Tuesday, June 11, 2013

UL's "Better" Deckbuilding: Bruna's Bad Brother

We're pretty tongue-in-cheek this week with a deck I'm messing around with, so if you don't like articles about playing for fun, go deflate your neighbor's wacky-waving-inflatable-arm-flailing-tube-man or something.

Cause I'm gonna talk about Dollar General today. For those who don't know, "Dolla G" is a format GG and I designed last year for newer players or people who prefer to play on the cheaper side of Magic in a casual way.

Dollar General gets its name from the fact that your Commander has to cost less than a dollar, and your deck in total has to cost less than $40, using the lowest calcuated price for a deck on the TCGplayer deck calculator via TappedOut.

Essentially, the idea was to create a challenge for players who spend money and get bored, as well as allow newer players a chance to compete under the umbrella of fun nonsense. By creating a salary cap, it allows us to not exclude cards directly, but to force a player to consider different options, or play bad cards they really like.

There are a lot of hilarious things I've seen recently in my group. The creativity is at an all-time high, and I'm super-impressed. We have all kinds of decks, ranging from Volrath "Voltron" to Sensei Golden-Tail Tribal "Samurai." We even have a bold Homura "Dudes" deck that can support an Umezawa's Jitte. Because that's how "Homie" plays it. Big Budget Bling and big 3/1 and 4/1 dudes with first strike.

Hopefully, I'll have the chance to talk about these decks in the future. Cause they're fun, cool, and it's quite bit of Battlecruiser Magic going on. 

Today though, we're gonna talk about Bruna's half-brained older brother, Hakim.

This is a deck I put together because I wanted to have a little more casual fun than I do with my other Dollar General deck, Green Eggs and Glissa.

Unlike Glissa T's, who's all about engines and little baby artifact triggers, Hakim is one of my more strange EDH decks.

Like Bruna, he's trying to salvage the non-value granted by Auras, and he does this at a pretty hefty rate.

Cause Bruna's ability triggers, and you get to cast a bunch of stuff, even if it isn't yours, for free, while Hakim is limited by time and cost. Because we have to squeeze all of the Voltron-ing in at upkeep, and hope by the time we go to combat that he's not dead.

Although it may not look like it, letting Hakim resolve for a turn in play can prove to be just as devastating as Bruna with a graveyard full of stuff, despite his horrible mechanics.

The good news is that you can trigger his ability in response to triggering his ability- as long as you have the mana to pay for it.

I did mention this was silly, right?

Although it may seem fairly ridiculous to do this, even try to play this deck, I have to say this deck has some surprising trickiness and resiliency.

And as always, I wanna talk about his tech.

I'm quite the Traitor to myself for playing
this card, I know. It's for the right reasons
though, I assure you.
So yeah, I'm playing with some evil magic. I know it isn't exactly a secret that this card is pretty incredible, and neither is my previously expressed distaste. My hatred for Treachery was fairly well documented here on a very angry segment of The Stack, so you know that I'm not a fan of this card.

HOWEVER...

To demonstrate that I am in fact a grown-ass man who knows how to keep his enemies closer, and who can effectively show people how to re-purpose cards that already have insane value, I am running this in Hakim.

There are many ways I can justify playing it and still being able to sleep at night, so let's talk about that a little bit.

Treachery's here, simply, so that I'm not tapped out when I enter my main phase. Having to do a lot of work in my upkeep usually means that I'm spent by the time I enter combat.

While taking other people's stuff is always a primary option, I've never been one to slam a card in a deck simply because I can do one thing with it. Treachery is great to play on Hakim cause it can also help him get pumped with Auramancer's Guise, which is pretty nice considering Hakim only has 2 power.

Combos on top of combos. That's why Treachery is actually useful in the deck, and slightly more creatively used.

Another goofy fun card I've enjoyed is Puca's Mischief.

I picked up a copy a month or so ago when I was building Braids, and ended up cutting enchantments.

So when I was looking for a few final pieces to test Hakim, I slotted it in.

I've had a couple games where this card has just been hilarious good fun. One of the cool tech things you can do with it is exchange creatures for Auras that are already enchanting your own creatures, effectively making Puca's Mischief a 2-for-1 machine that triggers on upkeep.

It's pretty cool. Not a great card, but goes along with my theme, and I think it helps to illustrate the kind of nonsense I'm playing.

If the last card didn't give you an idea of the crazy stuff I'm playing, then Thran Golem sure will.

I've gotten him out once or twice with some enchantments on him, and it's not good. At all. I mean, it's not good for your opponents!

Thranny's one of those cards that you get to play and make people laugh. It's one of the silliest cards I've  played in recent memory, and I have to admit I kinda love it, even though I have no idea why a metal creature would find extra strength from being enchanted.





On the other hand, this is a card I expect most people to start playing, if they aren't playing it already.

Bruna and Hakim get to see a lot of enchantments if you're trying to combo out right, so it should be pretty easy to combine our Researchers with an Eldrazi Conscription and swing fairly quickly.

Casting free Auras in Hakim is non-existent without this guy, and he can create even more consistency in Bruna, especially with tutors and all the white enchantments you can find. This card is awesome, and dirt cheap. So play it.

See also- Iridescent Drake. Cause when your Researchers die, you can re-use your enchantments again.

I helped one of the guys in my playgroup build a Rafiq Enchantment Voltron deck some months back now, and that was the first time I actually read this card.

The Magemarks, on the whole, aren't so great. I can admit that.

Still, this card is actually fairly filthy in Hakim. Since I'm biding my time in this deck until the day I can slam Hakim and win, enchanting Looters and little disruption gremlins like Cephalid Constable are part of my strategy.

With Magemark, turning Hakim into an unblocked machine without Tricks of the Trade is possible. I can set up a strategy before I really set up a victory. And let's face it- most people don't play Defender.dec, though I can't say I haven't seen them.

And I saved my favorite card for last.

When they first came out with this card in Innistrad, I thought it might be a thing for people, with all the flashbacking that was happening, and all the Snapcasters floating around.

Regardless, the Mirror-Mad man has had a home in a couple decks I've played in EDH. I ran him in a Damia deck I was playing last fall where I'd mill myself into Worm Harvest with a bunch of lands and other graveyard recursion.

