Hey Zoners! I know it was a slow week on the cosmetic side of TGZ, but behind the scenes there was a lot of planeswalking in the real for me (A puppy and a part-time job, nbd) and discussion to be had about the creative direction of our Saturday discussion.
Unsure about what the readers want, we've had quite a bit of dialogue about what might be the way to keep The Stack being fun and interesting.
And after a few days of getting all of my radical changes rejected, we just decided we're going to get (slightly) more nutty with our topics.
ALSO- we'd like to bring in guest opinions for future episodes of The Stack. So if you're interested in being part of our Saturdays here at TGZ, please email me at unclelanddrops@gmail.com.
That said, today's special Stack dish is being served up with this preamble:
Which creature would you most like to cheat in off an activated Quest for Ula's Temple? or, What is your favorite Octopus, Kraken, Serpent, or Leviathan?
The answers are all here, so let's see what's good.
So in the immortal words of Liam "Zeus" Neeson, THIS IS THE STACK. I mean,
VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS DOWN
This card has always been on my list of Creatures that Deserve Better Abilities. Aside from being an avid fan of the Azorius Guild and flicker mechanics, I'm also an octopus lover (guess what my favorite Beatles song is), and of the three octopuses in the MTG universe, you'd think that Lorthos the Freshmaker would have more to contribute than paying 8 mana to freeze 8 permanents.
Okay, so tapping 8 things down for essentially two turns is really badass and can be helpful (or annoying), but he's already an 8-drop 8/8, so I'd think his ability would be cheaper or he would be able to do more cool things. Plus, for a Blue creature, he doesn't have much "sneak value," like Islandwalk or activated abilities that do not require an attack.
My first chance actually playing the Freshmaker proved very bad for me because I couldn't use his ability without leaving myself without mana for responses. He managed to do exactly 8 damage for the seven turns he was out on the field. Heck, the mana cost alone would necessitate Quest for Ula's Temple, since hard-casting him is not always feasible in a game of Commander.
So, Wizards, this is my plea to you: come out with better Octopus creature types so that I do not have to admit that Lorthos is the best cephalopod out of Ula's Temple.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Normally, I'm very much in on the card nickname jokes, but I feel fairly ostracized from Lorthos' connection/obsession with Mentos. I don't really get it, and though I do come up with a lot of nicknames that I think most people wouldn't get either, this one is just too baffling. I feel like there's supposed to be some actual connection that makes this funnier, but then it doesn't.
Anywho, I'm pretty excited because I was promised this week that there will be a Lorthos deck coming to a playgroup near me. I have no idea what's going on, or where the parents are actually at in this circumstance, but I'm interested in seeing where it's going.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
Have I cast this card? Yes. I wasn't even embarrassed. Even though I have played it, I won't give it a thumbs up. This was really the last of a dying breed for me. Once the Eldrazi came out, Lorthos' fifteen minutes were up. It is way easier to make an arbitrary amount of colorless mana than it is to make three Blue mana, even in a Blue deck. That should tell you something about what I think of the 'big Blue' Creature theme. Now, if you are chasing after a magical moment where you get to totally humiliate your friends for that awesome one-timer story, it is hard to go wrong with this guy. It, as stated, is an octopus. You have to feel violated when you're getting ruffed up by tentacles. Cue raging anime fans.
GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
So...this isn't really a thing that I would ever do. I am not saying this is a bad strategy, but it is one that I tend to stay away from. For the sake of fun though, I am going to fully embrace this topic. Assuming we are playing a deck full of huge things we don't necessarily want them to clog up our draws and make our early game bad. We still need a sufficient density of cards to put counters on the quest card AND a fatty to throw down when we "get there". I would like to have an Inkwell Leviathan to throw in, but Grozoth could be just as good. Putting this into play allows us to refill our hand with several Inkwells and potentially other copies of Grozoth as well. It is like a big Blue Squadron Hawk....that has Defender and Transmute. I don't know what I am doing here.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I can dig it. Obviously, the Ula's Temple deck is going to get us a couple of nonsense things, but this card does "a little bit" of damage in my group. There's a Nin, the Pain Artist deck in my meta that plays control until it can find a Dragonstorm to combo out. Grozoth is one of the many ways the guy has to get there, which I think is at least partially, if not wholly cheeky and original. I like it because there isn't anything else like it, which means it's a nice card to build around.
Here's the Nin Deck too, if you guys want to check it out: Jordanstorm!
UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Well, I can't say it'd be my favorite thing to drop on an activated Quest for Ula's Temple, because I've actually never played it. Way back when, I actually built a 60-card Ula's Temple deck, so I do know a thing or two about it.
What I like about Trench Gorger is that we can scale its power. Greaves is probably really necessary for support when you go all-in exiling your lands on Trench Gorger, but it seems fun to have an alternative way to power up a creature.
I'd also like to point out that when you Gatherer search for all the things Ula's Temple puts into play, there are very few pieces of artwork that I feel really makes me "believe" a creature of this magnitude could be real. TG is one. Isleback Spawn is the other. You don't need to look too far to see a hokey-looking creature (cough Throw-Mo-Crates cough), but if you do, there are plenty amorphous blobs and oversized Barracudas for our topic this week. I was having this discussion the other day with a friend of mine about big sea creature artwork that's just so indiscriminate it doesn't make sense. Here, it's nice to see Leviathan, and feel it too.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I haven't played this before, but I can appreciate what is going on here. You get a big threat now that demands an answer and you also have the promise of a very high threat density going forward. This marginal improvement in the quality of your draws will likely mean that you are going to win the game anyway, but it is nice that this bonus doesn't cost you a card as it comes tacked onto what would otherwise be a kind of silly Creature despite its massive proportions.
That's all we got for today. Remember to email me if you're interested in being a guest, or if you just have suggestion. We'll be back next week to our usual schedule with all new exciting stuff.
Until next time, remember that the only rules are O'Doyle Rules!
-UL/VJ/GG
Saturday, March 15, 2014
Sunday, March 9, 2014
In General: Journey to the Center of the Deck
Welcome back Zoners, it's me Grandpa Growth. The last few weeks of my articles have been building up to the idea of centralization. If you missed the previous weeks I would suggest looking back a few pages to give them a read, but I'll give you the short version here. The Modern metagame is controlled by the use of the banlist. Because it is driven by competitive optimizers, the best deck in the format will always become the most popular and the other decks will either be trying to beat or ignore the best deck. Commander's metagame is more open because it isn't driven through competition. Instead it is driven by fashion. What is popular feeds what is played instead of the strongest decks BECOMING popular. I gave the example that Nekusar, the Mindrazer decks are very popular in my local Commander metagame right now, despite being mediocre at best in terms of performance. That discussion of fashion extends down to the single card level. That is what we are going to be discussing today. How decks become centralized through repetitive copying of information.
Centralization
Centralization is the idea that a deck contains what you would expect it to. The obvious stuff. The popular stuff. This is in opposition to the idea of optomization which would dictate you only include the best possible cards for your deck so that it will win more. This is a result of two things: the complexity of the format and the sources of information. Let's break these down further.
Complexity - Commander is a difficult format to break into at a high level. Quality decks are very expensive and often full of old cards that may not be readily available like Dual Lands. Many times it is difficult to know where to start. 99 unique cards can sometimes be a stretch of the imagination if you are new to the format. You need to have a working knowledge of older sets. Be able to recognize cards that have older iterations or functional equivalents with different names. It is also important to know what decks are popular and what the centralized version of those decks look like. Match-ups play an important part in 1v1 Commander strategy. Knowing what cards are important to in a particular archetype is critical to victory. Are you playing against a Rafiq of the Many deck? You need to know what Finest Hour does.
Sources of Information - So we established that Commander requires a huge pool of knowledge to be good at. It can, at times, be a more wide open Legacy. So where do you go to learn all of this stuff? Most people turn to the internet when they lack experience or information in/on a particular thing. This isn't bad, it is a great place to start and it is certainly faster and cheaper than gaining the experience yourself. However there is a downside. Information propagates very quickly on the web, even false information. People often take information for granted because they "read it somewhere" or "so-and-so said it". Consulting other decklists online and examining them for common cards or packages of cards is a quick way to fill up your deck list with reasonable card choices without having to know anything about the archetype you are building. This is how centralization happens. And bear in mind it does not necessarily contribute to optimization.
Now, An Example
Many Commander players will recognize Momir Vig as a common deck. It has many strengths and allows you to play a powerful color combination full of high value threats and cheap disruption. It also gives you a repeatable tutoring effect, which is powerful AND fun to play with. I am going to rattle off a big list of cards that I would expect to be in a Combo Vig List. You can't see me while I am writing this, but I assure you of two things: I am doing this all from memory and it is only going to take about three minutes.
Lands:
Centralization
Centralization is the idea that a deck contains what you would expect it to. The obvious stuff. The popular stuff. This is in opposition to the idea of optomization which would dictate you only include the best possible cards for your deck so that it will win more. This is a result of two things: the complexity of the format and the sources of information. Let's break these down further.
Complexity - Commander is a difficult format to break into at a high level. Quality decks are very expensive and often full of old cards that may not be readily available like Dual Lands. Many times it is difficult to know where to start. 99 unique cards can sometimes be a stretch of the imagination if you are new to the format. You need to have a working knowledge of older sets. Be able to recognize cards that have older iterations or functional equivalents with different names. It is also important to know what decks are popular and what the centralized version of those decks look like. Match-ups play an important part in 1v1 Commander strategy. Knowing what cards are important to in a particular archetype is critical to victory. Are you playing against a Rafiq of the Many deck? You need to know what Finest Hour does.
Sources of Information - So we established that Commander requires a huge pool of knowledge to be good at. It can, at times, be a more wide open Legacy. So where do you go to learn all of this stuff? Most people turn to the internet when they lack experience or information in/on a particular thing. This isn't bad, it is a great place to start and it is certainly faster and cheaper than gaining the experience yourself. However there is a downside. Information propagates very quickly on the web, even false information. People often take information for granted because they "read it somewhere" or "so-and-so said it". Consulting other decklists online and examining them for common cards or packages of cards is a quick way to fill up your deck list with reasonable card choices without having to know anything about the archetype you are building. This is how centralization happens. And bear in mind it does not necessarily contribute to optimization.
Now, An Example
Many Commander players will recognize Momir Vig as a common deck. It has many strengths and allows you to play a powerful color combination full of high value threats and cheap disruption. It also gives you a repeatable tutoring effect, which is powerful AND fun to play with. I am going to rattle off a big list of cards that I would expect to be in a Combo Vig List. You can't see me while I am writing this, but I assure you of two things: I am doing this all from memory and it is only going to take about three minutes.
Lands:
Gaea’s Cradle
Misty Rain Forest
Some other fetchlands
Breeding pool
Tropical island
Alchemist’s refuge
Flooded Grove
Simic growth chamber
Wasteland
Strip mine
Maze of ith
Yavimaya hollow
Academy ruins
Riptide lab
Winding canyons
Tectonic edge
Temple of the False God
Artifacts:
Sol Ring
Cloudstone Curio
Some other mana
Possibly Top
Possibly Caged Sun
Enchantments:
Heartbeat of Spring
Opposition
Equilibrium
Aluren
Possibly Earthcraft
Instants/Sorceries:
Intuition
Hinder
Spell Crumple
Void Slime
Force of Will
Upheaval
Cryptic Command
Cultivate
Kodama’s Reach
Voidslime
Fact or Fiction
Beast within
Pongify
Counterspell
Planeswalkers:
Jace(s)
Garruk(s)
Tamiyo
Creatures:
Cloud of Faeries
Teferi
Sower of Temptation
Venser
Phyrexian Metamorph
Solemn Simulacrum
Duplicant
Aether Adept
Vendilion Clique
Sakura-Tribe Elder
Loaming Shaman
Wall of Blossoms
Coiling Oracle
Trygon Predator
Mystic Snake
Winged Coatl
Eternal Witness
Terrastodon
Avenger of Zendikar
Craterhoof Behemoth
Seedborn Muse
Acidic Slime
Viridian Shaman
Indrik Stomphowler
Elvish Visionary
Fathom Mage
Progenitor Mimic
Prime Speaker Zegana
Oracle of Mul Daya
Joraga Treespeaker
Courser of Kruphix
maybe Magus of the Future, but let's stop here for now. There are probably a dozen of more obvious things that I forget, but you get the point. These are very common cards in the archetype. You might even say that this is a list of the archetype's staples.
