eureka moment and return with this answer. They think they 'get it' now. This is just about as bad as the previous response. Let's re-examine the monopoly example and talk about some end behavior. The ways you could make back your money on that monopoly square are: 1. Get lucky OR 2. Stay in the game for a VERY long time. That is it. You need to have a bunch of people land on the square to make the investment 'worth it', but that could take a little time or a lot of time and you have no control in which one actually occurs. This is a very bad investment because, in all likelihood, getting back what you invested will take too long. This is because of the time-value of money. Any resource can be put to some use and if you start early you will get the most out of it. This is completely separate from the economic concept of inflation; instead it is based on the concept of mercantilism. The idea that, through savvy business transactions, you can turn a small amount of money into a larger amount of money over time.
  • "A good investment outperforms its opportunity cost." This is the correct answer, but the hardest to see. People tend to be poor at evaluating the opportunity cost of their decisions. Sometimes the decisions are difficult to stomach. In a financial crisis your money might be safer in your mattress at home than it is in the stock market. It might provide more value in another country's currency. Maybe there is simply no value to be had and you have to find the alternative that simply minimizes your losses. A lot of people lose hope; they tend to give up entirely instead of micromanaging a losing proposition. The highest value alternative is the one that you should always take. Whether you end up ahead or behind, you will have done the best you could and you never know when mitigating a bad situation by taking only a small loss with give you an edge in the future. 
Phew. That was a lot to go over, but I wanted to make sure you got the whole picture because this stuff is important. A keen understanding of these theoretical principles will make you better at literally EVERYTHING, not just games. Let's take a look at how these three schools of thought translate to Magic. 

Return on Investment - This metric pushes you to get the most value out of the resources you spend. If you aren't getting a high return on investment you are mostly likely wasting your resources. This is a problem in Magic because you gave away X amount of your resources, but didn't receive X amount of benefit in exchange. Now, your opponent is ahead by the difference and will be for the rest of the game. It is easy to see how this will make it to difficult to win unless the situation changes. Imagine getting something on sale. You spent less for the same amount of value. Which would you rather have, a Grizzly Bears or a Gray Ogre? 

Time-Value of Money - The decisions you make have consequences that might not be immediate. You could spend a lot now, but get back even more in the long term. If that's the case then you need to make sure your investments account for the time-value of your resources. The person whose investments consistently outperform their expected time value is going to be dramatically advantaged to win the game. This is easiest to see in a race situation. You and your opponent both spend three mana. You get a 3/2 and your opponent gets a 2/3. If neither of you can ever block you will win substantially faster. Your investment pays off in more damage than your opponents investment did, and the longer this stays true the further ahead you will get.

Highest Value Alternative - So now we get to the tricky part. Magic is a tough game. Even if you have the best deck in the room you still have to play it. There will be wins and losses, bad beats and fist pumps galore, but being able to OPTIMALLY pilot your way through a single game will require making the right choices several times in a row without the benefits of unlimited time or perfect information. So how are you supposed to navigate the figurative sea of options to land upon the shores of success? Well, the first one is to tease your audience and then leave them hanging...

In next week's In General we will be talking about several different cards, types of cards, and strategies that make good use of them. By doing this we are hoping to come up with a unifying set of characteristics that will show us which investment cards to play and which ones to avoid!

-GG

Saturday, January 18, 2014

The Stack #43- The "Tech"tonic Edge

It's another Saturday, another Stack episode here Zoners.

Continuing our little 2014 theme here, we're talking lands.

Though my love of basic lands is no secret, I do not deny the inherent advantages of non-basics. From the new, expensive, and obvious Nykthos to the silent, cheap, and colorless Mystifying Maze, shaping mana bases with certain pieces of tech can power up your design in ways you probably never thought before.

Today we've got not only our favorite pieces of tech to date, but also the ways we are using them. So let's get started! THIS IS THE STACK!

JOHNNY CONFIDANT'S PICK
Johnny Confidant-  THUMBS UP
I lean heavily into my life in my Karador deck to put me farther ahead than my opponents. It's really similar to a suicide Black strategy. I found myself needing more and more ways to gain what I lost to survive the end game until I'm the victor.