It's actually a really great card for Bruna, Mimeoplasm (hashtag, eww don't do it, you've got so much to live for), and here in Hakim. If you're playing big graveyard decks, I'd recommend him. He's awesome, and he really is that all-in kinda fun, if that's what you're into.

If you want to take a look at the rest of my list, here's the link:

Hakim Loreweaver Dollar General EDH

It's still a work in progress, so suggestions are welcome. I'm not sure what I'm going to do with it yet, or if it's going to stay together for a long time, but I've been having fun, and I guess that's all that really matters.

Stay tuned for Johnny Confidant on Thursday, the Stack on Saturday, and ol' Gramps on Sunday.

Thanks For Watching.

-UL
















Sunday, June 9, 2013

In General: The Dreaded Ban List Article Part 3

Well hey there neighbor! Welcome back to the final segment of my long awaited discussion of the ban list. Throughout the parts of this series I have been taking a comprehensive look at the "Official" Commander banned list. In part 1, we took a look a the function the Rules Committee serves, the necessity of a banned list, and how your playgroup can make these decisions for themselves. In part 2, we took a look at the cards on the banned list, the reasons they were banned, and I weighed in on whether or not I thought a ban was justified. Today in the ultimate segment I will discuss the few reasons that I think are acceptable for banning cards in Commander and what cards I think need to be removed from the format.

Reason Number 1: Precedent from the DCI
As I mentioned in the previous parts, the DCI and Wizards' Organized Play collect and analyze a ton of information about event attendance, product sales, and top 8 results. Combine that with Wizards internal marketing research and now you have a lot of information to make predictions and decisions about the health of a format and the pros/cons of a ban. I will take this opportunity to reiterate that the Commander RC does not even come close to this level of analysis.

With that in mind, it makes some sense to trust the DCI's decisions about what cards can create an unhealthy format. At the very least it is a logical alternative to simply trusting the RC. The DCI's process is more scientific and they are much more capable of making decisions on an evidentiary basis.

This is all to say: if it is banned in Legacy, there is a legitimate argument for banning it in Commander. As I have previously discussed, I hate drawing lines in the sand. I will avoid doing it whenever possible because opinions differ so greatly between people. If a line must get drawn, do it in the most logical place and don't get bogged down in the details. So I would recommend banning ALL the cards on the Legacy banned list, even if some of them don't seem like much of a problem in Commander.

The Legacy Banned List is a bit extensive and can be viewed here: Check it out

Reason Number 2: Interacting Strangely Deck Construction
Because of the specific restrictions of a highlander format, the requirements of having Legendary creatures be included and constantly available, and the non-standard beginning life total some cards vary in function in Commander. Note: this is not an argument based on power level. I don't think any of these cards should be banned on that basis. We are attempting to set a precedent here. Do not allow cards whose functionality is changed by the rules of the format, whether that change is positive or negative.

This list of cards includes: Serra Ascendent, Felidar Sovereign, Test of Endurance, Tsabo Tavoc, Empress Galina, Karakas, Battle of Wits, and if not playing with sideboards: all of the Wish cards and Spawnsire of Ulamog. (There could be other things like these, I am only human, and only one human at that so I beg forgiveness if I have left anything important out)

An important point to be made here is that I categorically do not condone the idea of psuedo-errata-ing cards just so that they work in EDH. E.g. Serra Ascendent 'turns on' at your initial life total plus ten or Phage, the Untouchable doesn't make you lose if it is your general.

Aaaaaand that is really it. I don't think anything is too powerful or too little fun. Those are too subjective, too personal of criteria to make 'official' decisions about.

If you stuck with me through all three parts of this diatribe then you are a true Zoner, you have my thanks, and you deserve a medal. Next week I will be back to my old grind. Who knows, I may even put up a Super Secret Sunday.

Saturday, June 8, 2013

The Stack #13: Tokes My Goats

We've arrived at the lovely weekend again Zoners, so it's time to Stack it up once more with me and my ragtag team of Magic writers and enthusiasts.

Today it's all about the wonderful world of tokens.

One of the unique facets of the EDH table is that you can rock pimp nonsense tokens like this obligatory South Park character.

I really like this part of Commander, and so we've got a lot of neat other tokens to share with you from across the interwebz from more prominent Magic Community members like Inkwell Looter, to people who just like to turn various cards into Bear tokens.


Anyway, let's get started.


GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK



Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
These tokens are by Inkwell Looter. He makes funny posts on his blog and tumblr, usually featuring tongue-in-cheek humor and cool little pictures. Occasionally he will put his art into pdf format so you can print them out in the correct size! Like this set of 13 individual zombie tokens for Army of the Damned. Sweet.  Definitely check his stuff out. Honorable Mention: Jace the Bear Sculptor:

 Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
Making 13 individual zombie tokens takes a lot of time and effort, and Inkwell Looter, I'm glad you can put that much time and effort into making custom Army of the Damned tokens. Would have liked to have seen more Deadite-looking artwork, however.

Uncle Landdrops- THIRTEEN THUMBS UP
Inkwell comes up with awesome stuff. I've actually made a majority of the things that he's posted, of which my favorite is probably the drunk Faerie token he made for Bitterblossom.

Aside from the Zombies, one of the other cool things about his other tokens is that they can almost be multi-functional. Cause the 0/1 Plants could be Saprolings, and the Eldrazi Spawn could be Germs. So seriously, print them and play with them. You won't be sorry.

 Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
I love that Jace-bear. almost as much as I love the Hamster of the Fells. This guy has some cool artwork.

UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK

Uncle Landdrops-  THUMBS UP
Because I believed LSV can actually do anything, he did. These Channel Fireball tokens are the easiest to use, and they're a lot of fun because I find looking at traditional Magic tokens to be pretty boring. I'd rather play games with real people. Because of the nature of my decks, LSV ends mostly being a 3/3 Beast or Frog Lizard, I've found.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS NEUTRAL
Unfortunately I don't know of CFB or LSV. Probably because I haven't really followed a pro tour. Still, using a pro tour player as a token seems good.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
CFB is sweet. LSV is one of my favorite players to watch/listen to. He is a consummate pro, probably a nice guy, and a shoe-in for the Hall of Fame. He totally deserves a token. You know who did the art for this? Inkwell Looter. Like a champ. 

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP(?)
Wouldn't summoning a professional MTG player technically count as a Planeswalker?