There are some other considerations that I would be able to see after the first game as well. For example, if I saw a Snow-covered basic land I would assume Realms Uncharted. If I saw a second one, I would assume Scrying Sheets. If I saw an Artifact Land, I would assume Trinket Mage, and thus confirming the Sensei's Divining Top and likely a Wayfarer's Bauble and/or Expedition Map.
Now, to be clear: This ISN'T a deck list. I would not advise loading this up and playing it, not even for the fact that it doesn't have the correct number of cards. This is an example, a thought experiment if you will. Thinking about the centralized version of a list will both help you think about what cards you want in deck building, but also within the confines of the game. You will be able to think strategically and predict what cards your opponent has much more accurately if you can infer that a fairly large portion of their deck is essentially public domain. When you're fumbling in the dark, combo Vig can be a very tough deck to beat. You have to compete against a series of high-value, early-game plays and as soon as you are about to stabilize you suddenly die to the combo. However, if you know ahead of time what the opponent's win conditions are, you can save your removal and disruption for the correct pieces. If you stifle the combo in Combo Vig, now they are left with a big pile of cards that doesn't necessarily accomplish a whole lot.
Your homework for this week is to look across the table and ASSUME what is in your opponent's deck. Draw upon all your knowledge. All your experience. Start making a list in your mind. Ask yourself what is in his deck BEFORE YOU EVEN SEE HIS DECK. 20-30 cards could be considered Format Staples that are likely to be found in EVERY deck, so you should know, right off the bat, about a significant portion of his cards. Prepare for them. Once you see his Commander, you should have a pretty good idea about another 30 or so cards just based on the colors and archetype he is playing. So that is that. Centralization. Use it to your advantage. See you guys next week.
-GG
Saturday, March 8, 2014
The Stack #47- Not One of a Kind
Welcome to our 47th episode of The Stack, TGZ's most common Saturday article and home to all the card comments and discussions by our motley gang of Commander players.
Today's installment is all about the unique cards. Wizards has this habit of making weird one-of's that have decent mechanics and could be beneficial for the Commander community. This week, our panel picked a card with a unique set of mechanics, and we want to talk about how many more of these things we want to see.
And this is how it turned out.
Today's installment is all about the unique cards. Wizards has this habit of making weird one-of's that have decent mechanics and could be beneficial for the Commander community. This week, our panel picked a card with a unique set of mechanics, and we want to talk about how many more of these things we want to see.
And this is how it turned out.
VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Protection is a little "overpowered" in some cases, like Spirit Mantle, and some might even call it "mana-racist", as in the case of Knight of Glory, but it really is neat, especially when applied to a CMC. I use this guy in my Rafiq of the Many Voltron deck and he really does wonders when my opponents only have Khalni Hydras and Wurms on defense. His particular protection ability also prevents any Control Magic or Act of Treason style spells from turning him on me when I've beefed him up with Ethereal Armor and Triclopean Sight.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I could go in for some more irregular Protection abilities. Protection from Legendary. Protection from Instants. Protection from activated abilities. I think this keyword is overused, but too often spent on the usual suspects. Prot. Black and White, maybe Red, not much else. I don't necessarily think this would be good for the game, but it would be mildly amusing if the theme of an upcoming block was Protection from Green. Like Oprah bought all the extra Prot. Green and she is just throw them at the audience by the hand full.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I'm with GG on this one, but maybe not to the mass production/mass color hating he's talking about. There's definitely a need to bring balance to the force, but I don't see a single set being good for the format that way. I've been wrong before though.
Pro-Legends and Pro-Instants seem like sweet ideas, as is the strange CMC thing here. Little aggro Daxos likes his "can't be blocked" clause, and it's a pretty similar design here, I think. Pro-Instants might shut most of my decks down.
GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
While I would not play this specific card, the Fateseal mechanic in general is very strong. In fact, it only appears on one other card, Spin into Myth, but has a functional equivalent on Jace the Mind Sculptor. There are also other cards like Ransack which have similar effects, but predated even Scry. I would love to see more of this. The extra information has high strategic value. The extra control is a key decision making point and a true skill tester. Unfortunately, this is unlikely to happen because Fateseal is such a 'griefer' mechanic. It isn't fun to play against and only sadistic bastards like me are into this kind of thing.
What I would really like is a repeatable activated ability...Imagine this:
--
Theoretical Cardname {4}
Artifact
{2}, {T}: Put up to two target cards from a graveyard on top of that player's library in any order.
--
Continually forcing your opponent to draw garbage late in the game. The best part is that they have to relive the horror of drawing a bunch of situational cards that they chose to put into their deck. The punishment! You can't hear it, but I am doing a maniacal villain laugh right now.
Venser's Journalist- ONE THUMB UP, ONE THUMB DOWN
I guess the only reason why I'm on the fence about fateseal is that I haven't had much experience with it (perhaps a stronger argument for it needing to be more pervasive in the MTG community). In theory it does seem like an excellent ability, and because I'm a fan of library manipulation and things like scry, I'm all for anything that allows you to change the "future" in a sense.
My big concern with it is the potential for abuse. Like GG mentioned, this could prove to be sadistic and "un-fun" if people were to build decks around it, but since Extraction mechanics and Psychic Surgery type decks already exist, this would only provide another option for those types of control players.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I'm never playing Mesmeric Sliver, mostly cause I don't play Slivers, but Fateseal is good. I don't want it to invade the metagame the same way I want more cards with say, "Destroy Target Planeswalker," or aggressively costed red creature/enchantment removal, but a few cards will work. I'd like to see a cheap Instant so I could throw it on Isochron Scepter instead.
UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
All I want is a few more permanents that give me a little more casting speed. Wizards has been printing stuff, but really limiting their playability by giving them slightly more technical drawbacks (Like Hypersonic Dragon, Yeva, and Alchemist's Refuge). I don't care what kind of permanent the actual card is, but I'd like to see more enablers for Sorceries, Auras, and Artifacts. Maybe a little lower on the mana curve too. They're powerful, but they're still only as good as the cards you're casting at instant speed. Also- they still cost you a turn.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
There deinitely should be more ways to flex the casting restrictions on your cards. A creature version would be awesome. I would also like to see something that lets you play lands on your opponents turn. That would be a very difficult predication: is he holding an extra land that he can play in order to have counter mana? That is a whole new level of leveling. That idea probably makes some people sick to their stomachs, but the more thinking I have to do in a game the more excited I am about said game.
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Flash all day and night. Teferi would love this artifact, even if it makes the sorceries with flash redundant. Having mana open is a huge part of a lot of decks, and to me makes MTG closer to poker and other bluffing games. Whenever I have open mana, I kind of want to look my opponents in the face while taking a long sip of a martini.
Be sure to leave your picks in the comments below. I'm sure there are good ones we missed.
That's all that's here for today. It is now my intention to sit down and play video games for several hours. Pass Turn.
-UL/VJ/GG
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Protection is a little "overpowered" in some cases, like Spirit Mantle, and some might even call it "mana-racist", as in the case of Knight of Glory, but it really is neat, especially when applied to a CMC. I use this guy in my Rafiq of the Many Voltron deck and he really does wonders when my opponents only have Khalni Hydras and Wurms on defense. His particular protection ability also prevents any Control Magic or Act of Treason style spells from turning him on me when I've beefed him up with Ethereal Armor and Triclopean Sight.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I could go in for some more irregular Protection abilities. Protection from Legendary. Protection from Instants. Protection from activated abilities. I think this keyword is overused, but too often spent on the usual suspects. Prot. Black and White, maybe Red, not much else. I don't necessarily think this would be good for the game, but it would be mildly amusing if the theme of an upcoming block was Protection from Green. Like Oprah bought all the extra Prot. Green and she is just throw them at the audience by the hand full.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I'm with GG on this one, but maybe not to the mass production/mass color hating he's talking about. There's definitely a need to bring balance to the force, but I don't see a single set being good for the format that way. I've been wrong before though.
Pro-Legends and Pro-Instants seem like sweet ideas, as is the strange CMC thing here. Little aggro Daxos likes his "can't be blocked" clause, and it's a pretty similar design here, I think. Pro-Instants might shut most of my decks down.
GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
While I would not play this specific card, the Fateseal mechanic in general is very strong. In fact, it only appears on one other card, Spin into Myth, but has a functional equivalent on Jace the Mind Sculptor. There are also other cards like Ransack which have similar effects, but predated even Scry. I would love to see more of this. The extra information has high strategic value. The extra control is a key decision making point and a true skill tester. Unfortunately, this is unlikely to happen because Fateseal is such a 'griefer' mechanic. It isn't fun to play against and only sadistic bastards like me are into this kind of thing.
What I would really like is a repeatable activated ability...Imagine this:
--
Theoretical Cardname {4}
Artifact
{2}, {T}: Put up to two target cards from a graveyard on top of that player's library in any order.
--
Continually forcing your opponent to draw garbage late in the game. The best part is that they have to relive the horror of drawing a bunch of situational cards that they chose to put into their deck. The punishment! You can't hear it, but I am doing a maniacal villain laugh right now.
Venser's Journalist- ONE THUMB UP, ONE THUMB DOWN
I guess the only reason why I'm on the fence about fateseal is that I haven't had much experience with it (perhaps a stronger argument for it needing to be more pervasive in the MTG community). In theory it does seem like an excellent ability, and because I'm a fan of library manipulation and things like scry, I'm all for anything that allows you to change the "future" in a sense.
My big concern with it is the potential for abuse. Like GG mentioned, this could prove to be sadistic and "un-fun" if people were to build decks around it, but since Extraction mechanics and Psychic Surgery type decks already exist, this would only provide another option for those types of control players.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I'm never playing Mesmeric Sliver, mostly cause I don't play Slivers, but Fateseal is good. I don't want it to invade the metagame the same way I want more cards with say, "Destroy Target Planeswalker," or aggressively costed red creature/enchantment removal, but a few cards will work. I'd like to see a cheap Instant so I could throw it on Isochron Scepter instead.
UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
All I want is a few more permanents that give me a little more casting speed. Wizards has been printing stuff, but really limiting their playability by giving them slightly more technical drawbacks (Like Hypersonic Dragon, Yeva, and Alchemist's Refuge). I don't care what kind of permanent the actual card is, but I'd like to see more enablers for Sorceries, Auras, and Artifacts. Maybe a little lower on the mana curve too. They're powerful, but they're still only as good as the cards you're casting at instant speed. Also- they still cost you a turn.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
There deinitely should be more ways to flex the casting restrictions on your cards. A creature version would be awesome. I would also like to see something that lets you play lands on your opponents turn. That would be a very difficult predication: is he holding an extra land that he can play in order to have counter mana? That is a whole new level of leveling. That idea probably makes some people sick to their stomachs, but the more thinking I have to do in a game the more excited I am about said game.
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Flash all day and night. Teferi would love this artifact, even if it makes the sorceries with flash redundant. Having mana open is a huge part of a lot of decks, and to me makes MTG closer to poker and other bluffing games. Whenever I have open mana, I kind of want to look my opponents in the face while taking a long sip of a martini.
Be sure to leave your picks in the comments below. I'm sure there are good ones we missed.
That's all that's here for today. It is now my intention to sit down and play video games for several hours. Pass Turn.