That's where this little morsel comes into play. Since I'm not a big aggressor, I wait on this most of the time; using it as a deterrent. "Chump blocking" with a Deathtouch creature usually is enough to keep me safe for a turn or two. The Lifelink aspect, as previously stated, is a nice bonus and a great option should I need to go on the attack. All in all I can't get enough of this card.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Nifty land is nifty. I have several personal New Year's Resolutions I set for me as a Commander player. Part of that is creating good designs for the remaining guild color combos I call "unloved." The Orzhov Church Mafia is just one of the color schemes for which I hope to make a nice list. And I'll probably be playing this card in it when I can get some of these other goals accomplished.

The cool thing I want to point out with this card is that it's a pretty nice effect in something like Sydri, or as JC mentioned, in Karador. Decks about non-token dudes are the places this card needs to be. In most cases, that might not be in this color scheme's natural inclinations.

Grandpa Growth - THUMBS UP
I haven't played this, but that doesn't mean I wouldn't play this. It is a very powerful effect for a land to have. It is certainly expensive to activate, but the effectiveness scales up quickly when board states become more crowded. I have two problems with this card though, and they are what has held me back from playing with it in Commander. First, Black/White is not a color combination I want to go in on. There is just too much overlap and the generals are comparatively weak. Esper is well established, but basically every other permutation leaves something to be desired. Blue and Green are the best colors in the format. As strong as this card is, I would need a much bigger incentive before I commit to not playing both of them. Secondly, I don't want to be in the situation where I have a board full of things that are begging to be caught in a sweeper, which limits the effectiveness of this card. White and Black together have access to about 95% percent of the sweepers in the format. Not playing them would be foolish, they are too powerful to cut. So naturally, this will become less relevant when the boards get smaller.


Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
I use this land in my Obzedat deck and it has proven indispensable in my life gain/life loss combos with the Vizkopa Guildmage and Sanguine Bond. Having a field of Lifelink/Deathtouch creatures is not absolutely necessary, nor even desirable as GG pointed out; but I think it can be advantageous even at small scales. Being able to give these effects to even two creatures is well worth the four (technically five) mana you'd spend.

VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Sun Tzu has begun to tinge my style of playing MTG recently. There is a quote from him that goes something like "when able to attack, we must seem unable." I've applied this to a defensive removal strategy. Creatures with Flash can sometimes be as good or better than instant speed removal spells against attacking creatures, but not all good creatures have Flash. Hence, the importance of this gem of a land that I've found.

Before, I was using Alchemist's refuge as a way to give my creatures flash, but that requires Blue and Green mana specifically, which meant limited use in Simic, Bant, BUG, and RUG decks, often times limiting your choices of creature based on available mana. Though the Refuge also lends use to Artifacts and Enchantments, Winding Canyons is not a land to scoff at.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
Anytime you can gain pseudo-extra turns is a huge gain. Granted Winding Canyons only allows for creatures to be flashed for surprise blockers or end of turn bomb drops. These types of lands are huge for those beefy Mono green, Naya or Jund decks that don't have access to counter spells and can use these once the control player overextends or simply taps out.

Uncle Landdrops-  THUMBS UP
My Winding Canyons has been moving around from deck to deck, still trying to find a home where it's my first target. For a while it was stashed away in Yeva as a backup plan, but I never had much problem with Plan A, so it was just redundant. I'm hoping to get it somewhere where it will be feared again.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
My copies of Winding Canyons have seen a lot of use over the last few years. Having this in play allows and deck to assume the strategic position of Aggro-Control: an enviable aerie of unparalleled success. This allows you to maximize the time value of your mana and enables you to spend it on the most relevant things. You can leave up mana for counters and removal, but still have the ability to play threats on the opponent's turn. This is an unassuming card, but punishes stumbling harshly.

GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Shinka, the Bloodsoaked KeepShizo, Death's Storehouse


Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I hope we revisit this topic early and often; it is essentially Super Secret Sunday, but on Saturday. Who doesn't like learning about new tech?! Scrubs, that's who. I wanted to preach the virtues of Scrying Sheets or Diamond Valley. I have a list of cards a mile long for this conversation, but alas they will have to wait for another day. I make no secret of it, I loved Kamigawa block. This was the first cycle of legendary lands since either Urza's Block. That's a sizable chunk of time.