JOHNNY CONFIDANT'S PICK
Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
I like this little guy, I don't have a card that makes him but he's on the inside of my jewel case. I kind of want to derp him out and put googly eyes on him.

Uncle Landdrops- SQUIRREL HIGH-FIVE
While I wish they'd filled this one out a little more, this guy looks pretty desperate for some gratitude. I'll bite.


Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
This squirrel is pretty ridiculous.  He looks like a Rafiki style animal shaman guy thing. He is communing with his super sweet squirrel gods. GatheringMagic.com is also sweet for spoilers and such. Like this token, they are also brought to you by coolstuffinc.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
There aren't enough cards in the world that make squirrel tokens, and one day, squirrel decks should be more overpowered than elf decks, only much less annoying and something that I can actually appreciate playing.


VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
I've been quite puzzled by the distinct lack of unicorn creatures in MTG, and I figured that there should be another version of Storm Herd for unicorns, or an equine version of Bestial Menace that puts out a 1/1 Unicorn with Vigilance, a 1/1 Pegasus with Flying, and a 2/2 Horse on the battlefield. Make it a 3W sorcery called "Crusaders Assemble."

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS (I Have Them)
I could see another Un-set making unicorns and the "My Little Pony" creatures are something I've seen in play before.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS INDIFFERENT
I wouldn't play this, but any time we can put Lisa Frank-level girl nonsense on the table, I'm down. I like jokes.


Grandpa Growth- THUMBS DOWN
Unicorns are silly. My little pony is doubly silly. I share Hircine's stance on unicorns: Kill on sight.

BUT WAIT- THERE'S MORE!!!

Wild Pokemon Tokens Appeared!




These Star Wars tokens will help you shoot first, Tokie-Wan Kenobi.

 

































Some iconic badasses.


 




































AND MOAR BEARS!!! NO ONE EXPECTS THE SECOND (and 3rd and 4th and so on) BEAR! ALL BEAR EVERYTHING!!!


And of course, G.O.B. (pronounced 'Jobe') Because I'm not gonna get much further in my life without an Arrested Development reference. 

Well, that's all I got for today.


Till then...If you find yourself in trouble...

 









                                 Also: Beware of the Bear-pocalypse.
                                                                      -UL

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Top's down // Bottoms Up : Budget Utility Pt.3

Welcome back to the final installment of Budget Utility. You may have seen these on the table or you may use them in your meta. if you do not, and the card fits, go ahead and give these guys a try for less than $1.50.

Today I cover the final three parts, Enchantments, Instant, and Sorcery, Lets get started!

~Enchantments~

- Frozen Aether - Planar Chaos -

Blind Obedience's cheap CMC and Extort trigger might edge Aether out if you have to cut cards, but if you're looking to slow the game down, this does great work.

Shutting down haste and tempo plays are pretty huge. Griefer decks with Hate-Bears like Hokori, Dust Drinker provide a nice redundant synergy that has good strategy.

- Vicious Shadows - Shards of Alara -
Warstorm Surge has nothing on this card.

Don't get me wrong, Surge is good but Vicious Shadows allows for more flexibility. When combined with global draw spells you can end the game even faster. Imagine playing with VS and Forced Fruition. VS counteracts the negative of opponents drawing more answers into limiting their kill spells.

On the other hand, just using VS as a deterrent for kill spells and board sweeps make players hold onto them until absolutely necessary.

Its downside? It's a 7 cost which makes it a heavy investment so building around the ability is kind of necessary. Give it a try, put in some sac outlets, kill spells and group hug draws and turn this enchantment into a game ender!

- Ceta Sanctuary - Apocalypse - Don't let the uncommon fool you- This card operates at a rare level. Everyone is excited for Sylvan Library, Sensei's Top, Phyrexian Arena and Scroll Rack for card draw, but I like my Ceta Sanctuary.

For its colors it's really not that big of a deal, It's a blue card but really it's Blue/Red/Green due to its effect so it's a real niche card. so why is it here? It's Sylvan Library with a discard but you still get your draw step. so you're still netting 2 cards a turn but seeing three and thinning out your deck of choices you don't need. Discard in these colors is not that bad. Eternal Witness likes this party, as does Archaeomancer, Mnemonic Wall, Anarchist, and Charmbreaker Devils. Second this card is dirt cheap, we're talking $0.25 max. Some copies of Sylvan Library can cost up to 100 times more than this card. So if you play Riku, Intet, Maelstrom Wanderer or Animar, try it out. It's a much cheaper option.

- Mind Slash - 8th ed. - Once again another Uncommon playing the rare game. Mind slash is similar to its stronger counterpart Attrition. However, the ability to force discard any card is much better off than a non-black creature killer.

Now how do we maximize the potential with this card? Reanimator generals! Karador and Chainer love to put creatures in the graveyard but adding more targets, especially tasty bombs that are just sitting in a players hand really add to the value of the effect the card brings. What happens if the player doesn't have anything worth reanimating? counters and answers are usually good targets for the effect. No matter what card you have them discard it's always a good thing. The less a player has in hand, the less you have to worry about.

Of course Mind Slash also needs synergy for it to be more than just an occasional discard. Mono Black can create plenty of sac bait, so pair this with Mimic Vat and an ETB/LTB creature for maximum potential.

~Instant~

- Signal the Clans - Gatecrash - This card mixes the Green basic creature tutor spell with Gamble. You get to pick three creatures and randomly get one of them. Going random in EDH is an uncommon tactic that sees play with anyone who uses Cascade, Genesis Wave, Deadbridge Chant, and Guided Passage (read more in Sorcery).

How can this card be of use in EDH you ask? Normally what I choose is three creatures that change the board-state. For example, with my Animar deck I could search up Seedborn Muse, Deadeye Navigator, and Prime Speaker Zegana. No matter how you do it, there's plenty of ways to build around this card so that it always gives you what you need when you need it.

- Beast Within - New Phyrexia -
When it comes to destruction spells, green normally deals with artifact and enchantment removal. Flavor-wise, green wants to return to nature and grow. Cards like Acidic Slime, Terastodon, Sylvan Primordial, and Woodfall Primus can take care of many threats that your opponents have.