-UL/VJ/GG
Thursday, March 6, 2014
UL's Better Deckbuilding: Silvos, Rogue Elemental EDH
Heya Zoners!
Landdrops is back again with another installment of Better Deckbuilding.
I know it hasn't been too long since the last one, but I've got quite a few in the works, and whether it's the lucky "W" I picked up in a sweet match last night, or the fact that I've got so many new decks coming down the pipeline that I need to talk about ones I haven't even talked about yet, we're here. Either way, it's good news for the TGZ faithful out there- more decklists is way more fun, all the time.
So I don't remember if I mentioned it or not, but Yeva's been enjoying a nice little pension and sipping pina coladas on some remote island for a while, enjoying her retirement. I was told she won't be missed, and that's fine.
But much like a crappy hydra, when one of my monochromatic "heads" gets chopped off, something needs to grow back.
Enter Silvos, the biggest, beatdown-iest Bulbasaur-like thing of a Hulk I could find when I was trolling for new mono-Green leadership.
WHY SILVOS?
Having played Yeva so long, I felt that I'd lost sight of my green roots, and I wanted to get back. When I first started playing Commander, Grandpa Growth and I liked to pick generals based on their ability to damage and regenerate when all our plans went to mush. Silvos had been a guy on my radar for a long time, and when our games started getting more technical, and I needed different kinds of support, he kinda went backwards in line.
However, since I began creating my monochromatic decks, I've had this idea for a strong Voltron-based Green deck that incorporated more of Green's contribution to the color pie- ramp, combat tricks, and just generally being the big beatstick on the block. Thanks to several new cards and the re-emergence of Chroma as Devotion, this deck had some design space to work with.
THE STRATEGY
Essentially, Silvos was genetically engineered in the Mirari for 21 damage beats. In my playing of the deck so far, it has been the most efficient and effective way to get the game over with, and we do it by any means necessary, whether it's a few choice equipment, Auras, or even combat tricks.
Having so many different kinds of pump methods for Silvos means the deck is able to put a much more serious clock on an opponent than they might expect. With trample, and a regenerate trigger supported by ramp, and natural tutor power for tuck effects, chances are we're probably not going to lose our 3GGG investment on Silvos.
Not only does this mean we're going to have our Commander beating face, but it also means we have three green mana symbols, which gives us a nice solid chunk of Devotion. This is one of the new qualities that Theros has brought out int he 8/5 Elemental, and something I thought would be a nice thing to exploit that's kinda different than the better green decks, Omnath and Azusa.
THE TECH
We'll start off with perhaps the most obvious card. In a deck where creatures and spells both put lands into play, this card is mega value of the highest degree.
I finally got this card out of the deck last night, and netted about 15 life, six +1/+1 counters, and four beast tokens- all in about 4-5 turns.
My playtests of the card had given me a little taste of this, but until the moment arrived, the power of this card was still not fully understood.
Now, I get it. The +1/+1 counters are incredible on Silvos, and the life gain is a significant improvement from just playing Nylea's Disciple.
Canopy Cover is really underrated. Not only does it provide evasion in the colors of stompy creatures, but it also provides protection.
This is one of the cheeky ways I can build into Silvos, and one of his pieces of protection. If Cover resolves, you're not doing much in the way of stopping me.
Although flying and reach are probably in any decent deck, it's still not terrible. Most people want to attack with their flying creatures against green decks, this is a nice budget card that can get the job done if you've got a green Aura-Voltron deck or just a deck that needs something like this.
At long last, I finally made this card ridiculous. Previously seen in early episodes of The Stack, and possibly in many other decks, I finally got this card out with a way to dig into optimal disruption.
Seriously- you should've seen the amount of times I cast Krosan Grip, cycled Krosan Tusker, and Beast Within'ed in the game I was in last night.
When you have real stuff to go get, this card is seriously bananas when the deck has a fairly balanced amount of permanents, or is really deep in relevant kinds, like creatures and instants.
Definitely an All-Star where I've got it, and it's about time.
Greater Good is a fantastic card, but I don't want to play it in every deck (especially considering how much I abuse it in the one deck I do play it in).
So for all those times I don't have Greater Good, this is Momentous Fall aka the Tempo Draw Spell. It's pretty great, facilitating both relevant life gain and powerful card draw.
I've comboed this card with a Reincarnation before, and so that's a thing- but even if you aren't, hopefully you're refilling your hand or getting the card(s) you need.
The last card I'm going to talk about is Primal Bellow. GG used to have a 60-card deck where he beat the tar out of our little playgroup with big dudes and this card. Though it isn't very good, it's still kind of good with some support and proper tempo.
The cheap casting cost of this card makes it probably the best little spell I play short of Berserk, which I can't justify buying yet. So budget begets budget, and playing Primal Bellow has been a nice spell anyway.
Well, that's all I got for today. Here's my list, so you can comment, +1, or critique.
UL's Silvos, Rogue Elemental EDH
Until then, take it sleazy.
-UL
Landdrops is back again with another installment of Better Deckbuilding.
I know it hasn't been too long since the last one, but I've got quite a few in the works, and whether it's the lucky "W" I picked up in a sweet match last night, or the fact that I've got so many new decks coming down the pipeline that I need to talk about ones I haven't even talked about yet, we're here. Either way, it's good news for the TGZ faithful out there- more decklists is way more fun, all the time.
So I don't remember if I mentioned it or not, but Yeva's been enjoying a nice little pension and sipping pina coladas on some remote island for a while, enjoying her retirement. I was told she won't be missed, and that's fine.
But much like a crappy hydra, when one of my monochromatic "heads" gets chopped off, something needs to grow back.
Enter Silvos, the biggest, beatdown-iest Bulbasaur-like thing of a Hulk I could find when I was trolling for new mono-Green leadership.
WHY SILVOS?
Having played Yeva so long, I felt that I'd lost sight of my green roots, and I wanted to get back. When I first started playing Commander, Grandpa Growth and I liked to pick generals based on their ability to damage and regenerate when all our plans went to mush. Silvos had been a guy on my radar for a long time, and when our games started getting more technical, and I needed different kinds of support, he kinda went backwards in line.
However, since I began creating my monochromatic decks, I've had this idea for a strong Voltron-based Green deck that incorporated more of Green's contribution to the color pie- ramp, combat tricks, and just generally being the big beatstick on the block. Thanks to several new cards and the re-emergence of Chroma as Devotion, this deck had some design space to work with.
THE STRATEGY
Essentially, Silvos was genetically engineered in the Mirari for 21 damage beats. In my playing of the deck so far, it has been the most efficient and effective way to get the game over with, and we do it by any means necessary, whether it's a few choice equipment, Auras, or even combat tricks.
Having so many different kinds of pump methods for Silvos means the deck is able to put a much more serious clock on an opponent than they might expect. With trample, and a regenerate trigger supported by ramp, and natural tutor power for tuck effects, chances are we're probably not going to lose our 3GGG investment on Silvos.
Not only does this mean we're going to have our Commander beating face, but it also means we have three green mana symbols, which gives us a nice solid chunk of Devotion. This is one of the new qualities that Theros has brought out int he 8/5 Elemental, and something I thought would be a nice thing to exploit that's kinda different than the better green decks, Omnath and Azusa.
THE TECH
We'll start off with perhaps the most obvious card. In a deck where creatures and spells both put lands into play, this card is mega value of the highest degree.
I finally got this card out of the deck last night, and netted about 15 life, six +1/+1 counters, and four beast tokens- all in about 4-5 turns.
My playtests of the card had given me a little taste of this, but until the moment arrived, the power of this card was still not fully understood.
Now, I get it. The +1/+1 counters are incredible on Silvos, and the life gain is a significant improvement from just playing Nylea's Disciple.
Canopy Cover is really underrated. Not only does it provide evasion in the colors of stompy creatures, but it also provides protection.
This is one of the cheeky ways I can build into Silvos, and one of his pieces of protection. If Cover resolves, you're not doing much in the way of stopping me.
Although flying and reach are probably in any decent deck, it's still not terrible. Most people want to attack with their flying creatures against green decks, this is a nice budget card that can get the job done if you've got a green Aura-Voltron deck or just a deck that needs something like this.
At long last, I finally made this card ridiculous. Previously seen in early episodes of The Stack, and possibly in many other decks, I finally got this card out with a way to dig into optimal disruption.
Seriously- you should've seen the amount of times I cast Krosan Grip, cycled Krosan Tusker, and Beast Within'ed in the game I was in last night.
When you have real stuff to go get, this card is seriously bananas when the deck has a fairly balanced amount of permanents, or is really deep in relevant kinds, like creatures and instants.
Definitely an All-Star where I've got it, and it's about time.
Greater Good is a fantastic card, but I don't want to play it in every deck (especially considering how much I abuse it in the one deck I do play it in).
So for all those times I don't have Greater Good, this is Momentous Fall aka the Tempo Draw Spell. It's pretty great, facilitating both relevant life gain and powerful card draw.
I've comboed this card with a Reincarnation before, and so that's a thing- but even if you aren't, hopefully you're refilling your hand or getting the card(s) you need.
The last card I'm going to talk about is Primal Bellow. GG used to have a 60-card deck where he beat the tar out of our little playgroup with big dudes and this card. Though it isn't very good, it's still kind of good with some support and proper tempo.
The cheap casting cost of this card makes it probably the best little spell I play short of Berserk, which I can't justify buying yet. So budget begets budget, and playing Primal Bellow has been a nice spell anyway.
Well, that's all I got for today. Here's my list, so you can comment, +1, or critique.
UL's Silvos, Rogue Elemental EDH
Until then, take it sleazy.
-UL
Labels:
Better Deckbuilding,
Commander,
EDH,
Mono-Green,
Rogue Elemental,
Silvos,
Voltron
Sunday, March 2, 2014
In General: Fashion is Danger
Once again it is Sunday. Once again I, Grandpa Growth, am here with another In General. Today I will be fulfilling my promise of discussing how the metagame of Commander is shaped. Last week, we took a look at the idea of metagame composition: the breakdown of what decks are viable in a competitive format and what percentage of the total player base each archetype accounts for. Specifically in Modern with how Wizards has used the Modern banned list to control what the composition of the metagame looks like.
It is easy to explain how a metagame composition develops in a competitive environment. Because people are motivated to win tournaments, they need to be playing a deck that can win consistently. So a plurality, if not a majority, will be playing the deck that they think is the best in the format; meaning that it consistently wins in the majority of matchups. Sometimes that edge is thin, but in large enough sample sizes, a 55-45 edge in 75% of the potential matchups will become a substantial factor in deciding what deck to play. Historically, most of the 'best decks in the format' are not much better than 55-45 in general, but again I must stress: that is a significant edge.
Now a second contingent of people will be playing a different deck, one that is not as good against a variety of decks, but is favored against the 'best deck'. So you are a 40-60 underdog in 66% of the matchups, but a 80-20 favorite in the most frequent matchup. This is a fundamental kernel of deck selection strategy. This choice is a big part of what people mean when they say "metagaming" in the context of Magic formats.
There will also be some people playing other 'rogue' decks, or 'pet decks', or 'home brews', but when a particular format's metagame composition is stable, most people will either be playing the best deck, or trying to exclusively beat the best deck at the cost of all others. That is how things end up when the decision process is competition...but Commander isn't really all that competitive for most people. So how do you assemble a metagame in a format where people don't strategically optimize their metagame decision making?
The answer is simple...Fashion. Cue video.
Since I am a dispenser of knowledge and opinions, part psychologist, part life coach, part philospher...part analyst...mostly cartoon rabbit - I forgot where I was going with this, but the important takeaway is: if you haven't watched The Flight of the Conchords you need to. It is my legal and moral responsibility to distribute this public service announcement to as many people as I can. In the above clip we see how the normally dorky Brett and Jermaine are transformed into fashion forward heart throbs by a bottle of hair gel. I am starting to imagine the confused looks on some of your faces. The brows all-a-furl with the burning question: "Grandpa, what does any of this have to do with Commander?"