These lands aren't searchable, but other than that they are perfect. They produce colored mana, enter the battlefield untapped, and provide a relevant effect. In Commander you always have access to a target for these, even if it isn't your creature that gets targeted. The other members of the cycle are much more narrow in scope, but they still end up seeing more play! Minamo has Merieke, but Shink and Shizo are just substantially better than Okina and Eiganjo. If you have a 1-2 color deck that doesn't specifically need basics, use these.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
Jumping on the band wagon here, these lands are solid enhancements to any deck that already has a strong land balance. I've seen 5-color decks running at least Shizo for Fear and it's super easy to fetch up with cards like Tolara West, and Captain Sisay due to its Legendary type.

Legendary Lands to me are always a solid go-to if your building in those colors or have room for some colorless slots. Too bad we can't use Karakas though. I'd also like to give an Honorable mention to Nykthos our newest Legendary Land. Devotion is a great way to net mana, Not just in Mono-color decks, but I've seen that land do some work in decks with as many as three colors. Pick them up while they are still cheap-ish Zoners.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Kamigawa has always been a block of mixed feelings for me, but mostly curiosity. The amount of Legendary Creatures (and other things) from that set provides plenty of neat commanders. These lands are certainly neat for their creature-buffing tech, but we also mustn't forget lands for mana's sake (I'm referring to Untaidake).

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
This whole cycle's pretty cool. I've used almost all these lands in one way or another. Shizo's pretty hot tech in the Horobi list, and I've actually played Okina and Eiganjo more often than you think. Because of its underrated qualities, Okina really gives people a hard time in combat with Yeva when I make them remember that I play silly lands with combat tricks. The same goes for an unarmed Daxos and the land our playgroup calls "Django Castle."

UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK 

Uncle Landdrops-  THUMBS UP
I use the Mirrodin Artifact Lands to do so many different things. Though they are weaker from a removal standpoint, decks with card advantage really don't care too much about these going to the graveyard. In tight spots, they can turn Trinket Mages into Borderland Rangers. They can draw you extra cards off Trading Post. Turning on Metalcraft really doesn't begin to describe the tricky stuff I've done with this cycle. I use them a lot, often more than just for tapping mana.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS DOWN
Not too much of a fan unfortunately, it seems a bit contradictory due to the fact that I previously mentioned I like devotion, but not Metalcraft.

To me Devotion has a stronger synergy with EDH as well as it gives me more interesting options. With devotion the more mana symbols I play in my permanents the higher it goes. Where as in Metalcraft all I need is artifacts (here's looking at you Darksteel Relic). The second reason is that there are more beneficial effects coming out of devotion, More mana, Big Creatures, and splashy effects to be had.

In a artifact heavy deck, unless I were playing Sharuum, I wouldn't even consider running these.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I play the artifact lands often, they are not very exciting anymore - certainly not like they were in the old days, what with all the breaking of ground and formats. These cards were nearly banned in Standard and completely deserved it. Now they do a lot of fun things in Commander. They can serve as fuel for things like Master Transmuter or an additional name for Realms Uncharted. They give you a different card type so they be searched up by different tutor effects. You may not want to use your Enlightened Tutor on a land, but that flexibility doesn't cost you anything.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
I'm a fan of Metalcraft and I've tried hard for the past year to make a Metalcraft deck that works well and can activate early on in the game. I've stuffed it full of cheap trinkets (as well as the Trinket Mage) and with Uncle Landdrops as my witness, I even resorted to having Memnite Shyamalam in there just for a quick turn one artifact creature. The only thing keeping me from stuffing a Seat of the Synod in that deck is the price and availability of the Mirrodin lands in my area. Plus a Darksteel Citadel is good enough for now, and it will survive Armageddon and the Worldslayer.

We only ever have a few spots to share tech, but I know there's some we haven't thought of. As always, feel free to share with us your favorites or thoughts on ours in the comments below.

Be sure to tune in tomorrow for Grandpa Growth's continuing discussion on Investments and Engines.

Until next time Zoners- The Power is Yours!

-UL/GG/VJ/JC

Friday, January 17, 2014

TGZ News: MtG Money, Movies, and m-SPOILERS

Big news this week in Magic! Wizards now has a license to print money in different currencies, Fox leaves a paper trail that leads to an MtG movie, GP Sacramento starts tomorrow, and the first week of Born of the Gods spoilers is in the books.