What's hard for Green is creature removal. I talked about the fight mechanic on part one with Ulvenwald Tracker, that's a recent addition to Green and it has worked really well in flavor with green. This card is in good flavor with Pherexia's influence on Green by creating new life or as they call it, "Perfecting life," and this card is perfect.

- Fact or Fiction - Invasion -
It is no surprise that I'd put this card on a list of strong cards for cheap. This is another powerful uncommon that can net you a nice pile of cards.

If you play politically, this card can give you an edge if you have an ally for the time being, they can give you a good set-up but have the knowledge of what's in store for the next few plays. Without an ally, this card forces your opponent to make a hard decision based on the top five of your deck of what they would rather you have versus what they think you would go for.

The main drawback to this spell is that no matter what pile you pick, your opponents know what's going into your hand. The key to this card can be unlocked by adding recursion and choosing wisely who makes your piles.

- Reiterate - Time Spiral -
I've talked a little about Buyback spells in past articles and they are one of my favorite spell mechanics. This is simply described as a Reverberate that you can use as many times as you are able to.

While there are a small handful of other spells, enchantments, artifacts and creatures that allow for spell copying, why would I single out Reiterate? Let's break down the two groups.

Group A: "Copy target spell you control" - These are narrow and only allow you to double up on spells you cast, so adding a copy spell to it is a lot like the "Replicate" mechanic the Izzet guild had in Ravnica 1.0. "Replicate" allowed you to multiply one spell as many times as you could keep paying the cost for it for example Train of Thought is 1U to draw a card, pay it again and you draw 2 and so on. These were good for "Storm" decks due to you creating a longer chain of "Storm" effects to trigger.

Group B: "Copy Target Spell" -  You now have the freedom to take advantage of opponent's spells along with your own. I wouldn't go so far as to say that this is better or necessary for EDH decks that don't have access to mana ramp spells, but it sure helps and the advantages don't end there. Copying big spells like an Entwined Tooth and Nail, Kicked Comet Storm, or a Fused Breaking // Entering spell not only allows you to use the spell first, but keeps the pressure on by disallowing a player to get ahead of the game.

~Sorcery~

- Guided Passage - Apocalypse -
Fact or Fiction allows for your to gain off the top five, but with Guided Passage you can hand your deck over to an opponent and ask them to tutor for three for you. Used in the right way this can net you some fairly nasty cards that you'd want to have.

I have gone wrong with this card and my friend handed me a fetch land, mana ramp spell, and a mana dork creature. This was in no way helpful and not good late game. I learned that to play with this spell, I needed to build around it so that it is effective no matter when you draw it.

I use this in my Animar deck fairly successfully. By narrowing the options for useless non-creature, non-targets, I was able to leverage better card advantage.

Here are 3 questions to ask yourself if you want to make this card useful.
1) If I play this will it net me an advantage?
2) Do I have subtle yet good targets for the spell that will force my opponent to accidentally select them?
3) Do I mind revealing my entire library?
Chances are if even two of three are a yes this card can be of use for you.

- Wargate - Alara Reborn -
Green can find creatures, white can find equipment, artifacts, enchantments, and blue can find instant's, artifacts, and sorcery. When you combine the best of all three you're ready for the Wargate.

Simple and sweet, this card fits in Bant and five color decks. A word of advice about this, players love to drop a copy spell on Wargate, so try to play it with an answer so that only you profit!

- Praetor's Grasp - New Phyrexia -
What's interesting about Grasp is you exile the card but you still have to pay for the cost. Most of the time if your opponent knows his or her library by heart they can deduce what you took. This means that you should choose a card you can use, but not hold on too long to it. Another route to take with this card is to cut off a spell that you might lose too.

Personally I enjoy revealing my own library to my opponents as much as I like looking through them but I also understand that people value secrecy in competitive situations. Still, give this guy a try and see what you can pull off at your opponents expense.

- Molten Disaster - Future Sight -
X Spells can be dangerous, Especially if someone copies a high X burn spell like a previously mentioned Comet Storm. Molten Disaster was, and still is, in my opinion, the better version.

Split-second, for those who haven't come across this, is a mechanic that prevents further spells or abilities from adding to the spell stack essentially resolving the spell(s). The advantage to this is to avoid counter spells, spell triggers, and copy spells from raining on your parade. Now unlike Comet storm, Molten Disaster won't end the game as fast and it's not as discriminate as CS either so this card could come down to a Meta choice.

For those who use red but don't care about taking a few for the team for the safety of the split second, this card is your burn spell. Sprinkle some damage doubling or damage prevention for yourself and you're good as gold.

Well that's all for the three part Budget Utility series. I plan on having something similar again so stay tuned. Until next time Zoners, I wish you good luck on your Modern Master's Packs.

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

UL's Favorites: Save The "Red's" For Last

We're wrapping up this long-going favorites series with your favorite stepchildren at the EDH table.

Making a list for red creatures isn't so easy. Cause honestly, most red creatures aren't as good as Duplicant or Steel Hellkite.

So mostly, picking out mountain mana dudes is a lot like that ancient maxim, "In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king."

Also, red lends itself to some pretty niche-y archetypes. Not every card is going to be "universally good" in this color.

But I tried to get close. I've got some surprises, some Goblins, and some pretty obvious staples. And in the words of that guy who owns Men's Wearhouse, "You're gonna like what you see."

So let's count 'em down. 


10.Butcher Orgg
Right off the bat I've got something not quite so obvious. I know it should probably be something else, but I couldn't pass up the opportunity to talk about such a unique card, and one that I really like quite a bit, even though if you think it probably shouldn't be here.

I'll try to make a case for it anyway. a 7 for 6/6 is way too fair for anyone these days, so let's skip down to this unsettling-yet-carnal illustration by Kev Walker.

Any of you cool kids familiar with Batman: The Animated Series? If you're not, then all you see is an Orgg, or what's supposed to be an Orgg.

However, when I look at this, all I see is a much more sickly and wing-less version of the dreaded Man-Bat! 


There is family resemblance here. I know it.
Obviously, they had to clean Man-Bat up a little for kids, but they just feel so connected I can't stop thinking about it. And I love that.