Competitive environments are dominated by the best optimizers. You win more, you propagate more. Casual environments in Magic are dominated by fashion. It is not what wins the most that becomes popular, but what has the most 'it' factor. It is the newest, the funnest, the flashiest, the most underground, the most retro, the most gimmicky - whatever the cool thing of the moment is, you want to be doing that.
Think back, if you will, a few years ago. Before the first Commander product was released by Wizards, there was a distinct lack of enemy-color "wedge" commanders. Or Generals, as they were called then, I suppose. You could play the Planar Chaos dragons, and a small smattering of other choices like Doran the Siege Tower, but all-in-all your choices were limited. You didn't see many Green/Black/White or Black/Blue/Green decks. Suddenly, when the Commander pre-cons came out, everyone wanted to play a Kaalia of the Vast deck. Karador, Ghost Chieftan. The Mimeoplasm. These decks were literally everywhere. The convenience and price of the Commander product brought new players into the format and got old players excited about new cards. The metagame was dominated by these new Legendary Creatures, not because they were better cards or strategies than previous offerings (in fact in many cases they were just flat-out worse, ask UL about his opinion of The Mimeoplasm), but because they were fashionable at that moment. Of course, over time, their popularity has waned. Some, like Ghave and Animar, have stuck around and carved out permanent niches in the Commander metagame, but the others have died out. When was the last time you heard someone rave about how good their Damia, Sage of Stone deck was? The same happened with the Avacyn Restored angels, the RTR champions, etc. The evidence is beyond dispute. Without competition to sculpt better strategic deck choices, the format instead moves through phases like seasonal fashions. People play the newest stuff until they get bored, dig out an old favorite and pair it up with a newly printed enabler, or maybe they give mono color a shot based on some new mechanic that gets printed, but eventually things settle back down until the next 'fashion show'.
Don't misunderstand, I am not condemning this. It is in no way bad. It is fun. It is exciting. It keeps things fresh...or fresher at least and it requires less maintenance than altering a banned list every few months. As a side effect though, some weird things happen. When you want to try out a new archetype it is tough to know where to start. What cards do you start in your 99? Well an easy way to get an idea is to just look at other people's deck lists. This is how it typically happens too. You do a 10 minute Google search, look for some common threads, incorporate them into your deck and fill up the rest with your personal favorites or some new techy pet cards you want to try out to give the deck your own personal flair. If you repeat this process a few thousand times for every potential commander, then you start to see how the same cards are always popping up in a particular deck. Instead of being OPTIMIZED, i.e. choosing the cards to win the most games, decklists become CENTRALIZED, i.e. including more 'staple' cards that are common to the most viewed online lists and deck techs. A centralized deck is one that contains the cards that you would EXPECT to see in it, whether they are actually the best strategic choices or not. Think about your local metagame or even - GASP - your own decks! They are probably very centralized, with a few random exceptions for "hipster" decks or 'secret tech' cards.
This will be the focus of next weeks article. Centralization...and how it became the dominant deckbuilding principle in Commander.
I hope you have been enjoying this somewhat unconventional article series, because it is going to continue at least for the next few weeks. Remember to like/comment/favorite/subscribe/hashtag/retweet/pin/whatever it is you are supposed to do...I don't understand how to internet. And remember my friend: Fashion is danger.
-GG
It is easy to explain how a metagame composition develops in a competitive environment. Because people are motivated to win tournaments, they need to be playing a deck that can win consistently. So a plurality, if not a majority, will be playing the deck that they think is the best in the format; meaning that it consistently wins in the majority of matchups. Sometimes that edge is thin, but in large enough sample sizes, a 55-45 edge in 75% of the potential matchups will become a substantial factor in deciding what deck to play. Historically, most of the 'best decks in the format' are not much better than 55-45 in general, but again I must stress: that is a significant edge.
Now a second contingent of people will be playing a different deck, one that is not as good against a variety of decks, but is favored against the 'best deck'. So you are a 40-60 underdog in 66% of the matchups, but a 80-20 favorite in the most frequent matchup. This is a fundamental kernel of deck selection strategy. This choice is a big part of what people mean when they say "metagaming" in the context of Magic formats.
There will also be some people playing other 'rogue' decks, or 'pet decks', or 'home brews', but when a particular format's metagame composition is stable, most people will either be playing the best deck, or trying to exclusively beat the best deck at the cost of all others. That is how things end up when the decision process is competition...but Commander isn't really all that competitive for most people. So how do you assemble a metagame in a format where people don't strategically optimize their metagame decision making?
The answer is simple...Fashion. Cue video.
Since I am a dispenser of knowledge and opinions, part psychologist, part life coach, part philospher...part analyst...mostly cartoon rabbit - I forgot where I was going with this, but the important takeaway is: if you haven't watched The Flight of the Conchords you need to. It is my legal and moral responsibility to distribute this public service announcement to as many people as I can. In the above clip we see how the normally dorky Brett and Jermaine are transformed into fashion forward heart throbs by a bottle of hair gel. I am starting to imagine the confused looks on some of your faces. The brows all-a-furl with the burning question: "Grandpa, what does any of this have to do with Commander?"
Competitive environments are dominated by the best optimizers. You win more, you propagate more. Casual environments in Magic are dominated by fashion. It is not what wins the most that becomes popular, but what has the most 'it' factor. It is the newest, the funnest, the flashiest, the most underground, the most retro, the most gimmicky - whatever the cool thing of the moment is, you want to be doing that.
Think back, if you will, a few years ago. Before the first Commander product was released by Wizards, there was a distinct lack of enemy-color "wedge" commanders. Or Generals, as they were called then, I suppose. You could play the Planar Chaos dragons, and a small smattering of other choices like Doran the Siege Tower, but all-in-all your choices were limited. You didn't see many Green/Black/White or Black/Blue/Green decks. Suddenly, when the Commander pre-cons came out, everyone wanted to play a Kaalia of the Vast deck. Karador, Ghost Chieftan. The Mimeoplasm. These decks were literally everywhere. The convenience and price of the Commander product brought new players into the format and got old players excited about new cards. The metagame was dominated by these new Legendary Creatures, not because they were better cards or strategies than previous offerings (in fact in many cases they were just flat-out worse, ask UL about his opinion of The Mimeoplasm), but because they were fashionable at that moment. Of course, over time, their popularity has waned. Some, like Ghave and Animar, have stuck around and carved out permanent niches in the Commander metagame, but the others have died out. When was the last time you heard someone rave about how good their Damia, Sage of Stone deck was? The same happened with the Avacyn Restored angels, the RTR champions, etc. The evidence is beyond dispute. Without competition to sculpt better strategic deck choices, the format instead moves through phases like seasonal fashions. People play the newest stuff until they get bored, dig out an old favorite and pair it up with a newly printed enabler, or maybe they give mono color a shot based on some new mechanic that gets printed, but eventually things settle back down until the next 'fashion show'.
Don't misunderstand, I am not condemning this. It is in no way bad. It is fun. It is exciting. It keeps things fresh...or fresher at least and it requires less maintenance than altering a banned list every few months. As a side effect though, some weird things happen. When you want to try out a new archetype it is tough to know where to start. What cards do you start in your 99? Well an easy way to get an idea is to just look at other people's deck lists. This is how it typically happens too. You do a 10 minute Google search, look for some common threads, incorporate them into your deck and fill up the rest with your personal favorites or some new techy pet cards you want to try out to give the deck your own personal flair. If you repeat this process a few thousand times for every potential commander, then you start to see how the same cards are always popping up in a particular deck. Instead of being OPTIMIZED, i.e. choosing the cards to win the most games, decklists become CENTRALIZED, i.e. including more 'staple' cards that are common to the most viewed online lists and deck techs. A centralized deck is one that contains the cards that you would EXPECT to see in it, whether they are actually the best strategic choices or not. Think about your local metagame or even - GASP - your own decks! They are probably very centralized, with a few random exceptions for "hipster" decks or 'secret tech' cards.
This will be the focus of next weeks article. Centralization...and how it became the dominant deckbuilding principle in Commander.
I hope you have been enjoying this somewhat unconventional article series, because it is going to continue at least for the next few weeks. Remember to like/comment/favorite/subscribe/hashtag/retweet/pin/whatever it is you are supposed to do...I don't understand how to internet. And remember my friend: Fashion is danger.
-GG
Saturday, March 1, 2014
The Stack #46- Mo Mana, No Prollums
Welcome back to TGZ's Saturday Specialty, The Stack!
Today's theme is ramp. As theme and strategy, ramp is some of the best card advantage you can get in the game. Every time you have to the opportunity to exchange a card for a land in your deck, it's a solid opportunity that increases your chances of drawing spells you need as the game progresses. Being able to smooth out mana, and reach castability for those 6+ spells I rarely ever play is only ever going to help.
The gang and I have assembled a list of our absolute favorites, which shouldn't be too much of a surprise. Then again, anything can happen.
THIS IS THE STACK!
UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS THROUGH THE ROOF!
I finally arrived at the card choice that takes zero brain power for me. Hooray for easy victories!
Seriously my favorite card. I play it in almost every deck I own, and attempt to recur it multiple times. So far, my single-game record stands at 5 (Which I've gotten in two decks). It is a card that has seen a significant rise in my playgroup as a result, and would probably be my avatar if it weren't for the fact that it is already another person.
I love everything about Sad Robot/Marvin's original art too. It looks like he went and took a photo at Sears. Plus, he doesn't get mistaken for an Etched Oracle.
Obviously, playing this card is cheating, and picking it here is a little too easy because it does so much more than accelerate/thin out your deck. But there's just no other way I'm going to be convinced to settle for my second or third choice this time.
The only other thing I want to say about Solemn is that if you cast this card in a game, the chances of you winning go up dramatically. That sounds suspect, but the correlation is value, which is Solemn Freaking Simulacrum.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
Yippee Ki-yay melon farmer! There are some things you just don't leave home without. Grab your keys, your phone, your wallet, and your Solemns. It's telling that UL and I both made the same argument for why these are our favorite ramp cards: playing them just makes you win. Mana sum theory suggests that the guy who has and uses more mana is most likely to win. Simple. I have also been oft-quoted as saying that the most important resource in Commander is cards, and to be ahead on cards is to be ahead in the game. The common ground between Solemn and Reach is easy to see: they advance your resources on two fronts. You get more mana to work with and a free 2-for-1. They accomplish what most cards can't even dream of at a bargain price.
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Certainly a classic card in any Commander deck (any deck that wins, at least), the Simulacrum is a true multi-tasker, one that has no problem dying, especially if you can sneak in a way to revive him from the grave (like Reclaim) or bounce/flicker him. These are all things that really didn't need explanation though, because the sad robot is so ubiquitous.
VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Why Blue? Why not? I prefer mana acceleration that can be re-used because I've had my fair share of one-offs that didn't quite help later on in the game. Granted Harrow is probably a better way to achieve this effect because you don't have to discard a card to pay its cost, the Dreamscape Picasso's cost for his ability shouldn't bother you if you've got a full hand and ways to retrieve things from the graveyard.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I've talked at length about how I think having Spellshapers in your deck with relevant abilities can compensate for our inefficiencies. This is probably the most efficient and playable spellshaper on the market.
Because just having Harrow isn't enough, Dreamscape is at its best when you have relevant one or two-cost disruption in your hand. Forcing your opponent to have to guess what future mana you may be holding up adds a cerebral quality to the game that makes for the kinds of games I like to play. Even though this card has one ability with logical targets, it can be used in skillful ways to leverage tempo if you have other cards to play and your timing is right.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
Harrow is significantly worse than this, largely because you do actually have to discard that card, the Harrow itself. This is an engine, naturally you would have to feed it something to keep it going, but unlike most mana ramp cards, this is one that actually loses effectiveness pretty quickly. You generally want more mana so that you can use the cards in your hand more quickly or more effectively than your opponent. There is an inflection point where you simply run out of junk to pitch to this and would rather cast those cards instead. The point of comparison really comes in the late game when this has expended its utility, or you draw it at an inopportune time. You had to plant this Creature down on the board just to have the privilege of buying Harrows, but when that time is over you can suit up and beat down. The same cannot be said for drawing a Rampant Growth late.