Wizards announced that they would be partnering with the government of New Zealand to produce collector's coins featuring Magic. The coins are pure 0.999 silver and feature a full color print of Jace the Mind Sculptor on one face and a relief portrait of Queen Elizabeth II on the opposite face. The announcement on the mothership did not specify if this was the first of an ongoing series of releases or a single-release project. There has not yet been a initial offering price listed, but it should be noted that these special two dollar coins are going to receive a limited print run and will only be available while supplies last. If you ask me this is taking MtG financial speculation to a whole new level.
http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Article.aspx?x=mtg/daily/news/281

The Hollywood Reporter is, well...reporting, that 21st Century Fox has made an agreement with Wizards to buy the film rights to Magic the Gathering. This would obviously lead the speculation that an upcoming film adaptation of some aspect of the games story will become a reality in the next few years. As of yet, there has not been an official announcement from either party about the project, but here is my pitch for a potential plot: Life for a teenager at Planeswalker High School isn't all that it's cracked up to be. In this whirlwind romantic comedy we meet Jace (played by Jared Leto) as he is struggling to fit into with his new planeswalking friends. It is up to him to balance class, spells, and the love of his life, Chandra (played by Alyson Hannigan), but can he prove to her that he is the strongest spell slinger in the multiverse by beating the captain of the sportsball team Gideon Jura (played by Josh Duhamel), in a duel?! Sweet god I hope not.
http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/fox-bring-magic-gathering-big-670529

This weekend is Grand Prix Sacramento! This is the final premier level event for Theros limited before we see the format shaken up by the release of Born of the Gods. You can catch live video coverage of every round at GGs Live, including both days, top 8, deck techs, interviews and more, with commentary by Matt Sperling, Ben Starke, and Marshall Sutcliffe. I don't need much of an excuse to watch more Magic, but how could I say no to watching Ben Starke balk in disgust every time someone makes a pun?
www.ggslive.com

Speaking of Born of the Gods, the first spoiler week has come and gone and there is plenty of awesome stuff to be excited about. New keyword mechanics, 5 new multicolor gods, a sweet Kiora planeswalker, and more to come soon. Check out the image gallery for the latest cards as they are spoiled.
http://www.wizards.com/magic/tcg/article.aspx?x=mtg/tcg/bornofthegods/cig#

Next up on TGZ we have The Stack tomorrow and In General on Sunday! See you next week Zoners!

-GG

Wednesday, January 15, 2014

SNAP KEEP!? #2

Hey Zoners! Born of the Gods spoiler week is well under way now and some great new cards have really been spoiled. I can't wait to start cracking packs and digging into all the goodies. Five new Gods, three new dual lands, two new mechanics, and at least one new planeswalker! Color me excited. The release date is just around the corner and I can't wait.

We are back here with another Snap Keep and we have a wild one. This is one of my all-time great calls. Here is the story: Four players. Kitchen table rules against my old college roommates. Old school EDH. I open up this as my starting seven, with an additional card to draw on my first turn. I am playing Nicol Bolas, my old standby. My opponents are on Vaevictus Asmadi land destruction, Sen Triplets artifact theme, and Captain Sisay.



Savvy players will notice that this hand does not contain any lands. That might be a problem...FOR COWARDS! I have 45 lands left in the deck and two chances to hit thanks to our Gitaxian Probe. If we get a single land we can go all in on the turn two Bribery and force the game to be hilarious. The probe will show me if I am up against any disruption, since there is only one other Blue deck at the table. I knew going into the game that the Sen Triplets player had Tinker/Blightsteel in deck. The Sisay player obviously has a ton of juicy targets and I knew for sure that he had Ulamog. Because of this I felt pretty secure about being able to get at least one kill with whatever I get and having a reasonable chance to win the game immediately. My main concern was eliminating the White players as soon as possible because the likelihood of one of them having removal is very high. Swords to Plowshares or Path to Exile are just much more likely than an edict effect from the Jund deck. Worse comes to worst, things will be very interesting whether I draw the land or not and at the very least I had an interesting story to tell. I think what really sells this hand is the completely uncastable Cruel Ultimatum. How could you say no to that?

I don't want to spoil the ending of the story before you guys get a chance to weigh in on the subject. So, with all the information I have shared...would you keep this?