Moving further along, we get to the real uniqueness of Butcher Orgg, which is his sweet triggered ability. Have you ever wanted to kill six tokens at once? Do you have rampant Hexproof dudes like Uril Miststalking their way through your metagame? This is not a problem for Butcher Orgg. An untargetable damage trigger means he can be removal or a big six points of damage to your opponent's braincage. Obviously, there are some better value dudes here, one of which is on this list, but still. Isn't Butcher Orgg just super lovable? I want to give him a big 'ol hug, no matter what his flavor text says. 


                                                                                                9.Siege-Gang Commander
Our Siege-Gang friends see the obvious pick in sight, even though they know it's clearly them.

There's a lot to like about this four pack of Goblins. The flavor is really neat for one, and for a bunch of mana, you can effectively do quite a bit of damage with these guys. 


I don't know why anyone would leave home without them, really. They're one of the most versatile sets of Goblins you'll ever meet, cause they work either with friends or on their own.

This card represents Wizards getting something right, which is why it's been reprinted a couple times since it was released in Scourge.


8.Hero of Oxid Ridge
Surprise pick No.2 was fairly unexpected, even for me. I thought that I'd just slam Zealous Conscripts in here and call it a day.

The more I thought about that, the more it didn't feel quite right.

Red Hero hasn't seen nearly as much acclaim as ol' Bladehold, and I get that. Bladehold puts a bunch of power on the field. O-Ridge doesn't. Bladehold has a big booty. O-Ridge doesn't.

I'm aware of the weaknesses, but that's not why we pick cards to put in decks. O-Ridge found a home in Animar a while back, and I've been pretty excited, cause I really like hosing token players and creatures with defender. I think Pillow-Fort strategies are mostly nonsensical, and O-Ridge gets me some serious ground in the world of Animar. He's a great support card, providing pumps for the team, and he's got haste, which I can't say is a common thread of a lot of my creatures in there, unless Wanderer's out, and I'm probably a step away from winning the game.

I don't tutor for Hero, and I probably never will if you've ever seen this list. But he's great to cast and gives Animar quite a bit of extra upside. Great? No. Underrated? Absolutely.


7.Stigma Lasher
Ghost Rider here is pretty cool. I have had a lot of fun when this guy in my opener. Not being able to gain life has proven to be useful in some decks, and is essential in something like my Hidetsugu deck, where I don't want a person to gain a bunch of life back after I've Shiva-Blasted a couple times. Unless, of course, that person's me.

Wither isn't all that irrelevant either. Later on, I like to use Lasher as a chump block for someone's bigger guy to control the damage I take from the hate I draw with HH.

If you're playing Aggro, I think Lasher's a nice one. If you're looking for a more controlled Sulfuric Vortex, this is a good one too.






6.Instigator Gang // Wildblood Pack
Even as lowly humans, the Instigator Gang is nothing to scoff at. Animar loves casting these guys for R and getting a little extra damage. With the quantity of creatures I play, it's common to net 5 or 6 extra damage with just this one guy.

Then, when I get to flip him, the abuse gets worse. 


Wildblood Pack
 








As part of the Wildblood Pack, the damage gets bigger, Trample is involved, and I now have a fearless wolfpack with one united 5/5 P and T. While I do wish that this Werewolf thing was just a card by itself, this is one flip card that I've actually enjoyed playing, and so I'm signing a special release form so that everyone can play this card, free from judgment and the previous boycott against flip-cards other than Angry Garruk.


5.Hellrider
I was really excited about this card when it got spoiled, and I'm glad I finally got a copy of it.

This is more Red card design I can get behind. The design space is here, and it's happening.

One of the best parts about Hellrider is the fact that it influence blocking and can change the game in a turn.

Forcing your opponent to have to block Hellrider to avoid taking future damage is fairly painful in EDH when the "night is dark and full of terrors."

I've played him with only a handful of dudes in a deck, and though less potent, he still got the job done. Again, Animar makes this guy a beating and a half, cause it's a beating on its own.


                                                                                                4.Keldon Firebombers
Certain cards were not designed or intended for EDH, and I'm sure "Jaeg-uh-Bombz" here wasn't one of them.

I discovered this card doing research for Oros, and I'll never forget the first time I slammed it in a game. It was around Turn 7, and everyone was just kinda looking at me, like, "What just happened? Is this a card? Are you making shit up?"

This card is the business. It's possibly one of my favorite red creatures, and I don't get to play it too often, which is a bummer. Cause I love big mana.

I don't get the flavor, or anything really from a design perspective about this card (maybe someone will enlighten me?), but I will continue to try and cram this card into decks whenever I can. It's stupid good.


3.Viashino Heretic
Viashino Heretic is a pretty huge game. I've found playing Heretic is actually more like playing Gaddock Teeg for artifacts than doing what he actually does, but whatever. He definitely looks like a rattlesnake, so being a rattlesnake card isn't so bad.

Heretic, in my mind is clearly the frontrunner for artifact removal on a stick, though he doesn't have much competition outside of Mox Monkey and Chandler/Joven. But friends, Chandler is there for you if you need him.

Red also has lots of ways for Haste, so when I play him he's usually coming out on Turn 5 and shutting off abusive things like Greaves and Swords. I also like to hit artifact lands that aren't Darksteel Citadel.

Mycosynth Lattice can also get him quite a bit more work, so if you're playing combos with that, and you've got red, Heretic is very splashable.

                                                                                               2.Inferno Titan
Obvious card is obvious, obviously. Inferno Titan is just one of those cards you've got to play in Red or you're not gonna get your money's worth.

I included the nice Duels of the Planeswalkers Promo art here for something different, but it doesn't matter which one you're playing. Between him, Duplicant, and Chaos Warp, these are about the only serious spot removal mono-Red has right now, so it's in your best interest to play this guy in everything that isn't a Goblin deck. Sure it's tiresome, not being able to be creative with your threat choices, but I don't know why you'd want to be in Red. Most other things just aren't good, and aren't going to help you in the situations that will come across.

So play your Inferno Titans. It's all you've got.


1.Stingscourger
Short of Kiki-Jiki, meet the best and blue-est Goblin there is- Stingscourger.

Hands down one of my favorite creatures in Red, and one that I would play in every mono-Red deck, and something that can be competitive in making the cut for other decks.