There is something to be said here about the cost structure in designing spellshapers, or really any creature with an activated ability. The best offerings in this category have a cost and body that is appropriate AND is exactly one less than the cost to activate its ability. Naturally, you will want to begin using this at your earliest opportunity or else, why play it? Historically, some important Creatures have fit this model. Rebel Searchers, and Enclave Cryptologist are fine examples.
GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I teetered back and forth...and in several other directions about what to choose. Favorite is a hard bug to catch when it comes to me and my mana. I use so many of these cards and they almost always travel in a herd. Sol Ring is obviously in every deck, but it seems to be that if one of them is going in a deck, then Cultivate, Rampant Growth, Sakura Tribe Elder, and Joraga Treespeaker are coming too. Sadly though, I don't always play Green. I have a big collection of mana rocks that I like, but it would be hard to say that they are my favorite. Sakura Tribe Elder is my favorite card, pants down. For the sake of variety though, I won't point that out again. K Reach is even more ubiquitous, but it is the card that I always want in my opening hand. If this resolves it feels tough for me to lose. Once the train gets rolling it can be hard to stop and in most games the toughest hurdle to overcome is simply amassing enough resources to start throwing haymakers.
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Definitely a classic land ramp spell, the arcane version of Cultivate. I really don't have anything to say about the card except that it pays to be able to get a land on the field AND one in your hand.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I wish we'd just gotten actual Koko Baby instead of Cultivate as the reprint in M-Whatever. I prefer the hand of the Kodama doing actual reaching- it's just good flavor.
Also, I was going to say that this is one of the few Heather Hudson artworks I like, but it turns out I didn't realize she basically does all the work for Commander's most playable cards- Pongify, Chord of Calling, Sculpting Steel, original Karmic Guide and Ghost Quarter. The list goes on, and though she's definitely gotten better through the years, it's just astounding how many good cards her work got printed on.
Until next time, be sure to tell us about all your favorites in the comments below.
Pass!
-UL/VJ/GG
Today's theme is ramp. As theme and strategy, ramp is some of the best card advantage you can get in the game. Every time you have to the opportunity to exchange a card for a land in your deck, it's a solid opportunity that increases your chances of drawing spells you need as the game progresses. Being able to smooth out mana, and reach castability for those 6+ spells I rarely ever play is only ever going to help.
The gang and I have assembled a list of our absolute favorites, which shouldn't be too much of a surprise. Then again, anything can happen.
THIS IS THE STACK!
UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS THROUGH THE ROOF!
I finally arrived at the card choice that takes zero brain power for me. Hooray for easy victories!
Seriously my favorite card. I play it in almost every deck I own, and attempt to recur it multiple times. So far, my single-game record stands at 5 (Which I've gotten in two decks). It is a card that has seen a significant rise in my playgroup as a result, and would probably be my avatar if it weren't for the fact that it is already another person.
I love everything about Sad Robot/Marvin's original art too. It looks like he went and took a photo at Sears. Plus, he doesn't get mistaken for an Etched Oracle.
Obviously, playing this card is cheating, and picking it here is a little too easy because it does so much more than accelerate/thin out your deck. But there's just no other way I'm going to be convinced to settle for my second or third choice this time.
The only other thing I want to say about Solemn is that if you cast this card in a game, the chances of you winning go up dramatically. That sounds suspect, but the correlation is value, which is Solemn Freaking Simulacrum.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
Yippee Ki-yay melon farmer! There are some things you just don't leave home without. Grab your keys, your phone, your wallet, and your Solemns. It's telling that UL and I both made the same argument for why these are our favorite ramp cards: playing them just makes you win. Mana sum theory suggests that the guy who has and uses more mana is most likely to win. Simple. I have also been oft-quoted as saying that the most important resource in Commander is cards, and to be ahead on cards is to be ahead in the game. The common ground between Solemn and Reach is easy to see: they advance your resources on two fronts. You get more mana to work with and a free 2-for-1. They accomplish what most cards can't even dream of at a bargain price.
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Certainly a classic card in any Commander deck (any deck that wins, at least), the Simulacrum is a true multi-tasker, one that has no problem dying, especially if you can sneak in a way to revive him from the grave (like Reclaim) or bounce/flicker him. These are all things that really didn't need explanation though, because the sad robot is so ubiquitous.
VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Why Blue? Why not? I prefer mana acceleration that can be re-used because I've had my fair share of one-offs that didn't quite help later on in the game. Granted Harrow is probably a better way to achieve this effect because you don't have to discard a card to pay its cost, the Dreamscape Picasso's cost for his ability shouldn't bother you if you've got a full hand and ways to retrieve things from the graveyard.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I've talked at length about how I think having Spellshapers in your deck with relevant abilities can compensate for our inefficiencies. This is probably the most efficient and playable spellshaper on the market.
Because just having Harrow isn't enough, Dreamscape is at its best when you have relevant one or two-cost disruption in your hand. Forcing your opponent to have to guess what future mana you may be holding up adds a cerebral quality to the game that makes for the kinds of games I like to play. Even though this card has one ability with logical targets, it can be used in skillful ways to leverage tempo if you have other cards to play and your timing is right.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
Harrow is significantly worse than this, largely because you do actually have to discard that card, the Harrow itself. This is an engine, naturally you would have to feed it something to keep it going, but unlike most mana ramp cards, this is one that actually loses effectiveness pretty quickly. You generally want more mana so that you can use the cards in your hand more quickly or more effectively than your opponent. There is an inflection point where you simply run out of junk to pitch to this and would rather cast those cards instead. The point of comparison really comes in the late game when this has expended its utility, or you draw it at an inopportune time. You had to plant this Creature down on the board just to have the privilege of buying Harrows, but when that time is over you can suit up and beat down. The same cannot be said for drawing a Rampant Growth late.
There is something to be said here about the cost structure in designing spellshapers, or really any creature with an activated ability. The best offerings in this category have a cost and body that is appropriate AND is exactly one less than the cost to activate its ability. Naturally, you will want to begin using this at your earliest opportunity or else, why play it? Historically, some important Creatures have fit this model. Rebel Searchers, and Enclave Cryptologist are fine examples.
GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I teetered back and forth...and in several other directions about what to choose. Favorite is a hard bug to catch when it comes to me and my mana. I use so many of these cards and they almost always travel in a herd. Sol Ring is obviously in every deck, but it seems to be that if one of them is going in a deck, then Cultivate, Rampant Growth, Sakura Tribe Elder, and Joraga Treespeaker are coming too. Sadly though, I don't always play Green. I have a big collection of mana rocks that I like, but it would be hard to say that they are my favorite. Sakura Tribe Elder is my favorite card, pants down. For the sake of variety though, I won't point that out again. K Reach is even more ubiquitous, but it is the card that I always want in my opening hand. If this resolves it feels tough for me to lose. Once the train gets rolling it can be hard to stop and in most games the toughest hurdle to overcome is simply amassing enough resources to start throwing haymakers.
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Definitely a classic land ramp spell, the arcane version of Cultivate. I really don't have anything to say about the card except that it pays to be able to get a land on the field AND one in your hand.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I wish we'd just gotten actual Koko Baby instead of Cultivate as the reprint in M-Whatever. I prefer the hand of the Kodama doing actual reaching- it's just good flavor.
Also, I was going to say that this is one of the few Heather Hudson artworks I like, but it turns out I didn't realize she basically does all the work for Commander's most playable cards- Pongify, Chord of Calling, Sculpting Steel, original Karmic Guide and Ghost Quarter. The list goes on, and though she's definitely gotten better through the years, it's just astounding how many good cards her work got printed on.
Until next time, be sure to tell us about all your favorites in the comments below.
Pass!
-UL/VJ/GG
Labels:
Commander,
Dreamscape Artist,
EDH,
Kodama's Reach,
Solemn Simulacrum,
The Stack
Wednesday, February 26, 2014
You Make the Pick 5
Hey Zoners! Welcome to another You Make the Pick. This is a short weekday segment where I show you a booster pack, tell you the story behind it, talk about the cards, share what my pick would be, and then you guys let us know in the comments what you would take.
Last weekend was Pro Tour Born of the Gods, if you missed out on any of the coverage then you should definitely go check it out on dailymtg.com. They have text coverage, decklists, player interviews, video of every feature match, and also: a draft viewer, where you can see every pick from every seat in the exciting Theros block team draft format. There was a draft tech on day one of the coverage featuring Hall of Famer William 'Huey' Jensen. He was at the table drafting with other notable names like Travis Woo and fellow HoF member Antione Ruel. This is what Huey saw for his first pick of the draft on day one of the Pro Tour:
It is pretty interesting to step inside the mind of a Magic pro, especially one of the all-time greats. So here we have a playable rare in Fated Intervention, which is strong, but not crazy good and requires a heavy Green commitment. Drown in Sorrow is a decent card, but hard to abuse in booster draft. Black happens to be one of the better colors in Born of the Gods and the flat out best in Theros in my opinion. Staking a claim early could be very profitable if you see some Gray Merchants later in the draft. This format seems to be a little faster than triple Theros, so having a sweeper might come in handy if you plan on drafting a slower strategy. Aerie Worshipers is also pretty incredible in limited and a fine pick here, although Blue is weaker in Born of the Gods. That could be good or bad because it might actually scare other drafters away from the color. Most all of the commons are pretty bad, the only one worth talking about is the Bolt of Keranos.
That just so happens to be what Huey took from the pack. Starting off with a removal spell is a great idea and Red a strong color in all three packs of this format. Taking the bolt here will send a signal that Red isn't open since the next best card is...well yea there isn't another Red card worth taking early. I think that I would probably have taken the Drown in Sorrow because I really like Black, but he is the Pro and I am the chumpy community author. The only real question left to ask is...what would you take?
Last weekend was Pro Tour Born of the Gods, if you missed out on any of the coverage then you should definitely go check it out on dailymtg.com. They have text coverage, decklists, player interviews, video of every feature match, and also: a draft viewer, where you can see every pick from every seat in the exciting Theros block team draft format. There was a draft tech on day one of the coverage featuring Hall of Famer William 'Huey' Jensen. He was at the table drafting with other notable names like Travis Woo and fellow HoF member Antione Ruel. This is what Huey saw for his first pick of the draft on day one of the Pro Tour:
It is pretty interesting to step inside the mind of a Magic pro, especially one of the all-time greats. So here we have a playable rare in Fated Intervention, which is strong, but not crazy good and requires a heavy Green commitment. Drown in Sorrow is a decent card, but hard to abuse in booster draft. Black happens to be one of the better colors in Born of the Gods and the flat out best in Theros in my opinion. Staking a claim early could be very profitable if you see some Gray Merchants later in the draft. This format seems to be a little faster than triple Theros, so having a sweeper might come in handy if you plan on drafting a slower strategy. Aerie Worshipers is also pretty incredible in limited and a fine pick here, although Blue is weaker in Born of the Gods. That could be good or bad because it might actually scare other drafters away from the color. Most all of the commons are pretty bad, the only one worth talking about is the Bolt of Keranos.
That just so happens to be what Huey took from the pack. Starting off with a removal spell is a great idea and Red a strong color in all three packs of this format. Taking the bolt here will send a signal that Red isn't open since the next best card is...well yea there isn't another Red card worth taking early. I think that I would probably have taken the Drown in Sorrow because I really like Black, but he is the Pro and I am the chumpy community author. The only real question left to ask is...what would you take?