Bouncing Marit Lage tokens is his crowning achievement, but I've also been able to stave off Eldrazi and really influence the tempo of the game to my opponent's surprise with this little nonsense Goblin. He loves the Mimic Vat, and provides his own sac outlet for you. Cause I don't ever recall paying Echo on this. He's a sorcery speed Unsummon for your opponent's biggest creature, it's the best you can get in this color, and I've been able to stave off quite a few turns with him and turn the tempo just enough to squeeze out a W.

That's all I got for today.

We're on the tail end of article wrap-ups this week. Johnny Confidant's finishing up his budget series on Thursday. Be sure not to miss that.

Till then stay sharp by lookin' sharp. 















-UL




 










Sunday, June 2, 2013

In General: The Dreaded Ban List Article Part 2

Quid custodiet ipsos custodes? Today it's me, your old Grandpa Growth, except it is really a bit more like judging the judges, but you get the idea.

Welcome back to part two of my long awaited ban list article. In the first segment, I shared my feelings on what the function of the Rules Committee is as compared to to the function that the DCI and Wizard's Organized Play program serve and I gave you my thoughts on the necessity of a ban list.

In today's segment I will be looking at the cards on the banned list and the reasons they are banned (from what I can piece together from posts on the official site, forums, interviews with members of the RC, and my own speculation where necessary).

Note that I will not be addressing any of the cards on the Commander banned list that are ALSO on the Legacy banned list. Those cards, for various reasons, have an established precedent from the DCI as being bad for formats. Therefore, I am willing to concede that there is an argument for banning them.

I will revisit this issue in a future article and give you my thoughts on how Legacy and Commander differ and what implications it has for those specific cards because I think that is an interesting topic that deserves some discussion.

Due to the size of the Commander banned list, this article will be substantially longer than the previous segment so I ask that you bear with me. Without further ado, let's talk about some cards.

Biorhythm - This is banned because, and I am paraphrasing here: 'instant wins do not conform to the spirit of the format'. There are really two assertions that the RC are making here:
1. Biorhythm is consistent enough and powerful enough as a win condition that it has warped the format, leading to repetitive or abusive gameplay situations.
2. Cards that allow a player to win on the spot, even in multiplayer, such as Biorhythm, are not in keeping with the spirit of the format and should be banned in the interest of format health.

First, I do not feel that Biorhythm fits the definition of a card that has an abusive level of power or consistency. Can you win the game? Sure. I find it a bit unlikely, as you also need some set up; like a board sweeper or a bunch of creatures of your own. It is not like you just cast the card and proceed to the win phase. Also, Green has no way of tutoring a Sorcery, so they are most likely going to have to raw dog the wrath and the Biorhythm. In multicolor decks, tutors can provide access to the different parts of the Biorhythm puzzle and even add disruption to help insure that it resolves, but even in this dream case where you manage to 'have it all' there are still a dozen instant win combos that are easier to pull off. Most don't even require you to resolve a GIGANTIC sorcery, which trust me, is a task against a group of seasoned Commander vets.

This segues well into my next point. If shenanigans like instant win combos are indeed against the spirit of the format, why are the other offenders in this category not banned? This is a glaring inconsistency. Tooth and Nail is just as lethal than Biorhythm, but it is cheaper and also actually does something relevant when you can't insta-win. Felidar Sovereign is in a similar spot and heck, it can even attack. Note: I don't personall believe either of those cards, nor any other sort of instant-win nonsense should be banned.

The banned list page spells out what cards should not be played, but also tacks on a rider that you also shouldn't play "others like them". I won't abide this at all. Such a nebulous statement is simply too soft for an 'official ruling' by an 'official body'. A banned list should not require interpretation. A general guideline of what Sheldon Mennery thinks is un-fun is not sufficient material for the banning of a single card and certainly not an entire family of similar cards.

Verdict: Let my people dance! Unban Bro-rhythm.


Coalition Victory - I can only guess at why this is banned. It is a very similar instant win card, but it is restricted to only 5cc decks, which are admittedly pretty good in Commander, but Coalition Victory is approximately 10 times harder to win with than Biorhythm and I didn't even think that card was good at all. So what do you think I am going to say about this card?

Verdict: The Coalition isn't winning anything. Unban Coalition Victory, unless you agree to ban The Cheese Stands Alone.

Emrakul, the Aeons Torn - This card is certainly very powerful. It can lead to repetitive and abusive gameplay. It is easy to put in play on the cheap. It is tough to answer. The only things I will say in defense of Emmy are that it isn't a sure thing in multiplayer, it is colorless so anybody can fight fire with fire, and lastly there are plenty of other abominable threats that immediately dominate the board (I recommend Ulamog).

Sheldon Mennery mentioned in an interview at a pro tour that this card was banned largely due to the Eldrazis ubiquity in the format. So many people play them that every game had a good shot of ending with an Annihilator trigger regardless of which player, or Commander, was victorious when it was all said and done.

I cannot, CANNOT condone a ban based on ubiquity alone. Everyone is playing it because it is among the best cards in the format. That doesn't make it inherently unhealthy. I also do not condone drawing lines in the sand about an unhealthy power level. Especially without quantitative data proving that the format is suffering due to the influence of one card or strategy (data like the DCI collects constantly). If there must be a power ceiling and you have to make a cut off, then starting at the top seems logical. I'm not going to be happy about it either way, but Emrakul was Commander's big bad, not by much, but maybe that is enough.

Verdict: This is complex. I wouldn't ban Emrakul, but, if it is already banned, AND if there must be a power ceiling, then I recommend leaving Emrakul banned. Put the squid on ice. No sushi today. Keep Emra Watson banned.

Gifts Ungiven - I don't have precise information about why this was banned. If you told me it was banned on the basis of its power level I would grudgingly agree. It is extremely powerful. It is tough to lose after resolving a gifts and, as an instant, it is pretty easy to sneak past people's defenses. If you told me this was banned because of how it interacted with the deck construction rules, I would be inclined to argue the following point: Gifts isn't anymore powerful in a highlander format than it is in Legacy. Playing a deck with Gifts Ungiven carries the price of having a large package of 1-of's to begin with. That is simply how you have to play in order to maximize the effectiveness of the card. In my mind, this is a non-issue. Gifts does interact differently with the rules of Commander (a school of ban logic that I will address at a later date), but not in a significant way.

So, if I wouldn't ban it on the basis of its deck building interactions, I must assume it is banned because it is too powerful. Take a moment to think back to what I said about power level in regards to Biorhythm. Gifts doesn't dominate the format. It doesn't squash fun, limit the variety of viable decks in the format, or prevent creativity in deck building. My final thoughts are again about not wanting to draw arbitrary lines about what is 'too good'. Intuition is legal in Commander and Legacy. It sees only limited play in both formats and is very similar in power level.

Verdict: Take the gifts...and give them back to the people. Unban Gifts Ungiven.

Karakas - This is almost certainly banned because of how favorably it interacts with the myriad legendary creatures running around EDH games. Some decks are built with Commander centric strategies...and because people are reluctant to use land destruction, they can't ever beat Karakas. It is somewhat unfair that no other colors have an equivalent broad format hoser card, but that isn't a reason to ban something, even when it is this powerful. I promised further explanation of why I think it is, in fact, alright to ban cards that interact differently with the unique rules of Commander, but now is not the time for fear...that comes later.

Verdict: Big fan of Venezuelan politics. Not a big fan of Karakan politics. Keep Karakas banned.

Limited Resources - I am told that land destruction, especially mass land destruction, is not in the spirit of the format. I am going to put this simply: That is asinine. Disruption is a key piece of the game's strategy. Is it always fun to play against? Maybe not, but I don't get angry and throw my toys around just because I am only having 75% of the fun I wanted to have. Land destruction is one of the few types of disruption that actually works in favor of aggressive decks. In order for aggressive decks to be competitive in Commander they have to rely on back-breaking disruptive plays; usually something like Mind Twist or Armageddon. Speaking of old geddon: It is just as good as Limited Resources, but no one wants to ban it (although 'geddon is appropriately costed). Are you getting the idea about not drawing lines in the sand? Commander needs good land destruction in order to regain balance as a format.

Verdict: Un-limit the disruption. Learn to use it. As you become a better, more well-rounded player, you will see the wisdom of this decision. Unban Limited Resouces.

Sundering Titan - Look back at what I said about Emrakul and LR. The same arguments were made: over-powered, ubiquitous, against the spirit of the format. I make the same rebuttals: Titan does not substantially affect the metagame, it would continue to be healthy and diverse. There are more powerful threats certainly, but I will concede that Sundering Titan is unique in that is a highly disruptive colorless threat, but again, like Emrakul, everyone can play it. Its power scales down dramatically in 1v1. Ubiquity isn't a reason for a ban. The spirit of the format is limiting the diversity of the format...and is also laughable.

Verdict: Sunder the banlist. Unban Sundering Titan.

Primeval Titan - Sheldon Mennery is on record saying this was banned simply because too many games ended in Titan-vantage. I am flat out unwilling to accept that logic for banning a card. In the same interview, he purported that Sol Ring would never be banned because it is core to the spirit of the format. Sol Ring isn't unfair or ubiquitous at all.

Verdict: If you think this card should be banned you are the primeval one. Unban Primeval Titan.

Painter's Servant - I am grasping at straws trying to think of why this would be banned. It is a second class combo in legacy. It just isn't that good. Colorless or not, this card wouldn't get played. There are dozens of 2-card combos that win the game on the spot and are still legal in Commander. This is hardly worth a ban and I have never heard convincing logic about why this card isn't legal.

Verdict: Unban Painter's Servant. It serves the interest of improving the format.

Panoptic Mirror- I have very similar feelings about this card. A colorless, combo win condition that is barely playable in any other format. This card is significantly more expensive and more difficult to 'go off' with, but it has the added value of generating value in the absence of a combo. Not even close to powerful enough to ban. Do you guys at home seriously lose to this kind of junk? You see it once and you are surprised. The next time you are ready. Gimmick nonsense. This barely qualifies as a strategy. And also, Isochron Scepter is much more difficult to win through.

Protean Hulk - Spoiler: I never observe the official banned list in my normal playgroup. I find the idea patently absurd. I make the rules at my kitchen table and I say anything goes. Whenever I look over the banned list though, usually for the purpose of discussing its patent absurdity, I always laugh at this card. Banning Protean Hulk is like shooting at the Heavy in Team Fortress 2. It is just idiotic. YOU MUST kill the medic first. So I am just going to assume that the RC made a mistake and meant to ban Flash.

Verdict: You wouldn't like the Hulk when he is angry. Ban Flash.

Recurring Nightmare - I assume this was banned because of its power level and favorable interactions with popular threats like Kokusho, and now, the primordial cycle. Much like Emrakul, this feels like an arbitrary ban, but a logical place to draw the line if there must be one. I really don't get it though, isn't everyone packing graveyard hate by now?

Verdict: I don't think the nightmare should ever have ended, but I don't think we should let it recur. Keep Recurring Nightmare banned.

Sway of the Stars / Worldfire - I am just going lump these two together because I don't have anything to say about one that I couldn't say about the other. They are prohibitively expensive sorceries. The literal worst kind of win condition AND they each need additional help to win the game. Most people would think that this is the kind of stereotypical nonsense that Commander is ALL ABOUT! They do immediately warp multiplayer games when they resolve, but if you have 10 lands in play already...well let's just say it is about time things got weird don't you think?

Verdict: I am not starting a fire to ban Warp World or Reverse the Sands. It'd take quite the orator to sway my opinion on this one. Unban these cards.

Yawgmoth's Bargain - This is banned. Necropotence is legal. I swear, sometimes I think this is a joke.

Verdict: Unban Yawgmoth's Bargain before I start making puns.

Griselbrand - I haven't ever heard a member of the RC give a concise explanation of why this card was banned. Most of the conversation revolves around it being too powerful. It is too powerful, but in Commander that can be just as bad for you as it is for them. Bribery is a card. Desertion is a card. Games do tend to end when Grissly Bear hits the board, but not before things get interesting.

Verdict: I have no real opinion and could go either way, but banning a card without a reason is tough for me to chew.

Trade Secrets - Ahh the new guy. To be the hot topic. The villain du jour. Public Enemy #1. Trade Secrets was banned because it encouraged collusion in multiplayer. You don't say. Politics is the ONLY dynamic that sets multiplayer apart from single player games. Isn't that why people play it? If you don't like crony king-making then you shouldn't be entering into the Mexican standoff of multiplayer Commander. Trade Secrets is one of the rare cards that actually allows you to get ahead in a group game. Usually interacting with an opponent means that you are both going to be behind the table. Strip Mine for example. We each lose a land, but everyone else doesn't. If you can consistently convince your opponents to help you discover their trade secrets then you are awesome and deserve to win. This kind of behavior should be encouraged. If you can't stand your playgroup constantly teaming up and leaving you out in the cold then you have a social problem, not a gameplay problem.