Tuesday, February 25, 2014
UL's Better Deckbuilding: Daxos of Meletis EDH
Hey Zoners! Welcome back to another installment of Better Deckbuilding.
Today's design features one of the more popular Legends to come out of Theros- Daxos, the shirtless swordsman extraordinaire.
Today's design features one of the more popular Legends to come out of Theros- Daxos, the shirtless swordsman extraordinaire.
WHY DAXOS?
Normally, I'm not one to jump on the new Commander train when a card comes out.
Obviously, Daxos was an exception. I've liked and entertained building Thada Adel for a while, and I thought Daxos offered a very similar-but-different way to create a deck that would allow me to play my opponent's cards to assemble exciting board states.
This quality of improvisation and his unique evasion were both what drew me to the card and the catalyst for the challenges I faced in assembling my list.
THE DECKBUILDING PROCESS
Building Daxos was a lot different from most of my other designs for several reasons.
I actually began design after Theros came out, with the idea of playing some serious Stax-Style cards like Frozen Aether, Kismet, Winter Orb, and Meekstone to create favorable control elements for Daxos.
However, after learning his ability wouldn't allow me to play my opponent's lands, I lost my motivation for a while, so I unsleeved him and put all my card choices back for a while. Sometimes this is a necessary component to deckbuilding, especially when the designer can't find a clear vision for the deck. A couple months later I saw Johnny Confidant's list, and it gave me a few nice ideas for fixing my own problems.
Although Daxos possesses a rather underrated set of combat skills, he still promotes a very random and spontaneous way of deck design. His damage is much like Forrest Gump's box of chocolates- it's just hard to know what you're going to want in a game, and hard to know what you're going to cast off of someone's library. Either way, the life gain and Commander damage combine nicely to stabilize the value.
This also means you still have to play threats. Daxos isn't going to get 21 damage without a few tricks, and when you're hitting your opponent's lands, and not drawing into cards you need, it's easy to lose games.
So unlike most of my decks, which have a very methodical Pick Commander-Plan Strategy-Design-Test-Re-Tool plan, I realized that the only way I was going to be able to balance its reactive qualities properly was to get it on the kitchen table as quick as possible. So I adapted my methods, and it paid off.
This isn't my favorite way to build decks- I tend to find I'm no different than most in this regard. Putting decks out before you're satisfied sets a design up for failure before it begins. Confidence is an important part of the game, and any trace of doubt you may have is almost always going to seep into the game at some point. The "Heart of the Cards" is real, folks, and this seemingly silly faith is a source of competitive advantage when you've practiced with a deck and you know it inside and out.
Still, if you're able to effectively manage your expectations about a deck, it only inhibits your deckbuilding prowess. With Daxos, I was able to bring it into both 1v1 and multiplayer games knowing what it was going to do against good and bad matchups in a regular game setting. As a result, I was able to carve out its identity and smooth out my problems.
PILOTING THE DECK
In a number of ways, mine was based off JC's deck, which consisted of combining strong "Good Stuff" cards with Daxos to create aggressive threats and have a little counterspell backup. Things that gave us double strike, and Swords in particular, provided the deck with strong Daxos pumps and a little extra value whenever Daxos would deal damage.
After talking with JC about piloting the deck, I took his blueprints a step further by enhancing the strengths of the deck, transforming it into a basic "GoodStuffs" deck by maximizing the value of many of the cards that were already powerful parts of Magic's history.
Most of my decks have hubs and themes that get built around, and Daxos is no different. The first is combat damage triggers. Much like Daxos, the Commander Card Pool is chock-full of cool creatures and artifacts that offer unique triggers that activate in combat. Combined with Swords, these cards are the driving force of the deck, which is interesting when you consider this combination to be more like the "Slow-Zorius" decks I coined in Ravnica Limited, and less like a weenie Aggro deck.
In piloting the deck, it's definitely a sweet blend of the two. The Control elements can drive the Aggro parts, and vice versa- creating a very effective blend that can match the speed of the table.
As a result of Daxos' ability, there's also a different approach to the way you play spells. 70-80% of the time, tapping out in the first main is not going to be great- especially when Daxos is out getting damage and a random card.
However, rather than waste time on irrelevant cards like Lantern of Insight, what I found to be slightly more effective is just playing Instants- counterspells, disruption- anything that I can hold in my hand so that I can respond if someone tries to disrupt combat. Since we don't tap out until our second main, we can almost always ensure our interests are protected.
Plus, it gives us the element of surprise when we flip awesome things. Early on in testing I flopped a bunch of nice ones: Oracle of Mul Daya, Markov Blademaster, Brutalizer Exarch. I've even double-striked a Vigor and Sepulchral Primordial off the top of someone's library.
Still, there are plenty of ways to make your own luck with Daxos- so let's pop the hood and check out some of the tech.
THE TECH
There are quite a few cards with "put on top of owner's library" in my Daxos list that make for some nice versatility.
Disempower is probably the "weakest" one of them, but only because the other cards are Memory Lapse, Lapse of Certainty, and Unexpectedly Absent. Unlike the overcosted Griptide or Vanishment, Disempower sacrifices popularity and versatility for a cheap casting cost.
All that said, I like this card quite a bit. It can be a poor man's Unexpectedly Absent if our opponents play Gods, or a way to steal their Eldrazi Monument during combat and before damage is dealt. The tempo brings huge swings, and it can be done in the most favorable moments.
I'm not sure of the potential Disempower has in other decks, but I have a good feeling that if you try it out you probably won't be disappointed.
Any opportunity I have to showcase my cool lands I'm going to do it.
I think it's still all the rage in tournament Geist of Saint Traft decks to play his favorite castle, and I'm playing it here for the same reasons. Again, our mana stays untapped through combat, so this can be a nice trick if your opponent(s) was/were born yesterday and forgot about the things they do in the mainstream world of Magic.
If your opponent is chump-blocking, or flashing in tricks, this is also a good thing too.
In my group, this card got the mispronounced nickname of "Django Castle," which is also why I'm playing it. Any opportunity to play cards with nicknames is fun, and it's a great little card for other decks too- especially Captain Sisay.
Yeah. That's right.
I know it's not tech, but I had the opportunity to play a Magic classic in here, and I took it.
Earlier I mentioned that there's troubleshooting to be done here. When you're not getting threats off the top of your opponent's library, or cards from your own, it's a difficult place to be in.
Divination is not something I'm recommending for a Daxos deck, but I like it a lot more than playing nonsense like Ponder.
And even though I really dig the new art on this reprint, my Divination is the Yu-Gi-Oh card Pot of Greed (Which does the same thing in their game), and was gifted one by a guy in my playgroup.
The deck is a little light on land (37) because I have access to a plethora of mana rocks, and Divination can help me smooth out my land plays. That's mostly what it's here for.
Sometimes, you just gotta stack fun cards on top of more fun.
As predicted, Lavinia is silly good. Combined with Daxos, she's even better.
And in my meta, because it's almost always going to have a red player at the table, it makes her one of the best. She shuts down just about every creature that could block Daxos while also being a decent threat. It's win-win, basically.
I play a few blink effects, but there's so much tempo and value to be had, it's nuts. I can only imagine what proper decks built around her might do, and it's been making me cringe since she was spoiled last year. I'm glad I haven't seen any yet, but I don't know how long we're going to be able to keep that up.
Definitely a great pal for Daxos, and vice versa. The Azorius deck has gotten so much stronger just in the last year with her, Daxos, Medomai, and Render Silent. I'm really surprised we don't see more of U/W floating around. Then again, we can't all be Venser's Journalist.
I know much of the Daxos design is not original, and so it's no surprise to see Elspeth, Knight-Errant. Her magic is no secret.
But it's worth pointing out how neat she is in conjunction with Daxos. Many times people will make a dude with her ability and not think twice.
However, Daxos keeps it fresh. It's actually Elspeth's pumps and evasion in here that has proven to be much more instrumental in ending games.
Turning Daxos into a 5/5 flyer is absurd even without double strike or a sword, as it ups an 11-turn clock if she's not dealt with.
I know I'm just supporting an already innately good card, but being able to make a good card better is rare. Adding dimensions to them demonstrates unparalleled sense of respect to other players, to the game of Magic, and to the cards themselves. Overall, it's just good business, and that's what TGZ is all about. So I'd be remiss if I avoided it.
Most of the planeswalkers in this deck are not here simply because this is a Good Stuff deck, even though they are part of the stereotype associated with it. They help "gain life" by taking damage away from you, and giving Daxos a way to continue to be unblockable and relevant as the game scales. Opening hands in this deck with mana rocks and an early P-Dub almost always ensure that the game is going to be quick. This has been the case in most 1v1 matchups I've played.
The last card in our list is Thran Dynamo, and it's kind of interesting.
You see, because of the way that Daxos' ability works, Thran Dynamo and other boring mana rocks like it have the capacity to accept change.
Via Daxos' ability, this colorless mana can be colored mana, which is a very interesting Magic rule-breaker. Creating ramp support has never been so neat, and it allows us to play cards that may be out of our price range in the early turns.
Thran Dynamo and Mana Vault are two cards I play in here that I can ramp with quickly, and that also smooth out my draws long term. With less lands, these cards are just as important in supporting my mana base as they are in supporting our ability on offense to cast whatever we can get our hands on.
Anyway, this is the current list: Daxos of Meletis EDH, and Johnny Confidant's list that inspired mine- Daxos of Mediocrity EDH. Please check 'em out, +1 them if you like 'em, and suggest to us some neat tech if you think it'll help.
With that, I'll end my turn.
-UL
Obviously, Daxos was an exception. I've liked and entertained building Thada Adel for a while, and I thought Daxos offered a very similar-but-different way to create a deck that would allow me to play my opponent's cards to assemble exciting board states.
This quality of improvisation and his unique evasion were both what drew me to the card and the catalyst for the challenges I faced in assembling my list.
THE DECKBUILDING PROCESS
Building Daxos was a lot different from most of my other designs for several reasons.
I actually began design after Theros came out, with the idea of playing some serious Stax-Style cards like Frozen Aether, Kismet, Winter Orb, and Meekstone to create favorable control elements for Daxos.
However, after learning his ability wouldn't allow me to play my opponent's lands, I lost my motivation for a while, so I unsleeved him and put all my card choices back for a while. Sometimes this is a necessary component to deckbuilding, especially when the designer can't find a clear vision for the deck. A couple months later I saw Johnny Confidant's list, and it gave me a few nice ideas for fixing my own problems.
Although Daxos possesses a rather underrated set of combat skills, he still promotes a very random and spontaneous way of deck design. His damage is much like Forrest Gump's box of chocolates- it's just hard to know what you're going to want in a game, and hard to know what you're going to cast off of someone's library. Either way, the life gain and Commander damage combine nicely to stabilize the value.
This also means you still have to play threats. Daxos isn't going to get 21 damage without a few tricks, and when you're hitting your opponent's lands, and not drawing into cards you need, it's easy to lose games.
So unlike most of my decks, which have a very methodical Pick Commander-Plan Strategy-Design-Test-Re-Tool plan, I realized that the only way I was going to be able to balance its reactive qualities properly was to get it on the kitchen table as quick as possible. So I adapted my methods, and it paid off.
This isn't my favorite way to build decks- I tend to find I'm no different than most in this regard. Putting decks out before you're satisfied sets a design up for failure before it begins. Confidence is an important part of the game, and any trace of doubt you may have is almost always going to seep into the game at some point. The "Heart of the Cards" is real, folks, and this seemingly silly faith is a source of competitive advantage when you've practiced with a deck and you know it inside and out.
Still, if you're able to effectively manage your expectations about a deck, it only inhibits your deckbuilding prowess. With Daxos, I was able to bring it into both 1v1 and multiplayer games knowing what it was going to do against good and bad matchups in a regular game setting. As a result, I was able to carve out its identity and smooth out my problems.
PILOTING THE DECK
In a number of ways, mine was based off JC's deck, which consisted of combining strong "Good Stuff" cards with Daxos to create aggressive threats and have a little counterspell backup. Things that gave us double strike, and Swords in particular, provided the deck with strong Daxos pumps and a little extra value whenever Daxos would deal damage.
After talking with JC about piloting the deck, I took his blueprints a step further by enhancing the strengths of the deck, transforming it into a basic "GoodStuffs" deck by maximizing the value of many of the cards that were already powerful parts of Magic's history.
Most of my decks have hubs and themes that get built around, and Daxos is no different. The first is combat damage triggers. Much like Daxos, the Commander Card Pool is chock-full of cool creatures and artifacts that offer unique triggers that activate in combat. Combined with Swords, these cards are the driving force of the deck, which is interesting when you consider this combination to be more like the "Slow-Zorius" decks I coined in Ravnica Limited, and less like a weenie Aggro deck.
In piloting the deck, it's definitely a sweet blend of the two. The Control elements can drive the Aggro parts, and vice versa- creating a very effective blend that can match the speed of the table.
As a result of Daxos' ability, there's also a different approach to the way you play spells. 70-80% of the time, tapping out in the first main is not going to be great- especially when Daxos is out getting damage and a random card.
However, rather than waste time on irrelevant cards like Lantern of Insight, what I found to be slightly more effective is just playing Instants- counterspells, disruption- anything that I can hold in my hand so that I can respond if someone tries to disrupt combat. Since we don't tap out until our second main, we can almost always ensure our interests are protected.
Plus, it gives us the element of surprise when we flip awesome things. Early on in testing I flopped a bunch of nice ones: Oracle of Mul Daya, Markov Blademaster, Brutalizer Exarch. I've even double-striked a Vigor and Sepulchral Primordial off the top of someone's library.
Still, there are plenty of ways to make your own luck with Daxos- so let's pop the hood and check out some of the tech.
THE TECH
Disempower is probably the "weakest" one of them, but only because the other cards are Memory Lapse, Lapse of Certainty, and Unexpectedly Absent. Unlike the overcosted Griptide or Vanishment, Disempower sacrifices popularity and versatility for a cheap casting cost.
All that said, I like this card quite a bit. It can be a poor man's Unexpectedly Absent if our opponents play Gods, or a way to steal their Eldrazi Monument during combat and before damage is dealt. The tempo brings huge swings, and it can be done in the most favorable moments.
I'm not sure of the potential Disempower has in other decks, but I have a good feeling that if you try it out you probably won't be disappointed.
| The "D" is silent. |
I think it's still all the rage in tournament Geist of Saint Traft decks to play his favorite castle, and I'm playing it here for the same reasons. Again, our mana stays untapped through combat, so this can be a nice trick if your opponent(s) was/were born yesterday and forgot about the things they do in the mainstream world of Magic.
If your opponent is chump-blocking, or flashing in tricks, this is also a good thing too.
In my group, this card got the mispronounced nickname of "Django Castle," which is also why I'm playing it. Any opportunity to play cards with nicknames is fun, and it's a great little card for other decks too- especially Captain Sisay.
Yeah. That's right.
I know it's not tech, but I had the opportunity to play a Magic classic in here, and I took it.
Earlier I mentioned that there's troubleshooting to be done here. When you're not getting threats off the top of your opponent's library, or cards from your own, it's a difficult place to be in.
Divination is not something I'm recommending for a Daxos deck, but I like it a lot more than playing nonsense like Ponder.
And even though I really dig the new art on this reprint, my Divination is the Yu-Gi-Oh card Pot of Greed (Which does the same thing in their game), and was gifted one by a guy in my playgroup.
The deck is a little light on land (37) because I have access to a plethora of mana rocks, and Divination can help me smooth out my land plays. That's mostly what it's here for.
Sometimes, you just gotta stack fun cards on top of more fun.
As predicted, Lavinia is silly good. Combined with Daxos, she's even better.
And in my meta, because it's almost always going to have a red player at the table, it makes her one of the best. She shuts down just about every creature that could block Daxos while also being a decent threat. It's win-win, basically.
I play a few blink effects, but there's so much tempo and value to be had, it's nuts. I can only imagine what proper decks built around her might do, and it's been making me cringe since she was spoiled last year. I'm glad I haven't seen any yet, but I don't know how long we're going to be able to keep that up.
Definitely a great pal for Daxos, and vice versa. The Azorius deck has gotten so much stronger just in the last year with her, Daxos, Medomai, and Render Silent. I'm really surprised we don't see more of U/W floating around. Then again, we can't all be Venser's Journalist.
I know much of the Daxos design is not original, and so it's no surprise to see Elspeth, Knight-Errant. Her magic is no secret.
But it's worth pointing out how neat she is in conjunction with Daxos. Many times people will make a dude with her ability and not think twice.
However, Daxos keeps it fresh. It's actually Elspeth's pumps and evasion in here that has proven to be much more instrumental in ending games.
Turning Daxos into a 5/5 flyer is absurd even without double strike or a sword, as it ups an 11-turn clock if she's not dealt with.
I know I'm just supporting an already innately good card, but being able to make a good card better is rare. Adding dimensions to them demonstrates unparalleled sense of respect to other players, to the game of Magic, and to the cards themselves. Overall, it's just good business, and that's what TGZ is all about. So I'd be remiss if I avoided it.
Most of the planeswalkers in this deck are not here simply because this is a Good Stuff deck, even though they are part of the stereotype associated with it. They help "gain life" by taking damage away from you, and giving Daxos a way to continue to be unblockable and relevant as the game scales. Opening hands in this deck with mana rocks and an early P-Dub almost always ensure that the game is going to be quick. This has been the case in most 1v1 matchups I've played.
The last card in our list is Thran Dynamo, and it's kind of interesting.
You see, because of the way that Daxos' ability works, Thran Dynamo and other boring mana rocks like it have the capacity to accept change.
Via Daxos' ability, this colorless mana can be colored mana, which is a very interesting Magic rule-breaker. Creating ramp support has never been so neat, and it allows us to play cards that may be out of our price range in the early turns.
Thran Dynamo and Mana Vault are two cards I play in here that I can ramp with quickly, and that also smooth out my draws long term. With less lands, these cards are just as important in supporting my mana base as they are in supporting our ability on offense to cast whatever we can get our hands on.
Anyway, this is the current list: Daxos of Meletis EDH, and Johnny Confidant's list that inspired mine- Daxos of Mediocrity EDH. Please check 'em out, +1 them if you like 'em, and suggest to us some neat tech if you think it'll help.
With that, I'll end my turn.
-UL
Labels:
Aggro-Control,
Azorius,
Better Deckbuilding,
Commander,
Daxos of Meletis,
EDH
Sunday, February 23, 2014
In General: The Modern Approach
Hello Zoners. I am Grandpa Growth, your regular Sunday writer. This is In General, your regular Sunday column. In General focuses on discussion of higher level strategy, player psychology, game theory, and other loosely related topics. In General is not the place for my thoughts on individual cards...usually.
You see today, I am at home watching coverage of the Top 8 of Pro Tour Born of the Gods in Valencia, Spain. The Constructed format for this tournament is Modern. Wizards has established a pattern of wanting to showcase a "fresh" format for the Pro Tour, so that everyone at home can watch the top players in the world design and play decks for an unexplored metagame. *BUZZ WORD ALERT*! Metagame huh? Metagame is the umbrella for all the things that relate to the game, but are outside of an actual game of Magic. In this context I am referring specifically to the metagame composition - the breakdown of all the viable decks available to players. In a solved format this is a known quantity. There will be statistical analysis available that documents each major deck's win percentage against the other major decks and what percentage of the total player base at recent tournaments have been playing each deck. No such information exists for Commander, but that is the nature of a casual format. Next week, in fact, I will be discussing how the idea of the metagame influences Commander as a format, but that is not what I am talking about today.
Today, I am talking about how Wizards accomplishes the task of taking a solved format and essentially wrecking it. You see, this is how you make a "fresh format" out of an existing one. In Standard, cards rotate on a yearly basis and new cards are coming out every few months. Because the card pool is sufficiently small, each of these changes makes a significant impact on what decks are viable in the format. Modern has a much larger card pool, so new cards are much less likely to be powerful enough to impact the format at large. Cards also don't rotate out, so the only way Wizards can remove something from Modern is to put it on the Banned list. This is the exact tactic that they have chosen to control the Modern metagame and it is an interesting decision that I believe has applications to Commander.
Wizards unbanned Bitterblossom and Wild Nacatl just weeks before the Pro Tour, ensuring that new (old) decks would become viable and the Pros would need significant amounts of testing with and against these previously unusable archetypes. With Modern, Wizards has adopted the unwritten policy that whenever the Banned and Restricted List is updated, they will typically ban the best card in the best deck at that time. Once established, this meant that players who invest in the format could expect it to change more frequently than Legacy and also expect that any deck dominant enough to win consistently, would not stay legal for more than a few months at a time.
This was essentially all preamble to a simple question. What if Commander was managed this same way? It is no secret that I am not a supporter of the so-called "Official" Banned List. There is simply nothing official about casual Magic. If you have issues with a particular card, deck, or person in your local metagame then you should deal with those issues individually. Don't rely on, and certainly don't endorse, other people putting rules on they way that you have fun with your friends. That is how I feel at least. Anyway, the point I am making is that this could provide a much more intuitive guiding principle for establishing a banned list. Instead of listing all the cards that commander.net moderators don't like, we could have a more objective and democratic system.
For example, Nekusar, the Mindrazer is popular in my group these days. Keep in mind this just an example, I don't think these decks are even good, much less worthy of a ban, but for argument's sake let's say I started an open-ended poll. I want to shake up my metagame, so I ask people what they think the best card in the best deck is. If people feel like I do, they will inevitably start naming cards that are in these Nekusar decks. Winter Orb, Back to Basics, maybe Phyrexian Tyranny, or even Nekusar himself. If the consensus is to ban a card that is popular in Nekusar decks, we know Nekusar is a problem in my group. If the group consistently points out a particular card, then we should think about banning that card to put the power level and popularity of Nekusar decks back in line with the rest of the format. Every six months-to-a-year we could re-examine the list and use the same system to take cards off the list. If the majority of people seem to think that allowing Braids, Cabal Minion as a Commander would help diversify the format, then heck, we can give it a go.
This is more of a thought experiment than anything. The idea intrigued me and I think that there is potential for it to supplant the Official Banned and Restricted List in my sphere of influence. So, rather than asking if you support this idea since that isn't really the point, I want ask: what do you think the best archetype in Commander is and what single card could you take away that would make you stop wanting to play, or hate playing against, that archetype?
-GG
You see today, I am at home watching coverage of the Top 8 of Pro Tour Born of the Gods in Valencia, Spain. The Constructed format for this tournament is Modern. Wizards has established a pattern of wanting to showcase a "fresh" format for the Pro Tour, so that everyone at home can watch the top players in the world design and play decks for an unexplored metagame. *BUZZ WORD ALERT*! Metagame huh? Metagame is the umbrella for all the things that relate to the game, but are outside of an actual game of Magic. In this context I am referring specifically to the metagame composition - the breakdown of all the viable decks available to players. In a solved format this is a known quantity. There will be statistical analysis available that documents each major deck's win percentage against the other major decks and what percentage of the total player base at recent tournaments have been playing each deck. No such information exists for Commander, but that is the nature of a casual format. Next week, in fact, I will be discussing how the idea of the metagame influences Commander as a format, but that is not what I am talking about today.