Verdict: The secret is out, but the card is in. Victoria says: Unban Trade Secrets.

A quick note about the banned generals: I don't agree with this practice in general. People should be able to play what they want. In a competitive setting though, things change. I agree to bannig generals in that context. And in that context I believe that all 7 Tier 1 generals should be banned: Erayo, Sharuum, Niv-Mizzet, Rofellos, Azami, Braids, and Jhoira. I would also recommend that Edric, Arcum Dagsson, and Blue Braids be banned. It might even be necessary to ban some of the other overplayed 1v1 generals like Venser or Vendilion Clique, but I would need more intel before I commit to that position. This configuration of bans would, based on my logic, maximize the variety of viable generals in the format, but not necessarily the health of the format or the fun of playing it. 

Well, that is all for today youngins'. This was a biggun, but I feel it was worth it. This is a topic that eats up a lot of my time both on the internet and away from the keyboard. I have been itching to pen an article about it for a good bit. Thanks for sticking with me zoners! Make sure to join me next week for the final installment where I will discuss what reasons I think ARE acceptable for banning a card and I will reveal the list of cards that Grandpa thinks should be kept off the kitchen table. Till then, make sure to share your thoughts on the ban list and this article in the comments.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

The Stack #12- Flavor With The Proper Swerve

It's a short sweet Saturday Zoners.

A few weeks ago we did cards we thought had bad flavor, so this week we decided to talk about the ones with that feel-good taste.

Hopefully, this won't be a "#iatethebones" moment. Cause we only like using hashtags in ironic, non-Twitter media. Or, whenever Nick Offerman from "Parks and Recreation" reads tweets from young female celebrities.



Anyway, we've gotta short class today cause I'm hanging out with GG, and we plan on going to do Hood Rat Stuff with some of our friends.

So here's The Stack.

GRANDPA GROWTH'S PICK
Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
Givin' cards the proper flavor swerve? I'm bout it. Cards should make sense. Great cards unite flavor and mechanics in a way that makes sense. True gems occur when said great card is able to elegantly illustrate a piece of the set's narrative story. That is easier said than done, but what the heck? The design team are professionals right? I find it strange that, in my opinion, Red has a highly disproportionate number of proper flavor cards compared to the other colors. Blue cards rarely, if ever, make sense. Lightning bolt and Earthquake though seem to make perfect sense.

Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
This is a board wipe for the ages. At least it doesn't include Planeswalkers and enchantments in its text...

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
I have never seen this card hit play but in the right hands this could just be brutal, If you wanted a boardwipe this is it's definition. this card is great, simple and effective.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS UP
Boardwipes with huge sweeping one-word statements should do exactly what they say regardless of what other people have to say about them. Jokulhaups is still a cooler word though.

UNCLE LANDDROPS' PICK
Uncle Landdrops-   THUMBS UP
While Innistrad, the land of gothic horror, wasn't perhaps the best place to put this particular Clone iteration, it certainly wasn't the worst. He's actually gotten a power-bump now, considering the rules change. He's now the only Clone that actually can kill another Legend.

I like his flavor because he is as humorous as advertised, and he didn't warp the color pie. Also, I didn't quite understand the value of his bonus ability until I started cloning Solemns on the table. Even so, I like the way Evil Twin rewards you for copying your opponent's stuff. Funny, Fun to play, and Functional. This card passes my tests with 3 F's, which is actually a great thing.

Johnny Confidant- THUMBS UP
I had this guy in my old Vela deck before I even had clone and enjoyed his added ability. As UL said, he now got a power-bump which I feel is deserved for this twin. I can't think of any other clone id run in my next U/B/x? deck than this guy.

Grandpa Growth- THUMBS UP
I like to see classic cards get revisited and updated. It is sad to see them get outclassed by shiny new editions, but I can't complain too much about this guy. It's sweet. It does what you think it should do. It calls back to an iconic card. This is a win.

Venser's Journalist-
THUMBS UP

A solid clone-effect indeed, Evil Twin makes perfect sense. Only the evil one would stick a dagger in someone; the flavor text says so! Plus the art on this card almost reminds me of the forty times I've watched Army of Darkness. "You're a goody little two shoes, goody little two shoes..."


VENSER'S JOURNALIST'S PICK


Venser's Journalist- THUMBS UP
The best thing about the Azorius Guild is how satirical it is of the Federal Republic style of governing. No card sums up the legislative branch of government like the Elocutors. In terms of flavor, this reeks of it. Blue is about control and stall; White is about protection and bizzare win conditions. Don't believe me? Felidar Sovereign. Near-Death Experience. Barren Glory. In fact, it's one of my favorite win cons and with enough fog-effects and tempo, this card can be an unstoppable advising force ready to talk the opponents to death. Throw it in an Angus Mackenzie deck and have fun.

Uncle Landdrops- THUMBS DOWN
For a couple of guys who are supposed to be brilliant at speaking and gumming up the Azorius Senate, I'm not sure their voices are loud enough to be doing what they're saying.

I get that this is a slow U/W card. That's fine. It's just not, in my mind, what I would expect a group of people attempting a Filibuster to be doing. The idea of this act is to talk and talk and talk, which will either deadlock legislation or prevent them from doing something before a particular set of rules gets passed. Therefore, this action requires a proactive stance to create inaction.  Mechanically, what I feel Azor's Elocutors actually does is compel your opponent to action whilst you wait to be reactive.


The idea of an alternate win-con is a correct avenue in design. They just didn't get the rest of it right, is all.


Grandpa Growth- THUMB DOWN
I agree with Landdrops. This card is flavorful, but it isn't evocative of the concept it is presenting. A fillibuster would be stalling combat, not getting crushed by it. Check out how Queen Amidala smashes the fillibusting:


I wish I had more to say, but Natalie always seems to know the words that make me stop breathing.

Anyway, Happy June 1st. Now go forth and pretend like you fools never left April.
-UL