Today, I am talking about how Wizards accomplishes the task of taking a solved format and essentially wrecking it. You see, this is how you make a "fresh format" out of an existing one. In Standard, cards rotate on a yearly basis and new cards are coming out every few months. Because the card pool is sufficiently small, each of these changes makes a significant impact on what decks are viable in the format. Modern has a much larger card pool, so new cards are much less likely to be powerful enough to impact the format at large. Cards also don't rotate out, so the only way Wizards can remove something from Modern is to put it on the Banned list. This is the exact tactic that they have chosen to control the Modern metagame and it is an interesting decision that I believe has applications to Commander.
Wizards unbanned Bitterblossom and Wild Nacatl just weeks before the Pro Tour, ensuring that new (old) decks would become viable and the Pros would need significant amounts of testing with and against these previously unusable archetypes. With Modern, Wizards has adopted the unwritten policy that whenever the Banned and Restricted List is updated, they will typically ban the best card in the best deck at that time. Once established, this meant that players who invest in the format could expect it to change more frequently than Legacy and also expect that any deck dominant enough to win consistently, would not stay legal for more than a few months at a time.
This was essentially all preamble to a simple question. What if Commander was managed this same way? It is no secret that I am not a supporter of the so-called "Official" Banned List. There is simply nothing official about casual Magic. If you have issues with a particular card, deck, or person in your local metagame then you should deal with those issues individually. Don't rely on, and certainly don't endorse, other people putting rules on they way that you have fun with your friends. That is how I feel at least. Anyway, the point I am making is that this could provide a much more intuitive guiding principle for establishing a banned list. Instead of listing all the cards that commander.net moderators don't like, we could have a more objective and democratic system.
For example, Nekusar, the Mindrazer is popular in my group these days. Keep in mind this just an example, I don't think these decks are even good, much less worthy of a ban, but for argument's sake let's say I started an open-ended poll. I want to shake up my metagame, so I ask people what they think the best card in the best deck is. If people feel like I do, they will inevitably start naming cards that are in these Nekusar decks. Winter Orb, Back to Basics, maybe Phyrexian Tyranny, or even Nekusar himself. If the consensus is to ban a card that is popular in Nekusar decks, we know Nekusar is a problem in my group. If the group consistently points out a particular card, then we should think about banning that card to put the power level and popularity of Nekusar decks back in line with the rest of the format. Every six months-to-a-year we could re-examine the list and use the same system to take cards off the list. If the majority of people seem to think that allowing Braids, Cabal Minion as a Commander would help diversify the format, then heck, we can give it a go.
This is more of a thought experiment than anything. The idea intrigued me and I think that there is potential for it to supplant the Official Banned and Restricted List in my sphere of influence. So, rather than asking if you support this idea since that isn't really the point, I want ask: what do you think the best archetype in Commander is and what single card could you take away that would make you stop wanting to play, or hate playing against, that archetype?
-GG
Saturday, February 22, 2014
The Stack #45- Card Name Re-Assignment
After several weeks of vacation, it's time to get back on our weekend routine.
The Stack returns this week with a fun pastime GG and I used to have back when we were playing on the regular- the Nickname game.
Having so many cards in the format means we get the wonderful opportunity to continue to enjoy making new names as well as continuing to keep alive those made-up names from competitive decks of the past.
Nicknaming cards is one of the many ways I'm able to gratify good ones, excite mediocre ones, and convince myself that playing bad ones are totally worth it. They come from all different facets of humor tactics and pop culture, and I tend to think it's a key tactic in helping me to maintain my competitive edge while remaining not too serious.
So we're going to share some of our more recent nomenclature with you. This is it!
GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
The Convertible Turtle. And really, what else would you even call him? This definitely isn't my favorite nickname, but a good one nonetheless, though this is surely my favorite Turtle. Even as a Pauper-only playable, this is still by far the best Turtle ever printed. Speaking of which, why no love for the Turtle tribe? What's up with that Wizards?
From a flavor perspective this card is total nonsense. A gigantic turtle would not exactly be an effective hunter. In fact there is no way something this big could reasonably survive in a desolate environment like a desert or salt flat. There just isn't enough food. And if anything it would most certainly be an herbivore and thus, there wouldn't be much of a need for all the snapping - the plants don't run away.
I have to confess I am a pretty savage abuser of card nicknames. Understanding my speech during a game of Magic is practically impossible because of all the shortcuts, nicknames, and inside jokes. It's like I am talking in nerd code. My pen name for this very blog is a direct port of a card nickname. Bonus points if you know what it is. Hint: it was featured in the now derelict "Super Secret Sunday" series.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Interesting language for sure, but I like the image evoked a lot more. What would a turtle do with the top down, cruising down the street? Would he look for other chick turtles? Would he feel nervous and naked? I don't know what to do if philosophy and science can't answer my questions.
Anyway, I keep finding myself trying to make "Convertible" and "Turtle" rhyme, but mostly because it makes me feel like a little kid again, bashing action figures together on the floor of my little playroom growing up. That's a little memoir-y, but I kind of have history slingin' Turtle around back in Zenny (slang for Zendikar; be hip even if you aren't folks), when I didn't care about rarity, and lands seemed to drop from the sky whenever I wanted. Now, I have days where I can't seem to hit any lands, and my collection of Calcite Snappers were handed down to my brother.
VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Call me boring, but I usually refer to Bruna here as "Light of Abra Kadabra." It makes sense, no? She's somewhat of an enchantress, so the name fits the kind of spellcasting/spell inclusion you see in most decks that utilize this angel.
Interestingly, I've never put her at the forefront of a deck. She currently resides in my Rafiq of the Many deck alongside her sister "Sigarda, Crazy Bird Lady."
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I have no problem with malapropism. Mistaking words for other words can be comical, and often hilarious. I like the way words sound, and sometimes changing just one word in a sentence or phrase can be costly, or cause infectious laughter. Just ask the folks who created "Damn You AutoCorrect!"
Anywho, my personal favorite Magic malapropism is "Baklava Reaches," which is what I've learned to affectionately call "Lavaclaw Reaches" because my friends sometimes get dyslexic and have a taste for Greek pastries.
In my neck of the woods though, Bruna is named after her corresponding PowerPuff Girl, Bubbles. I'd printed up the whole squad and presented them to some players in the area with various versions of the team, for fun and local blog networking/marketing. Hopefully, it's paying off.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
Pop culture isn't everyone's strong suit, but it happens to be one that I share with UL. Bruna/o Mars is a much more nickname for this place and time in which we live. Even if you aren't into pop music he did perform at the Superbowl, which is one of the most watched television events of the year, every year.
I wouldn't call someone boring though, that is just rude.
UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
When I was hanging out with my friends at Theros prerelease, I started calling him, "The Burger King" because of how fun and creepy and worthless this card is. Though he is still a seldom talked about part of Magic for now, the name has stuck and so has an insatiable craving for breakfast every time I talk about it. Or maybe it's... brains?
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I can definitely see this catching on, although the low playability and general unpopularity of this color combo is likely to limit the infection rate. He even looks like The King. No not Elvis you annoying- SO ANYWAY. I used to love those silly Burger King commercials where The King would run around committing cheeky shenanigans. Too bad Burger King and the Murder King are so awful. Well, at least they have something in common.
Side Note: Why do some activated abilities function in the graveyard and some don't? I am not a big fan of rules, but I truly despise exceptions. Having a case-by-case standard for this type of thing really rubs me the wrong way.
Well, that about wraps 'er up.
If you guys have nicknames, be sure to share them with us in the comments below.
Happy Norse Apocalypse day.
-UL/VJ/GG
The Stack returns this week with a fun pastime GG and I used to have back when we were playing on the regular- the Nickname game.
Having so many cards in the format means we get the wonderful opportunity to continue to enjoy making new names as well as continuing to keep alive those made-up names from competitive decks of the past.
Nicknaming cards is one of the many ways I'm able to gratify good ones, excite mediocre ones, and convince myself that playing bad ones are totally worth it. They come from all different facets of humor tactics and pop culture, and I tend to think it's a key tactic in helping me to maintain my competitive edge while remaining not too serious.
So we're going to share some of our more recent nomenclature with you. This is it!
GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
The Convertible Turtle. And really, what else would you even call him? This definitely isn't my favorite nickname, but a good one nonetheless, though this is surely my favorite Turtle. Even as a Pauper-only playable, this is still by far the best Turtle ever printed. Speaking of which, why no love for the Turtle tribe? What's up with that Wizards?
From a flavor perspective this card is total nonsense. A gigantic turtle would not exactly be an effective hunter. In fact there is no way something this big could reasonably survive in a desolate environment like a desert or salt flat. There just isn't enough food. And if anything it would most certainly be an herbivore and thus, there wouldn't be much of a need for all the snapping - the plants don't run away.
I have to confess I am a pretty savage abuser of card nicknames. Understanding my speech during a game of Magic is practically impossible because of all the shortcuts, nicknames, and inside jokes. It's like I am talking in nerd code. My pen name for this very blog is a direct port of a card nickname. Bonus points if you know what it is. Hint: it was featured in the now derelict "Super Secret Sunday" series.
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Interesting language for sure, but I like the image evoked a lot more. What would a turtle do with the top down, cruising down the street? Would he look for other chick turtles? Would he feel nervous and naked? I don't know what to do if philosophy and science can't answer my questions.
Anyway, I keep finding myself trying to make "Convertible" and "Turtle" rhyme, but mostly because it makes me feel like a little kid again, bashing action figures together on the floor of my little playroom growing up. That's a little memoir-y, but I kind of have history slingin' Turtle around back in Zenny (slang for Zendikar; be hip even if you aren't folks), when I didn't care about rarity, and lands seemed to drop from the sky whenever I wanted. Now, I have days where I can't seem to hit any lands, and my collection of Calcite Snappers were handed down to my brother.
VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK
Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Call me boring, but I usually refer to Bruna here as "Light of Abra Kadabra." It makes sense, no? She's somewhat of an enchantress, so the name fits the kind of spellcasting/spell inclusion you see in most decks that utilize this angel.
Interestingly, I've never put her at the forefront of a deck. She currently resides in my Rafiq of the Many deck alongside her sister "Sigarda, Crazy Bird Lady."
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
I have no problem with malapropism. Mistaking words for other words can be comical, and often hilarious. I like the way words sound, and sometimes changing just one word in a sentence or phrase can be costly, or cause infectious laughter. Just ask the folks who created "Damn You AutoCorrect!"
Anywho, my personal favorite Magic malapropism is "Baklava Reaches," which is what I've learned to affectionately call "Lavaclaw Reaches" because my friends sometimes get dyslexic and have a taste for Greek pastries.
In my neck of the woods though, Bruna is named after her corresponding PowerPuff Girl, Bubbles. I'd printed up the whole squad and presented them to some players in the area with various versions of the team, for fun and local blog networking/marketing. Hopefully, it's paying off.
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
Pop culture isn't everyone's strong suit, but it happens to be one that I share with UL. Bruna/o Mars is a much more nickname for this place and time in which we live. Even if you aren't into pop music he did perform at the Superbowl, which is one of the most watched television events of the year, every year.
I wouldn't call someone boring though, that is just rude.
UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
When I was hanging out with my friends at Theros prerelease, I started calling him, "The Burger King" because of how fun and creepy and worthless this card is. Though he is still a seldom talked about part of Magic for now, the name has stuck and so has an insatiable craving for breakfast every time I talk about it. Or maybe it's... brains?
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I can definitely see this catching on, although the low playability and general unpopularity of this color combo is likely to limit the infection rate. He even looks like The King. No not Elvis you annoying- SO ANYWAY. I used to love those silly Burger King commercials where The King would run around committing cheeky shenanigans. Too bad Burger King and the Murder King are so awful. Well, at least they have something in common.
Side Note: Why do some activated abilities function in the graveyard and some don't? I am not a big fan of rules, but I truly despise exceptions. Having a case-by-case standard for this type of thing really rubs me the wrong way.
Well, that about wraps 'er up.
If you guys have nicknames, be sure to share them with us in the comments below.
Happy Norse Apocalypse day.
-UL/VJ/GG
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)